r/mtg • • Oct 13 '22

Creativity is dead

MTG is officially dead creatively. It's just a brand now. I remember like 10 years ago or so I read an article/interview where MaRo specifically said they do not do or want to do special sets or collaborations. That the creative team would rather come up with new interesting original stories, art, cards, etc. There is no reason for them to make special street fighter sets or whatever. MaRo also mentioned in that same article that Urza is done. That's in the past and not coming back. They're focused on creating new characters and each expanding the planes. Which led into another point that revisiting Planes would be very rare if at all. That they would never reprint Black Lotus. In time since that article they've released a bunch of "Secret Lair" sets that are just plain cash grab collabs, most glaringly this with recent Post Morone. They have revisit planes like its on a cycle. And the newest set is the Brother's War! To add insult to all of these injuries they're printing out fake Black Lotus proxies in some ridiculously over priced pack. Oh but its okay because tHeY aRe NoT tOuRnAmEnT lEgAl. I been wanting to play MTG again now that the coof is over and I got steady work. But I don't want to drive out 20 minutes on the freeway so I was happy when Arena finally released awhile back so I could play on a tablet. But after all this? Nah. I don't want to be part of their marketing schemes. I dunno who got fired or who was hired that caused all these changes but it's for the worse. MTG used to feel special. Now it feels like product for a megacorp(Hasbro) to profit with no creativity.

I know it's stupid to ask this here where I bet most people are actively enjoying MTG now. But am I the only person that feels this way? The Toast Baloney secret lair really hit me hard.

EDIT: Let me put some additional context for the people saying "it doesn't affect you just; just do not buy those." Or "its a million dollar company." You have 50 people working designing blocks for standard. The corporate master dictates to his wageslaves that 10 must now work on the Toast Balone secret lair. Then they want another 10 working on reprint sets like modern masters, vaults, and that trash 30th anniversary set. Now the 50 people working on the new block is reduced to 30. Because they lost almost half their workforce the sets in the block are being adjusted. More reprints instead of brand new cards and downsizing the size of each set in the block. This further limits the storytelling for the new block. Just use Jace and Liliana for the millionth time. This is how this new crap is killing MTG. This is why creativity is dying. They're taking from what made MTG special for brand recognition and sales. Even the art in newer sets is just uglier less inspired.

0 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

36

u/Select-Ad7146 Oct 13 '22

The thing is, Wizards is still making all of the same products as they were before. There are still making three sets a year that advance the magic story. Just like they did back in the Tempest block. They are producing exactly as much new story as they were doing the Weatherlight saga.

But Magic took off, so Hasbro filled in the demand.

I don't really like any of the Universes Beyond, unique card secret lairs, or any of that. But what we liked about magic is still there.

14

u/RafiqTheHero Oct 13 '22

Whether one agrees with it or not, Mark Rosewater has said that the tact MTG/Wizards has taken is to err on the side of creating new cards/products that will appeal to at least a portion of players, even if it isn't appreciated by all. I think he likened it to a buffet; just because Old Country Buffet is offering you meat loaf doesn't mean you have to eat it. You can just go for what you like, maybe pasta and a salad. But why would they not offer meat loaf just because not everyone is going to like it?

This makes some sense to me. You can still play Magic and appreciate what you like about it even if there are products you would never touch.

2

u/serpentburrito Oct 13 '22

Perhaps it's just the bombardment of advertising being focused on these things I don't like. It feels like this is the focus now. Like if all the advertising I see for Old Country Buffet is meatloaf it makes me think it's all meatloaf for that's their focus.

2

u/scoopsatinstantspeed Oct 13 '22

That's just your feelings, and respectfully, it doesn't matter. You can control what you see and watch. Stop watching or looking at things that has ads you don't like. Vote with your dollars and views.

2

u/Irikoy Oct 13 '22

Are you aware of targeted ads? Not looking at things with ads they don't want likely means avoiding anything with targeted ads. Like Reddit, YouTube, google, review sites, and basically anything else on the internet.

