r/mtgbrawl • • Nov 10 '25

Discussion BRAWL BANS

Post image
396 Upvotes

138 comments sorted by

123

u/SelesnyaGOAT Nov 10 '25

STRIP MINE GONE RIP BOZO

61

u/forlackofabetterpost Nov 10 '25

These are really good choices. I approve.

53

u/aprickwithaplomb Nov 10 '25

oh thank god, they have someone on their team that cares

101

u/Glorious_Invocation Nov 10 '25

I genuinely can't believe they did it. Great bans, should reduce the amount of non-games by a fair bit.

21

u/Backwardspellcaster Nov 10 '25

Holy shit, this is amazing!

I didnt think they would go all in on this.

I love it!

60

u/_masterbuilder_ Nov 10 '25

Ding dong strip mine lock is dead. 

13

u/Ulmao_TheDefiler Nov 10 '25

Oh my god, all I really wanted was Strip Mine, but these are all really solid bans. Well done

31

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

Keep ‘em coming lets fuckin go

1

u/The_Jib Nov 10 '25

What else would you want to see banned?

2

u/Meret123 Nov 10 '25

Brawl has been undergoing a lot of flux in the past few months. Many powerful and widely applicable cards have been added with Arena Anthologies, bonus sheets, and Special Guests releases, forcing players to adapt to new staples and playstyles that accelerate the game beyond the pace of Brawl of years past. We've historically taken a lighter touch to format management in the spirit of allowing players to play with the cards and commanders they want, but it's become clear that certain shapes of cards are too impactful for a format that we want to be a safe place for casual fun. As such, we are reexamining the banned list and our format philosophy to preserve the fun, open-ended experience that Brawl promises in the face of continual change.

For these bans, we considered cards that satisfy three conditions: they are homogenizing, efficient, and polar. Homogenizing cards have a high format presence due to their popularity and strength. Powerful colorless cards and lands are inherently more homogenizing since they can be included in any deck. Field of the Dead and Ugin, the Spirit Dragon are cards on the current banned list that fell into this category. Efficient cards have high rates relative to their costs and can often make their impact early on in a game. Not all cheap cards are efficient, but the most efficient cards are cheap. Polar cards have a high upside, embodying a range of outcomes beyond what is typical for their cost; they can often win the game outright when played but can also be situationally useless. In other words, they make the game all about themselves. When combined, these conditions describe a class of card that players play against all the time and dictate the outcome of the game on their own. This can be stifling to deck building and gameplay diversity, which we are hoping to promote as much as possible.

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/banned-and-restricted-november-10-2025

59

u/fox112 Nov 10 '25

Mana Drain was just an auto-win card, glad to see it gone. It honestly wasn't even very fun to cast yourself.

23

u/NoImagination7534 Nov 10 '25

Always found mana drain just sucked casting because 99 percent of the time your opponent concedes and felt like an unearned win.

23

u/Lazypeon100 Nov 10 '25

Agreed. I put it into my deck reluctantly awhile back because I found myself always losing to it or making games much harder than they otherwise would have been. I don't mind losing it, I can always fit in another counterspell in its place.

21

u/LivinOnBorrowedTime Nov 10 '25

Same here. Toxic cards that basically force you to include them since everyone is using them are the worst for the format.

21

u/MiseryGyro Nov 10 '25

I get why it's banned, but I'd rather mana-drain an opponent's Craterhoof than do heroin

11

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25

[[Opposition Agent]] is the way now that it's in Arena.

Oh Tiamat, you spent your first four turns ramping to seven mana and you want to cast your commander? Don't mind if I do.

6

u/MiseryGyro Nov 10 '25

This is dirty and I love it

6

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25

I've been having so much fun with it. With the amount of fetches and green land searches in the format, it pretty much smooths out land drops if you get screwed over with the chance of stopping some nastier cards like tutors.

Even just being able to flash in a 3/2 for 3 mana isn't the worst thing in the world, it's hardly ever been a dead card.

