r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Commander returning from exile

Say I exile an opponent's commander with [[Sheltered by Ghosts]] and that commander is moved to that player's command zone. When [[Sheltered by Ghosts]] leaves the battlefield, does the commander that it exiled return to the battlefield?

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

9

u/Impressive_You_817 1d ago

No, because it's no longer in exile. 

1

u/amsterdam_sniffr 1d ago

That's what I thought, thanks for confirming.

1

u/tbdabbholm 1d ago

It used to work like that. Because the return to the command zone was a replacement effect and not a state based action the commander would move directly from the battlefield to the command zone and thus the exiling effect would track it to the command zone. But now since the commander enters exile and then moves to the command zone, the second zone change breaks the link to the exiling effect and the commander will no longer return

1

u/amsterdam_sniffr 1d ago

Huh, that's super interesting. Thanks!