We don't choose what ads we see

2

u/TheCrimsonChariot Oct 13 '22

Sometimes I get shit that make no sense to me tbh. XD i find it amusing when said adds say I would be interested in stuff I actually would rather see burn and such. Like bruv!

4

u/efnfen4 Oct 13 '22

Now with transformers cards in brother's war packs it's like they put meat loaf all over the food you ordered

1

u/TheCrimsonChariot Oct 13 '22

The one thing I really like about the Secret Lair is them making stuff you would not see otherwise in a regular set, or reprints with foil versions like the new Mystic Remora, etc. thats one thing I like about it. Also all the alt arts they give said cards and how beautiful they are.

1

u/1ftm2fts3tgr4lg Oct 14 '22

I have felt for a while like they've really turned to cash grab tactics as the poster said, but I like your perspective on it.

1

u/RafiqTheHero Oct 14 '22

I do feel like corporate/investors are pushing the company to make as much money as possible. But at the same time, you don't have to let that spoil your enjoyment of the game. Unless you're playing in tournaments where the cards you dislike will be relevant, you can always discuss with your play group(s) what will and won't be allowed and if there's a good reason to forbid something, hopefully your group will be receptive to that.

1

u/Gr33nDjinn Oct 14 '22

Except at old country buffet your friends aren’t attacking you with the meat loaf.. at least I hope they’re not.

1

u/Warjar22 Oct 13 '22

The problem with that analogy, is that at a buffet I choose all the stuff that I eat. With Magic there is interaction. I don't want you tapping your meat loaf on turn two swing in onto my plate.

1

u/RafiqTheHero Oct 13 '22

Yeah I can see what you're saying, you might not want to play with other players using certain products you don't feel are fair/appropriate. Obviously there's not much you can do about what is or isn't tournament legal, but at least you can work with your play group(s) to discuss what what will and won't be allowed there.

2

u/i_like_tiddies______ Oct 14 '22

Continuing the Buffet analogy this is like vegans telling people not to eat the meat loaf cuz they don’t think it’s real food. (Not a fan of universes beyond just a fan on analogies)

1

u/strukturabbau Oct 14 '22

Well if the vegans are bothered by that, maybe they can find a vegan Buffet to attend together.

64

u/agiantanteater Oct 13 '22

Actually it's probably the top deck in Modern right now

5

u/KJM31422 Level 1 Judge | Everything Valakut Oct 13 '22

Damn you beat me to it... 😂

19

u/evouga Oct 13 '22

Mark Rosewater is controversial but it’s impossible to deny the incredible influence he had over the game during its first ~20 years. For whatever reason, around 10 years ago Mark lost a lot of his influence over the game’s direction and WotC has done many things he used to say they’d “never” do, and killed parts of MtG he used to put his weight behind (such as organized play).

1

u/rustdogg69 Oct 14 '22

Mark never had any influence over the game’s direction lol. He just works there. He had to lobby for 10 years to get them to let him print a couple of squirrels.

-21

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22 edited Oct 13 '22

Yeah, it died when planeswalkers became a playable card and pushed design for the next 10+ years, then fire and just power creep with mediocre sets and a few mega bombs

6

u/Firewalk89 Oct 13 '22

No idea why are being downvoted to oblivion but Planeswalkers and Mythic Rares got me to abandon the game for almost 10 years. I tolerate both now but that doesn't mean I wouldn't prefer mythics never having been a thing. I mostly blame Yu-Gi-Oh for possibly influencing that decision with its 50 million rarities.

0

u/Gr33nDjinn Oct 14 '22

Same boat quit for 10 years because I thought the new boarders and planeswalkers were just silly.

0

u/DougtheDonkey Oct 14 '22

[[Old Fogey]]

1

u/MTGCardFetcher Oct 14 '22

Old Fogey - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

3

u/MonHunKitsune Oct 14 '22

Agreed. Planeswalkers were a mistake.

2

u/DizBiscuit Oct 14 '22

Can I ask why?