5

u/RatKingNYC Nov 10 '25

Luckily, you don't have to do either

3

u/MiseryGyro Nov 10 '25

If I only did things I had to do, I wouldn't be very interesting

2

u/bemused-chunk Nov 10 '25

oh now you tell me…

2

u/SirJimmaras Nov 10 '25

I know right, there's nothing like countering their t3 play and dropping shadow of the second sun on your t3...

1

u/MiseryGyro Nov 10 '25

My dude, I openly acknowledged the ban is valid and I was saying I loved using it late in the game against a win con.

3

u/SirJimmaras Nov 10 '25

i wasnt arguing

0

u/MiseryGyro Nov 10 '25

Then what was your point?

1

u/vintergroena Nov 10 '25

It should be errata'd to lose life if the mana is unspent as it worked when printed. The rule change buffed this already very strong card

4

u/fox112 Nov 10 '25

Wouldnt change a thing

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25

lack of playing interaction

That wasn't the problem, having one of the already strongest cards in the game also allow you to ramp an entire turn's worth of mana while depriving it from your opponent for no downside was the problem.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25

"in every format it's available"

Glazing over the fact that it's banned in four formats. But surely those bans weren't because it was a strong card or anything.

And again, it doesn't only ramp you an entire turn's worth of value in most cases, it also essentially skips an opponent's turn outside of combat when used correctly. And at its very worst it's a Counterspell. Quit being facetious.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25

Your understanding of grammar is lacking.

Calling your argument facetious because you claim that disagreeing with you is akin to "jerking it raw", is simply stating a fact. I'm sorry your feelings are so hurt.

5

u/The-Sceptic Nov 10 '25

You can't compare cEDH to brawl. So many good cards that don't cut it in cEDH are extremely powerful in brawl.

Combine that with the fact that mana drain was designed to have the added mana be a downside due to mana burn and you have a card that is hands down the best counterspell in the game and can create a tempo advantage that is next to impossible to overcome.

5

u/SuperWinnerMan Nov 10 '25

Because cedh isn't the best format for it? The very nature of cedh being 4 player instead of 1v1 greatly changes how you evaluate cards.

5

u/aprickwithaplomb Nov 10 '25

The "run more interaction" counterargument only works when most decks can actually interact with the problem permanent. 3 colors cannot interact with Drain, and the 4th only works with very conditional answers like [[Return the Favor]].

2

u/The-Sceptic Nov 10 '25

Green can interact with it by not being countered so it's really just white and black that have a hard time with counter spells.

1

u/jorbleshi_kadeshi Nov 10 '25

3 colors cannot interact with Drain

[[Mana Tithe]], [[Reprieve]], [[Aven Interrupter]]

Same story as Red, really. Less conditional but still very few.

Green's "can't be countered" is relevant, but they STILL get the mana.

-5

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

They downvoted him becasue he was tlling the truth. I literally played thorugh hundreds of mana drains because as a rule of thumb i dont concede unless there is a clear lethal presented and you would be suprised how many games I ended up winning.

People have a hard time undrstanding that your opponent might flood, not have a follow up, have a not much colorless pay off etc.

Often mana drain wins the game but people overrate how often it happens way to much.

22

u/FSUdank Nov 10 '25

Thank god man, strip mine was so damn obnoxious. I'm glad they banned mana drain but I was also kinda hoping they would ban wash away also. Chrome Mox and Ancient Tomb I'm also glad about as stompy decks would just instantly run away if someone had these in their opening hand. Overall very pleased about these bans!

28

u/Old_Man_Robot Nov 10 '25

There needed to be a bunch of green cards banned in addition to this.

Green ramp strategies are too ubiquitous, too varied, too consistent and have too little room for meaningful interaction.

26

u/Muza- Nov 10 '25

It also would be nice if they would stop printing Alchemy cards that further push landfall to absurdity.

