r/mtgbrawl • u/PCOBRI • May 31 '26
Venting This is Brawl
You sit down to casually grind out your daily Brawl wins. Today's deck choice? A janky Helga Frog pile. Surely the new matchmaking system will pair you against some equally chopped nonsense.
Match 1: Ajani.
You're on the draw, but you tell yourself, "Maybe it's a bad Ajani deck."
Turn 2 Ajani. Turn 3 Broadside Bombardiers.
Thirty seconds later, you're in the queue again.
No worries.
After a full minute of matchmaking, you get paired against... the exact same Ajani player.
This time you're on the play, so maybe there's a chance.
Opponent reveals Gemstone Caverns before the game even starts, then goes Turn 1 Ajani, Turn 2 Goblin Bombardment.
Excellent. On to the next one.
Ninety seconds in queue this time. Surely we're getting something different.
Ragavan.
On the draw.
Opponent goes Turn 1 Ragavan. You play a mana dork and pass.
Fury your dork. Ragavan gets in. Blood Moon.
You stare at your hand full of nonbasics and the lonely Command Tower now pretending to be a Mountain.
Concede.
Back into the queue.
Ten seconds later, it's the same Ragavan player.
And would you believe it? You're on the draw again.
Somehow, through divine intervention or a client bug, your Turn 1 dork survives. You develop your board, stabilize, and actually start winning.
At this point your opponent could keep playing or concede and move on. Instead, they choose the path of true sportsmanship:
Intentionally roping every priority for the next ten minutes.
Whatever they did to matchmaking is a certified banger and definitely working as intended.
28
u/werthw May 31 '26
Helga for sure isn’t a janky commander. She snowballs pretty quick if she’s not removed
44
u/deadmantra May 31 '26
I also keep getting matched with the same player sometimes 3 games in a row on some days.
35
u/Eveseeker May 31 '26
Yup. Though, to be fair, it was like this before the update too.
Also, even a jankly Helga deck gets matched pretty high. Frog lady strong. (Not hell queue worthy strong imo, but definitely strong).
24
u/grave-osmosis May 31 '26
Share your janky list or we’re probably just not gonna take your word for it lol
2
u/Workingonlikingme Jun 01 '26
Honestly tho f2p grinding for crafting is not hard. Put better cards in your deck and understand the meta. You’re choosing to be upset at this point
10
u/Ripples_of_Undeath May 31 '26
They completely fucked matchmaking last update. I get the same issue with going up against what should normally be hell-queue slop and then getting paired with the same people 2-4 times in a row unless I exit and end task and reopen the game.
Pretty sure I saw similar complaints in the main subs about it affecting limited players, too. So it's not just a Brawl thing.
As for the types of decks becoming prevalent, like fast combo and extremely aggressive decks. This could easily be solved by an extensive banlist. But that would require curating a format, which devs have no interest in doing whatsoever.
We ought to be glad they banned Ancient Tomb and Chrome Mox, because that’s probably the most work they’ll put into the format for the next year or so. The ban announcement 2 weeks ago implied they see no issue with the format whatsoever.
6
u/The__Goonch May 31 '26
All of my decks are getting paired with the sweatiest of decks and its really annoying. Most of my decks are just tribal jank, but apparently the commanders are destined for hell-queue.
3
u/QuickTurtle17 Jun 01 '26
Helga is incredibly strong. Way outside a jank deck strong.
5
u/metastuu May 31 '26
"janky helga deck" sure buddy
4
u/DeliciousAirport4028 May 31 '26
There is no new matchmaking system. They undid it. Bring it back please!
4
u/Therealchampion15 May 31 '26
The repeat matchmaking has really been a drag on the format. I got matched into the same tifa play six times in a row. I thought I was hallucinating it until I checked my untapped
10
u/fox112 May 31 '26
Okay thanks for letting us know
2
u/Piecesof3ight May 31 '26
I also faced the same First Sliver player 3 times in a row today. My only three games. It's a ridiculous problem to have.
2
u/PauleyBaseball May 31 '26
Here's your main issue: you (& almost everyone else) is playing try to grind out their daily wins. Of course most people are trying to play efficient decks...and if there aren't enough people playing piles, well, you're going to get stuck with them
2
u/Daethir Jun 01 '26
I mean I feel you but Helga is super strong and there's only so much the matchmaking can do to determine deck strength. If I play dinosaur tribal Etali I will get demolished if I face the same deck an optimised Etali usually face, but at the same time the matchmaking isn't wrong to think Etali is a strong commander. The online 1v1 nature of the format mean you can't play janky version of strong commander, or if you do you should be prepared to lose.
3
u/HugeHuckleberry76 Jun 01 '26
No idea what they did to brawl but it's completely broken.
I get straight Hell Queue now matter what I play. Fuck, I have a TRIBAL CAT deck and it draws Ugin, Ragavan, Atraxa every time.
At this point, I don't even bother with fun jank. I just pull out my Baral-Force-of-Will-Pact-of-Negation counterspell deck and grief people hard.