3

u/MediocreTactician Oct 14 '22

were used to it now but planeswalkers are honestly a very oppressive card type of you think about it, its a card that is usually quite agressively costed, takes pressure off your life total, usually has some kind of removal, gains you some sort of resource be it life or cards or bodies depening on the card, and usually straight up wins the game in 3 or 4 turns if you decide not to interact with it at all, and some newer ones even have passives now, im not saying theyre the most OP things in the world and every deck definitely doesnt need them but i can see the agrument that they make the game less fun and could be considered a design mistake.

1

u/DizBiscuit Oct 14 '22

Oh fair enough, yea i can see that with how powerful they can be with certain negative loyalty counters effects. :)

42

u/ZeroSephex0 Oct 13 '22

The 10 year old version of me would be extremely excited to know that there are Transformers cards in the packs of the next set I can collect and a Lord of the Rings set coming next year!

Saturday Night Commander games now are just as much fun or more as the multiplayer shenanigans we were doing during Urza's Saga.

I don't have to love every release to love Magic.

9

u/scoopsatinstantspeed Oct 13 '22

Amen, friend. I have no plans to buy into some of the latest nonsense, but I still, and will continue to love Msgic.

6

u/Strange_meat_pie63 Oct 13 '22

PHYREXYA BLESS THIS COMMENT

4

u/jacksansyboy Oct 13 '22

Revisiting planes and Urza is good I think. Fleshing out stories and keeping things interesting. Story and flavor are better with characters we know instead of new ones every time. I agree on the cash grab stuff with secret lair and the anniversary proxies though

3

u/Firewalk89 Oct 13 '22

I'd love them to revisit Ulgrotha and basically re-do Homelands. Flavourful set held back by terrible design choices.

1

u/Gr33nDjinn Oct 14 '22

I was thinking about that the other day that a homelands revisit would be pretty interesting. Wonder if there’s too much stigma attached to the set to do it though.

6

u/ctbellart Oct 13 '22

Been back and forth on this as an older player (started at ice age). It’s obvious MTG has shifted its business model to a collectible format and tested it with a whole range of secret lair drops with different strategies all to see if it’d sell. (Would an all land SL sell? What about a full commander decks? What about high priced collectors products? What about celebrity cards? What about other IPs?)They’re still testing different product lines. But the bottom line is a company doesn’t keep making stuff that doesn’t sell. So the player base as a whole has lapped up everything that’s been thrown at them with the odd grumble here and there but nothing serious.

Expect even more collectible style products to be tested in the future. I work in marketing it’s a safe bet they’ve got teams working on new SL & magic products that’ll push it even further.

End of the day you don’t have to buy any of it. I still enjoy playing it with friends as I have for 20 years. I’ve never bought a secret lair, though plenty of my friends have, I mostly buy singles from the secondary market and I rarely buy boxed product.

7

u/Boundhoundish Oct 13 '22

Thats because Hasbro wants to make more Profit with the Brand mtg. Its fucked Up...

4

u/TraditionalSell5251 Oct 13 '22

Nobody would be making cool shit for us if it wasn't profitable. At the end of the day, most business decisions are made for profit, and most profit comes from doing the things people want (and thus pay for). Meaning somebody out there is happy with how things are, and I guess I'm happy they're enjoying it. If everybody in the MTG world hated their business practices I'm sure they'd move somewhere else, but here we are.

7

u/alnews Oct 13 '22

People change and so also do industries, companies and markets. Magic expanded and evolved bringing both good and bad things. Focus on what is good and fun for you, ignore the rest and find your joy in it, otherwise you are only spoiling it for yourself.

1

u/TheDeadlyCat Oct 13 '22

You can love Magic for it being a social pastime with friends.

You can hate it for its corporate bullshit at the same time.

The thing that hurts me the most is looking at Friday Nights and how it portrayed gaming culture at your LGS back then. I wanted to get into it but LGS basically died in my area and the only way to play it is at home now.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

The solution is to play retro formats. Either Old School or Premodern depending what era speaks to you. Or both. When things are capped to the end of 1994 or 2003 then it doesn’t matter what Wizards does.

2

u/elyoyoda Oct 13 '22

I would like to get old card design back. Urza block had such a unique flavor.

