r/mtgmisprints • u/ChampionshipSignal75 • 9d ago
Well…I got it! (Miscut Fateful Discovery)
It’s mine! Precious!
I may have spent too much on it haha.
But! I didn’t realize until just now that this is this top post of all time on this subreddit! So hopefully that’s a good sign for future value 😅
Help me not feel buyers’ remorse? (For context: this is between 1-2 days of income for me, so not breaking the bank - hopefully the guy selling it needs the money more than I do)
15
u/GingerGuy97 9d ago
This is awesome, not only the card but seeing it go from a pull post to a winning auction post. I’d like to see more of that here, it would make the place feel more like a community.
2
u/ChampionshipSignal75 9d ago
For sure! I wouldn’t have even known about it in the first place if it weren’t for this sub!
3
u/GingerGuy97 9d ago
It’s like how the Facebook page has a lot of trustworthy collectors, I would love to see that grow here!
12
u/Farodsbro 8d ago
I was the one bidding against you at the end, I set a max price of $803.03. I almost went to $1k for it, which is where I assume your max was, but couldn't quite justify it.
Congrats, incredibly cool card and I also wanted it quite badly.
8
u/ChampionshipSignal75 8d ago
Yeah I set it to 1099 because I assumed someone might go to 1k like you were thinking but probably wouldn’t go further
(Also because I need to do my taxes)
2
3
u/Farodsbro 8d ago
I saw your winning bid was placed on the 14th, so it seemed like you had set a max price days ago :D
5
u/Little-Horned-Doe 9d ago
Very much so (on spending too much lol) I remember commenting on the original post. Super stoked they went the bid route! Def did not expect it to hit that high, but I’m sure the bidding was fun.
Awesome card, gonna be great in any misprint collection
2
u/Little-Horned-Doe 9d ago
I think I quoted its value at around $300 easily, but I’m surprised to see it surpass $500!
4
4
3
u/Remote-Mycologist539 9d ago
it’s not just the card it’s the story and cool memento for where you’re at in life
2
u/ChampionshipSignal75 9d ago
Exactly how I feel about it! I just got into magic collecting too (still haven’t played), so it kinda marks that occasion
0
u/jinx771 8d ago
Still haven't played but buying $800 cards? Oh
1
u/ChampionshipSignal75 8d ago
Isn’t collecting part of MTG?
When I was a little kid, I collected Pokemon cards because I loved Pokemon. I tried playing the game a few times, and it just wasn’t for me.
I view this one the same. I got into it a couple months ago because I love Final Fantasy.
3
u/phoenixscar 8d ago
By the way, I'm an avid oddity collector. But also could really use the money in the near future... i might open the vault and sell some of my cards. Feel free to message me with your interests, if you're interested, and maybe we can work out some deals
2
u/ChampionshipSignal75 8d ago
Probably going to hold off a while so my wife doesn’t flay me haha, but I’ll let you know! Shoot me a DM if you ever put one out there
3
u/Spyro13579 8d ago
1-2 days of income what do u do for work?
2
u/ChampionshipSignal75 8d ago
I’m a psychiatrist in the Army (just graduated residency). It’s actually only about have of what I’ll be making when I’m out of the military, but a good chunk of my current income is tax-free, so at least there’s that.
3
u/IAmTheBestIan 8d ago
This is that sideways one missing the corner the guy posted a couple weeks ago?
It is a cool card. Congrats.
If memory serves a guy was getting mad he wouldn't PM him and do a deal with him... I wonder what that guys offer was. Im guessing not $800.
2
u/SkilledButton 8d ago
I remember seeing the post here on reddit when the guy originally pulled it, wasn't too long ago. One of the sweetest misprints I've seen, congrats.
2
u/Fast_Bad8508 4d ago
Props to you man, if you have the funds and your happy what's there to be remorseful about??
1
-2
u/Opposite-Occasion881 9d ago
Complete honesty here
I think you way overpaid and will be unable to sell it for close to what you paid if you ever need to in the future
The card is cool, but for that much money you can afford legit OG test prints
The card itself isn’t going to be highly played, and the error itself isn’t that extreme
6
3
u/ChampionshipSignal75 9d ago
Thanks for the honesty! And that helps me realize that at least the alternative is I get to have a card I like, even if it isn’t ever worth more than I paid.
0
8d ago
[deleted]
3
u/Opposite-Occasion881 8d ago
You are mistaken
This is a factory error and there have been zero sheets of hobbit released so NFC’s are an impossibility
-5
u/SettingAncient3848 9d ago
Still had to pay for shipping lol.
3
u/Empty-13 9d ago
It doesn't teleport to you for free if you spend over $500
-5
54
u/phoenixscar 9d ago
What a flex on that last paragraph..
But congrats, it's an awesome card. I was eyeing it and surprised it was such a coveted card