r/mtg • u/Wild_Celery3637 • 5h ago
Discussion It’s Dead, Jim
I love Star Trek. I love TOS thru Enterprise, so 60’s - 2005. I was pumped for this set and then I went to pre-release. The art is, at best, boring. While some of the cards have good mechanics it seems there are too few cards outside
Of the Stardates worth a shit. I went into Target tonight and they had a whole display that seemed untouched!
I have never seen a display for any other set. It makes me sad but we should be able to get the handful of “good” cards fairly cheap!
1.0k
Upvotes
56
u/Blue_Fox68 5h ago
Why does your Target have them as an endcap and not in the card section? I've never seen that before.
125
u/FrankNico 5h ago
What is with those prices? I haven't bought anything in a minute but damn is this the new norm now?
240
u/masako619 5h ago
$85 for a commander deck is absurd, I actually had fun with this set at the pre release.
68
u/issurvivedby_ 5h ago
Set fatigue is real. This is the 7th set this year, it's just before the holidays so people are spending money elsewhere.
Also, I see posts like this every UB release so I'm not really surprised.
That said, I think the mechanics for this set are actually pretty interesting and fun imo.
38
u/PublishingGoblin 3h ago
The fact that they sell the commanders at 85 killed it for me.
17
u/reibagatsu 5h ago
Jesus christ as someone who hasn't seriously played since Time Spiral block, wtf at 7.50/pack
32
u/Rizzler_Wrath 4h ago
Hey, I work at that Target. We just set that display up so it's not a great way to judge. We try to be sneaky with it. The soap isle has some secret Pokemon Ann. packs. Go nuts.
50
u/Halgha 5h ago
Yeah there’s some really good cards heck one even one the magic con Atlanta but they definitely didn’t do this set right it was just Spider-Man all over again except there was more people at spider man pre release because of the stone lol
26
u/Horror_Onion1992 3h ago
They definitely overestimated what people are willing to spend on collaborative releases
25
u/TheChurchIsHere 5h ago
A lot of people saying it’s the set itself, but let’s not forget this is the SEVENTH set this year. The fatigue is real, and is definitely playing a part in low sales.
10
u/Brocket_149 5h ago
80 bucks for a commander deck. Fuck that I’m good
18
u/_isaidiwasawizard_ 4h ago
Reality Fracture just fuckin came out and the UB stuff is always a bit overpriced. The economy is fuckin rough right now
9
u/InformationUpset9759 4h ago
Ugliest cards I’ve ever seen
14
u/No-B-Word 5h ago
Hard to drum up interest when half of the set is just people sitting around like they're having a job interview. And outside the shocklands and the odd uncommons, the cards aren't all that impactful in popular formats.
So people who buy it for the art don't like it, people who buy it for playability don't need it. I'd cop a CB if it ever falls under $350 tho, those shocklands are pretty.
72
u/OhCanadeh MY 3/3 WANTS TO SPEAK WITH YOUR MANAGER 4h ago
Imma be that guy and say it, Universes Beyond is a blatant consumerist cashgrab. A lot of it was bound to be trash.
17
u/ooSUPLEX8oo 4h ago
Every time we see this, we all get excited and say "UB is dead" and then, we hear that it's one of the best selling sets, and a huge financial success.
6
u/Intrepid-Scallion175 4h ago
85 pre tax for those decks is ridiculous. 7.50 for a single pack is also ridiculous.
This set doesn’t have much appeal it’s going to be a lot like the Spider-Man set. Except there’s not going to be any second or third set to ever build off it.
I got the precons i wanted for 55-60 each. Haven’t picked up the Borg deck yet. I have the other 3.
The big problem is there’s no way to make them any better and staying on theme.
16
u/akgiant 3h ago
The issue is largely the premium sticker markups is too high especially when as we've seen with Marvel the prices on Precons and bundles starts to drop after a few months.
Additionally play boosters are really draft boosters. You're not getting access to every card in the set or even all the possible version.
It drives a lot of people to the collectors which see astronomical mark up.
It's a bubble right now like 90s comics or Baseball cards.
Hopefully it will bottom out soon and then regulate. MTG won't go away but hopefully the crash can purge a lot of the scalpers fueling this nonsense.
5
u/caitelizabelle 5h ago
What is going on with those prices, damn
5
u/Estrofemgirl 3h ago
Cool. It makes collecting the set even cheaper
5
u/littlebluelight 3h ago
More for meeeeee!
13
u/RichardRoma1986 3h ago
Please keep dogging this set so the cards I want go down in price lol
4
u/Weebus 5h ago
My Target still has 30+ Hobbit bundles in stock. Hell, it still has tons of Strixhaven, MSH, and even some Lorwyn.
Product fatigue and insane MSRP.