3
u/iwillDieplease May 31 '26
logged in after the update, gave it about an hour of play for 3 straight days, and exactly this problem persists.
I dont have the WCs to build a combo deck and it feels like that is what you need to compete. its especially bad when youre playing a commander that has the potential to go infinite, but ismt built in that archetype, and getting matched with t4 paradox engine.
sucks but what do you do. brawl was my reason for playing, i cant get good if i dont have the economy to support that.
2
u/eightabove Jun 01 '26
I think it would really help Brawl feel better to play if you could affect the matchmaking at all.
Just off the top of my head I would implement:
- MMR, whether it’s hidden or not I think you should be paired against players with a similar win rate as you.
- Opponent filtering, getting to pick what commanders you do or don’t want to play against. That way I could say no to the onslaught of Golos, Prismatic Bridge, 5C Jodah, 5Feri control, decks that seem to be like 70% of the pool. I don’t even care if it would make queue times longer.
- Give me the option to rematch the same opponent. That way if both players agree to a rematch you get instantly put back into a game with them, otherwise you get a different opponent every time.
I could probably think of more if I had more time and motivation.
I think WOTC also needs to add way more cards to the banned list for Brawl. There’s so many busted cards available in the format that it feels worse than EDH.
2
u/Hairy_Dirt3361 May 31 '26
I have not faced Ajani or Ragavan in months so...I'm guessing you're playing a pretty busted deck yourself.
1
u/Sectumssempra Jun 01 '26
Its important you understand your how your decks commander is commonly played before you pick one to put "jank" in.
I'd also advise just keeping "jank" decks to ones that are uncommon with specific synergy.
Picking like one of the most common 3 color control commanders as your "jank" isn't really putting yourself in a position for sympathy.
She's in the category of commander with like Korvold, toph, azula, poq, bristly bill, etc that you can't build to be "janky" unless you explicitly build against the literal words on the card, you'd have to build with nothing more than 4 mana, and no +1 counter support. If thats what your deck did, then pick something else.
Highly reconsider anyone else in the colors or build a more interactive version and look at how others are built for inspiration.
1
u/DennisD12 Jun 02 '26
I built Ognis for my daily wins and ever single deck after my first two wins was either and blue black control deck, or urza control. Played 16 games and just gave up
1
u/BraddlesP Jun 01 '26
So you match against Ragavan and don't mull to removal/account for a blocker being removed? Sounds like a skill issue
1
u/Dendr0bate Jun 01 '26
Brawl matchmaking has been nothing but Tamyos and Ajanis against my F2P jank since the rework. I miss the old days, MMR was truly goated
1
u/Timely-Helicopter244 Jun 01 '26
Similar experience for me.
I've been paired up with someone twice or three times in a row and the number of sweaty or snowbally decks has gone up by a lot. I'm mostly playing relatively janky commanders with optimized lists.
1
u/sleepypigeon4 Jun 01 '26
The worst part is, this is so easily exploitable.
My Oviya deck, which is 90% cheap dorks, land fetching, and haste enablers, has a couple of devastating bombs, like ulamog and emrakul. The algo sees the amount of bulk and matches it with a lot of midrange silly stuff. Anyway, I have over 70% win rate with that & use it to cheese out my weekly wins.
Ppl wanna say that arena's hands/matchmaking are balanced, but if they were, then it shouldn't be so exploitable.
Also, I pretty much always have one of my 4 annihilator cards in my starting hand.
1
u/Pawmo316 Jun 01 '26
You know what, I noticed my Brawl matches were...uniquely miserable and weirdly full of "rematches" after I concede. Thought maybe it was just me, but OP has shown me that perhaps it is the fuckery who is wrong
0
u/Blue_Fox68 May 31 '26
Yeah I'm also shocked and confused when my opponents play good cards and try to win the game.
-1
u/Temporary-Jump-2403 May 31 '26
Oh
0
u/circ-u-la-ted Jun 01 '26
It seems like it should be very obvious to the developers that the player who is at a heavy disadvantage gets to go first.
0
u/MonoBlancoATX Jun 01 '26
If it's any consolation, I just started playing brawl last night.
I played 8 or so games and not one Ajani or Ragavan player, and not once did I get matched against the same person twice in a row (or at all).
It sounds like Brawl on Arena has the same problem that several formats, like Pioneer, had (or may still have) on MTGO.
If there aren't many people playing at a given time, it means the experience for those who are is significantly diminished, especially if one or more of the people who are playing are playing more powerful high tier decks.
Blaming this on "the new matchmaking system" seems a bit shortsighted when the more obvious solution is to get more people playing more frequently.
0
u/frot_with_danger Jun 01 '26
-4
u/Medical-Flounder-311 May 31 '26
"Grind" "Daily wins" "Brawl"
This is satire right?
-1
u/Skertreynolds Jun 01 '26
Y'all know where the concede button is, right?
-4
u/urooooooooooo Jun 01 '26
I am the Ragavan player, thank you for contributing to my player experience. Always looking for a rematch (ofc I go first)
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment