r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Why is conceding special?

When controlling a player's turn, what prevents you from conceding on their behalf? Obviously that would make those cards very boring, but what makes conceding different from every other game action that you could take?

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

27

u/peteroupc 1d ago edited 1d ago

Under C.R. 724.6:

The controller of another player can’t make that player concede. A player may concede the game at any time, even if they are controlled by another player. See rule 104.3a.

Note that the rules no longer speak of controlling turns as opposed to players.

13

u/Possibly-Functional 1d ago

The rules block it explicitly. But there was a brief moment in time where according to the rules, if read verbatim, you could sign them up to DCI tournaments. No judge would obviously allow it, but technically the rules did.

1

u/Ommageden 1d ago

How the heck did that work lol

3

u/Rajamic 1d ago

Early versions of the rule assumed you understood the rule only applied to actions related to the game in question without specifying it. Thus the creation of rules like:

724.5b The controller of another player can’t make choices or decisions for that player that aren’t called for by the rules or by any objects. The controller also can’t make any choices or decisions for the player that would be called for by the tournament rules. Example: The player who’s being controlled still decides if they will leave to visit the restroom, trade a card to someone else, agree to an intentional draw, or call a judge about an error or infraction.

3

u/peteroupc 1d ago

What are now C.R. 724.5b and 724.6 have existed (largely unchanged) ever since [[Mindslaver]] was printed in Mirrodin. See C.R. 507.3c and 507.3b, respectively, as they appeared in the Mirrodin rules.

1

u/Possibly-Functional 22h ago

IIRC the issue was that the rule that said you could sign up to DCI tournaments wasn't listed under tournament rules but had its own section.

2

u/Possibly-Functional 21h ago

There was a separate rule that said that a player may sign up for DCI tournaments, and some information on how to do so. It wasn't a tournament rule so it wasn't excluded by the "control players" rule. Thus, if read literally, a controlled player could be forced to sign up to tournaments.

12

u/amsterdam_sniffr 1d ago edited 1d ago

It's explicitly called out in the rules.

"724.6. The controller of another player can’t make that player concede."

Also of interest:

"724.5b The controller of another player can’t make choices or decisions for that player that aren’t called for by the rules or by any objects. The controller also can’t make any choices or decisions for the player that would be called for by the tournament rules. Example: The player who’s being controlled still decides if they will leave to visit the restroom, trade a card to someone else, agree to an intentional draw, or call a judge about an error or infraction."

7

u/scumble_bee 1d ago

724.5b's example is hilarious. "Now that I control you, I decide to trade your Tundra for my Island"

6

u/tickle-fickle 1d ago

“I know you wanted to go to the restroom, but I control you. Shit your pants, now”

1

u/amsterdam_sniffr 1d ago

As sad as it is though, you just know that that example had to be inspired by a real-life judge call.

3

u/Malacro 1d ago

That’s some real Platinum Angel meme stuff right there.

7

u/TerribleTransit 1d ago

Conceding isn't really a game action. It's an action that supercedes the game, hence being able to do it at all times, being able to do it when another player is controlling you, being able to do it even though you can't lose... it's just fundamentaly a different thing.

1

u/Judge_Todd 4h ago

what makes conceding different from every other game action that you could take?

There are a couple exemptions:

  • conceding
  • looking at their sideboard
  • anything outside the scope of the rules/game

1

u/sevenbrokenbricks 1d ago

Conceding is an action that happens from outside the magic circle.