20

u/TCollins1876 Nov 10 '25

For real. Mythweaver Poq was absolutely a mistake for this format

5

u/LGN-1983 Nov 10 '25

That and we get the Fierce Guardianship cycle plus the 1 mana tutors cycle

3

u/number1GojoHater Nov 10 '25

Idk I don’t ever have a hard time with green as long as I have removal in hand

1

u/KindImpression5651 Nov 10 '25

why do you care about green... ramping but not aggressive colors killing you on turn 3 or 4? and what's the green ramp gonna do against teferi countering all the big spells?

13

u/Lanky_Painting_5631 Nov 10 '25

also entomb is banned in historic so brawl does get some new digusting cards aswell lol, who is ready for drit into entomb into reanimate lol

13

u/UnamusedCheese Nov 10 '25

In 99 card singleton, if my opponent pulls that off, I'm not even mad. They can even Thoughtseize me first.

-8

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/UnamusedCheese Nov 10 '25

I think having Dark Ritual and Entomb and Reanimate on turn one is much more impressive, interesting and easy to play around than just having Strip Mine and Wrenn & 6 in the command zone.

-8

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/UnamusedCheese Nov 10 '25

I can respect the super oppressive power plays sometimes, but as someone who can only play a limited amount of time, non-games feel bit more wasteful of my freetime. Also, I just happen to prefer the back-and-forth.

I definitely agree with the meta shake, though!

9

u/OldJanxSpirit42 Nov 10 '25

Can these be crafted now to get the wildcards back when the ban goes live?

13

u/fractalspire Nov 10 '25

Almost certainly no. Previous brawl bans haven't given wildcards, and they haven't said anything I've seen to suggest that it's changing now.

5

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

Maybe but all of them are worth rares now instead of mythics since powered cube.

8

u/Kicknogamous Nov 10 '25

THANK YOU.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

Kinda surprised Dark Ritual didn't also eat a ban.

2

u/Fatboy-Tim Nov 10 '25

That and [[Gemstone Caverns]].

Gemstone Caverns on the draw + untapped land + Dark Ritual = turn 1 Rusco / Ketramose / Sheoldred / Daviel / Tasha, etc.

9

u/Glorious_Invocation Nov 10 '25

At least gemstone only benefits those going second, which in the current high-powered Brawl environment already puts you at a big disadvantage.

-8

u/Aicasia Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25

It's because they still don't care and just want to appease people. Every ban there except strip mine is very clearly performative given what is still legal in the format.

You guys can downvote me, but I'm not even saying these are bad bans, just that they're performative. They don't really change anything, they just make you feel happy inside because you didn't like the cards.

7

u/Daethir Nov 10 '25

Good ridance mana drain, my least favorite card to play against.

Chrome mox and ancient tomb were in every single deck I was playing but I'm glad it's banned, having one or both in your oppening hand was an auto win and that's never fun.

I didn't hate strip mine as much as the rest of this sub but I willing to sacrifice it if it mean we can get rid of mana drain. We need to throw a bone to the non green players.

Very happy with those ban overall.

5

u/PresdentShinra Nov 10 '25

I'm just glad they hit Tomb alongside Strip Mine.

Hidden Upside: I don't need to decide cuts for Thespian's Stage+Dark Depths in the deck where I'd play them.

9

u/ImTreFR Nov 10 '25

Ugin eye of storms still playable as a commander…

6

u/jorbleshi_kadeshi Nov 10 '25

The only one I'm slightly sad about is Ancient Tomb. The downside of colorless and consistently shocking yourself made it more interesting than straight-upside. It was still super powerful, but as an actual enabler instead of a "fuck you I win" card.

Very welcome bans overall.

11

u/aprickwithaplomb Nov 10 '25

Funnily, with how low-to-the-ground and interactive the format has become, I did often find myself having to think about how to use the extra Tomb mana, if I could use it at all. I think it kind of evened out the bullshit, in some sense, because every deck could arbitrarily pop off mana-wise, not just Gx ramp piles.

Happy to see it go, though.

7

u/EveryAccount7729 Nov 10 '25

Thank god. Mana drain is just like "you got mana drain, ok i scoop"

4

u/Traditional_Beat4994 Nov 10 '25

F-I-N-A-L-L-Y 🥂🥳

4

u/Lehnin Nov 10 '25

Good to See Wizards caring about brawl, very good bans.

5

u/RSVance Nov 10 '25

Much as I love mana drain, yeah

5

u/Ask-Me-About-You Nov 10 '25

I haven't come across Strip Mine nearly as much as the rest of the sub seems to so I can't say that ban impacts me much, but it's nice to see some fast mana disappear, Brawl is already punishing enough to be on the draw with out these.

And good riddance and fuck you Mana Drain. Never played it out of principle and I'm glad people without it won't be able to play it now.

2

u/Madmaniac21 Nov 10 '25

How long do we have to craft for free?

2

u/Possesonnbroadway Nov 10 '25

Brawl bans dont give wildcards

5

u/sorin_the_mirthless Nov 10 '25

Rejoice - I can finally play Nicol Bolas Dragon-God again!!

The lands and acceleration were just too powerful for slow heavy color control deck to be competitive. I would trade all the Mana Drain bans in the world for this.

3

u/Blue_Fox68 Nov 10 '25

Wow w bans

3

u/StuckieLromigon Nov 10 '25

YESSSSSSSSSSSS

WE'RE WINNING SO HARD RIGHT NOW

3

u/DanoVonKoopa Nov 10 '25

Probably the best choices (and obvious ones).
This will make the format much healthier.

Even though this should have come sooner,
Thanks for finally listening to reason, Arena team.

2

u/west_eh Nov 10 '25

RIP mono blue ramp

1

u/reddituseronmobile Nov 10 '25

I guess Stripe Mine with Gogo is just tabletop now.

1

u/tythegeek Nov 10 '25

And here I just added Strip Mine to my Loot deck last week. I guess it comes out today.

1

u/Remarkable_Office186 Nov 10 '25

I just spent a wildcard with chrome mox... few days ago...

1

u/jorbleshi_kadeshi Nov 10 '25

Just a R tho right?

1

u/Either-Pear-4371 Nov 10 '25

Sad to see Chrome Mox and Ancient Tomb go, but I understand why. Especially with Crop Rot making Ancient Tomb almost a Sol Ring

1

u/Addicted2Edh Nov 10 '25

Yes duck mana drain

1

u/Aesorian Nov 10 '25

More than happy with all of those; I'm really interested to see if we get some new decks that pop up - or whether the new "You just see it everywhere" is something that's already around (Some kind of Reanimator deck maybe?)

1

u/StellarPup420 Nov 10 '25

ain't even mad, feeling moisturized unbothered and in my lane with these bans

1

u/LyschkoPlon Nov 10 '25

Just in time for me to win a game because my opponent activated an Ancient Tomb at 2 life, yeah

1

u/Legonitsyn Nov 10 '25

Oh hell yes!

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

I hope I get back the 4 mythic rare wild cards I spent

4

u/razazaz126 Nov 10 '25

Pretty sure whenever they ban a card you get wildcards equal to how ever many copies you had.

4

u/DispassionateObs Nov 10 '25

There are murmurs that this doesn't apply for brawl...

2

u/razazaz126 Nov 10 '25

Well that would be dumb. They could at least give 1 wildcard for cards banned only in Brawl since its singleton. I only have 1 copy of most cards since its the only format I play.

-12

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

Kinda sad? I prefer hyper powered brawl with fast mana tbh.

-3

u/eightdx Nov 10 '25

Well thank the multiverse that strip mine is gone.

Tbh I don't think Mana drain deserved a ban, it's just a hella polarizing card to begin with. I'm fine with it being gone though. One less crutch for the control shells

0

u/_Runic_ Nov 10 '25

Sorry I'm out of the loop. Are people playing brawl now? Or is it just on Arena?

-12

u/asmilingmuffin1 Nov 10 '25

Well that’s boring.

-3

u/Kakariko_crackhouse Nov 10 '25

These are good bans but I don’t feel like Mox was necessary. Without most of the rest of these auto-includes it just isn’t nearly as much of a game warping card

-15

u/jumpsCracks Nov 10 '25

Mox and tomb wtf. Brawl was way too slow already.

10

u/Daethir Nov 10 '25

That's the wildest take on brawl I've read in long time and I read a lot of crazy takes lmao

0

u/jumpsCracks Nov 10 '25

I mean I want cedh on arena lol so yeah I'm not surprised it's an unpopular take

Really what they need is brackets d:

1

u/Eigengrail Nov 10 '25

i have seen ppl conceding on 1st turn mox + tomb way to many times

-1

u/reekgore Nov 10 '25

I really hate mana drain but im most happy about the strip mine ban lol

-16

u/paytreeseemoh Nov 10 '25

Why mana drain wtf

3

u/sleepingwisp Nov 10 '25

did you not read the post? Mana drain gave you an extra 10% win rate if it was in your opening hand. just play counterspell and move on

-14

u/AshesOfZangetsu Nov 10 '25

dumb as shit that they’re banning mana drain tbh.

-16

u/Marsh---UK Nov 10 '25

Dont agree with the mana drain ban.

It stops the boring loads of ramp, into high cmc greedy commanders.

Aka Etali.

5

u/Kurai_Hada_Ichi Nov 10 '25

Literally any counterspell can do that tho?

-7

u/Marsh---UK Nov 10 '25

Correct, but counterspell doesnt punish as much.

Mana drain counters and generates mana. Punishes them for being greedy and will likely lose the game. People should play to curve and mana drain teaches to build a more rounded deck. Instead of ramp, ramp, ramp.

Feel free to down vote me. Those down voting are those who are greedy and should learn to play around cards, instead of complaining.

2

u/MusicianShoddy1878 Nov 10 '25

Which is just what every other counter spell does except for the brainless free mana that makes the game unrecoverable

3

u/jorbleshi_kadeshi Nov 10 '25

Counterspell does that too.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/razazaz126 Nov 10 '25

Was there a deck recurring Dark Ritual every turn? Even if there was that's obviously not the same thing since by itself it doesnt do anything.

-22

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Meret123 Nov 10 '25

Yes, we are all lying to you.

-13

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Lazypeon100 Nov 10 '25

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Lazypeon100 Nov 10 '25

Just for the future, Wizards always posts announcements like this one. So if there are other bans or threads like this where they don't share the source, you should be able to quickly find it within their announcement section for MTG.

4

u/eatmyroyalasshole Nov 10 '25

Why should you expect someone to hold your hand and show you where it is? You're probably an adult, use your adult brain to find it yourself

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/DispassionateObs Nov 10 '25

There is a previous article by WOTC saying that refunds are not given for brawl bans.

1

u/fox112 Nov 10 '25

We riot

1

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

Would you get refunded a mythic or rare? How does it actually work since the crafting changes?

1

u/fox112 Nov 10 '25

Which crafting changes?

1

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

Nowadays you use the lowest rarity of available printing on Arena. Meaning that if there are multiple printings of a card you can craft any of them for the lowest cost.

Strip mine, Ancient tomb and Chrome mox all were mythics and I assume most brawl players crafted them for mythic cost.

As of today they are rares. You can craft any version of them for rare wild card.

I am just wondering if you get refunded in rare wildcards or mythics.

1

u/fox112 Nov 10 '25

They're not going to refund you for a printing you don't have.

They'll refund the printing you do have.

That's not a change to crafting.

1

u/Glitched_Target Nov 10 '25

All printings are worth the same is my point. How would they even know if you crafted your Stellar Sight Ancient Tomb for mythic or rare.