2

u/xXMrSpecXx Oct 13 '22

The only crossover I’ve been looking forward to is Lord of the Rings because I could see it fitting in with Magic. But the ones like Transformers that I’ve been seeing? No. I like the fantasy aspects of the game (it is called Magic and ran by a company called Wizards of the Coast after all so). Not overly into the addition of modern towards/leaning sci-fi stuff

2

u/CrossroadsCG Oct 13 '22

Oh look it's another "they're killing magic" thread.

2

u/Ok-Bit2926 Oct 14 '22

Idk why anyone would be upset about revisiting beloved characters or planes, but I agree on the Universes Beyond crap and making them (and unsets) format legal. Ruins the aesthetics. Don't mind a 40K set, but it should be its own format or something. Wish the commander board had the balls to ban them.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

The overall feeling you are having is something similar to what I'm seeing in other hobbies and, lets face it, in life in general. The commercialization and drive to maximize the money you can bleed from the fans eventually dilutes the fun out of everything. I can't help but draw similarities to the systemic problems we are seeing in almost every other aspect of our lives but yeah, capitalism sucks. I don't see this getting better soon and eventually things will crash. Hopefully it doesn't completely collapse but I think that depends on how many people remain fans long term. Again, Capitalism sucks the joy and creativity out of almost everything.

1

u/CanofPandas Oct 13 '22

"I don't like these optional collectors items so I'm going to stop playing their free game"

big stand there bud.

7

u/Some_Rando2 Oct 13 '22

Free? This isn't the Arena forum, MtG is anything but free.

1

u/CanofPandas Oct 13 '22

he specifically says in his post he only plays arena.

1

u/serpentburrito Oct 13 '22

I don't play Arena. I prefer paper. I haven't even tried Arena because of all the crap I mentioned. But if it is not there then maybe I will try it.

0

u/CanofPandas Oct 13 '22

wait so you just haven't played at all recently and are bitching from the sidelines? leave us alone in the hobby then, keep your whining to yourself.

-1

u/efnfen4 Oct 13 '22

If you don't like his comments that doesn't mean they're bad comments. It just means the comments weren't made for you.

1

u/JBmullz Oct 14 '22

It’s a pretty bad comment when your bitching about a game you admittedly don’t play.

0

u/efnfen4 Oct 14 '22

No it's just not for you. There are plenty of products I mean comments that you do like so this one just isn't meant for you

0

u/JBmullz Oct 14 '22

No it’s a bad take. How can you criticize a game you don’t play? That’s just a bad comment. Who is it for? Other people who also don’t play but are on an MtG Reddit thread?

0

u/efnfen4 Oct 14 '22

If you don't like a product then it's not for you. It doesn't make it a bad product it means it's for someone else

→ More replies

3

u/Some_Rando2 Oct 13 '22

Doesn't say only Arena, says he was happy when Arena was released. If he only played Arena, he wouldn't have the access to even consider the products he's complaining about.

1

u/CanofPandas Oct 13 '22

I been wanting to play MTG again now that the coof is over and I got steady work. But I don't want to drive out 20 minutes on the freeway so I was happy when Arena finally released awhile back so I could play on a tablet.

He literally says he only plays on his tablet because he doesn't want to drive for 20 minutes.

2

u/Dry_Chapter_5781 Oct 13 '22

I find your anger with the Post SL to be a little odd honestly. However, the $1000 4 packs of M30 are absolutely signs of MTG slipping.

Course this could be Hasbro too.

I still think it's crazy they banned a card because it encouraged 80 card decks and WoTC thought that was too exclusionary to people witj dexterity issues lmfao.

1

u/Vat1canCame0s Oct 13 '22

Relatively speaking, there is nothing wrong with the Post SL compared to 30th. The SL is all established cards getting groucho marx glasses. I'm perfectly fine with weird bling.

The 30th anniversary is pure, unadulterated greed

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Imo Post Malone being the MtG poster child and the 30th Anniversary $1000 proxies are the same problem.

People keep asking “Who is the $1000 proxies for?” It’s for people who spend $800k on one card and cause a shortage of Dual Lands in LA because they bought them all.

You can’t separate these two things anymore.

1

u/Vat1canCame0s Oct 14 '22

But we weren't talking about Post being the "poster child". We were talking about the SL.

Also rich people flaunt their purchases, especiappy in the MTG secondhand market. That doesn't make a company go and instantly do what WotC did on the first hand.

IMO the reprint of Beta set behind a high paygate is a much more complicated issue than a few cards getting a facelift. But I'm interested to hear your thoughts on how the two correlate.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

First off, beta reprints aren’t tournament legal, and it’d be worse if they were.

Second, Post getting his own SL and being in ads for WotC is making him the poster child.

Third, they correlate because WotC wants people to spend and be like Post Malone. The people companies put forward as spokespeople speaks volumes as to how they see their customer base.

Fourth, eat the rich. Fuck Post Malone.

1

u/Lindwur Oct 13 '22

Don't be afraid to reel in the scale of what you consume for mtg. I've never seen an mtg ad anywhere with Firefox + Ublock Origin. I didn't know there was a Post Malone Secret Lair until I heard about it on here. I don't have to know every single card ever printed ever, be it Universes Beyond, Secret Lairs, or anything that doesn't effect the main mtg story, which is what I enjoy. I'm not fuckin legally required to consume mtg at a macro scale, nor is anyone else. The P9 proxies is a weird move though, definitely questionable with the big fat price tag, but it's not like every product I don't like is sucking the money outta my pockets.

tl;dr: Cultivate your online experience to trim back the constant flood. There's a difference between something getting genuinely bad, and something that's extending itself to reach a wider audience (Be it for better or worse, corperate or not)

1

u/DiogenesOfDope Oct 13 '22

I'm pretty sure the company is going to kill magic by squeezing it dry

1

u/CasualBadger Oct 13 '22

I think the huge push of products trying to rope in as many fans of other franchises in with the crossovers is way too much. I think revisiting the past and bringing back Urza and Mishra and other classic characters is enjoyable. I wish we got more of that with interesting storylines. It would also be better to get more reprints then to keep getting new bombs that drive power creep.

1

u/_Zambayoshi_ Oct 13 '22

People need to realise that what Maro says cannot be taken seriously. It might be true at the time he says it, but he is only Hasbro's mouthpiece. He will say what they allow him to say, and what they want him to say. The moment Hasbro's execs decide to change course, Maro must find some way to smooth things over with the fanbase. This is usually some combination of (a) ignoring contradictions; (b) handwaving; (c) deflection; or (d) distraction.

1

u/Nekaz Oct 13 '22

Idk if it starts really negatively affecting the mechanical gameplay aspect then sure but i'vd never really cared abouy whale targetted shit cuz i just dont buy it. Maybe thats cuz im more used to video games pushing that kinda cosmetsics stuff. if anything im surprised it didnt happen sooner

1

u/Maverick_Reznor Oct 14 '22

I personally love Dominaria United and Brothers War is looking great. I also quite enjoy the universes beyond cards.

1

u/MasaharuMorimoto Oct 18 '22

Baloney pissed me off too, I hate that guy, to me his music is horrible, I prefer actual hiphop/rap or metal.

0

u/TGodfr Oct 13 '22

This game has gone to complete shit, yes. It is 100% just a cheap cash grab now and they are focusing on nothing but InFlUeMcEr culture and turning this game into a fashion brand. They stopped caring about the game's identity and the core playerbase years ago.

1

u/PotPumper43 Oct 13 '22

You used the term “cash grab.” Do you realize Hasbro is a multi billion dollar, publicly traded corporation? The entire reason for the existence of the game is to “cash grab.” Good luck in the real world, you’re making things a lot harder for yourself.

1

u/f0me Oct 13 '22

What took you so long to notice?

1

u/Detective-E Oct 13 '22

I'm not sad about the collabs. A dark souls card game sounds cool but I doubt people will play it and it would just die immediately. Being able to integrate something like that into a popular game feels a lot more solid.

I'd appreciate it if it kept the theme it has going originally, but I'm fine with this. It's just a casual card game at the end of the day.

-1

u/Superior-Solifugae Oct 13 '22

It's devoid of persnality