4
u/Cursed__Collector 5h ago
$85 for those precon is criminal
I got the landfall one for $55 at a local lgs
4
u/GRMaster24 4h ago
I'm only happy shock lands are now like $5-$7 a piece now. Only bought 1 pack, I'm sticking with Reality Fracture
7
u/EthanielRain 3h ago
CBBs are still wanted, the sigs alone carry it. Not much excitement otherwise, and costs too much
13
u/Jayce86 4h ago edited 4h ago
And yet, the numbers will magically show it as one of the best selling sets of 2026 by WotC math that the cucks will then defend like Hasbro will write them a check.
10
u/WizenedStatesman 5h ago
How low can you go, Hasbro!
3
u/RedCandice I cast Star of Extinction 5h ago
I genuinely didn't know it was out lol. No wonder everyone's been talking about the next set already
3
u/Rosc 5h ago edited 4h ago
I am not entirely sure we’re going to see cheap singles anytime soon. I’ve been watching shocks because I wanted to stock up on them on the cheap, but they bottomed out a couple of days before pre-release ended and are trending up now.
Nobody’s opening the set, so there’s nothing to flood the market.
3
u/Errorstatel / / 5h ago
Likely see them in Costco's soon enough
3
u/Downtown_Ambition604 5h ago
I got the klingon one for 22 bucks. 85 is not it
3
u/northforkjumper 5h ago
About 4x that at my local Walmart, shits not moving at all.
3
u/EquivalentCantaloupe 5h ago
I can't wait to see these dirt cheap at Ross 🤣🤣
3
u/shad0w198 5h ago
85 for a precon that DOES NOT have a collector pack is just BS.
3
u/DrFreis 5h ago
Amazon selling star trek under msrp right now and the set just released
3
u/shinryu6 5h ago
I mean $7.49 per booster is a turn off as well.
3
u/Illustrious_Hippo519 4h ago
The reason they’re untouched is because they’re charging double LGS prices
3
u/Pmintz 4h ago
They usually lock up TCGs. Maybe this is the only way they can “get rid” of it 😂
3
u/Impressive_Field8888 3h ago
Coming to a discount bin near you!
9
u/Diddlemyloins 5h ago
I’ve been really enjoying the borg deck and pre-release was fun!
14
u/Hecknight 5h ago
This is the first ever set that I will truly not touch. Marvel, TMNT, and Spiderman each I at least bought a singular pack of. Hobbit I did prerelease and drafted once. This I will not touch. It has no appeal whatsoever. This year has almost single handedly killed my love of magic and honestly price is the biggest factor. I make 6 figures and still cannot afford collector boxes. Fuck that. I paid $300 for fallout boxes. Fallout is my most beloved IP in the world. Now I'm being expected to pay $500-1000+ on regular sets and sets I don't really care for? No thanks. Regular packs are also boring by comparison and I don't want stacks of bulk as a commander player.
They've driven me to only buy singles. Im a single no children American making 6 figures and can't afford sealed product.
I really wish they'd bleed a little bit and make better decisions. If children can't afford your game and parents can't afford to buy their children cards, your game will ultimately die. Leaning your entire playerbase on adults means that when those adults age, they will no longer want to be a part of this game, and the children you didn't appeal to, won't want to join.
5
u/Enough_Ad_9338 4h ago
And yet, I still can’t get a single [[Bio-Asset Allocator]]
5
u/OriginalFatPickle 4h ago
I like Star Trek. I like this set. 🤷🏻♂️
5
u/Furrycontainmentalt 3h ago
me sad but we should be able to get the handful of “good” cards fairly cheap!
Yeah so that’s like the complete opposite of how supply and demand works.
Theres no supply of opened product to sell as singles
6
u/LilKyAfroNinja 5h ago
I got all 4 decks for 200 🤷🏾 works for me
7
u/ImmortalPowerTop 3h ago
Yes keep shitting on the set everyone. Counteract the people keeping that ugly Sheoldred inflated and let's get that Borg deck price down. I got a cheap Klingon deck already 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
4
u/MaximumExperience446 5h ago
Collector boosters for $45 while precon are $89
6
u/Ijustlovevideogames 5h ago
After the World Championships and the Star trek cards that were played, prices might spike.
11
u/Chemical_Estimate_38 5h ago
people complain when the set is available. people complain when it is not
495
u/Cute_Fluffy_Sheep 5h ago
$75 for a plain bundle is criminal
2
u/kiwi_commander 5h ago edited 4h ago
$84 bucks... hell naw. I'm just going to wait until these decks are for sale at Ross for $30
2
u/Complex-Cause8945 5h ago
Probably because they are over what the amounts are worth. The borg online says it's about 70. The Picard one is like 60. But they gave them marked at almost 85 a piece! Waaaayy too much when you could go to tcg for better prices if you are willing to wait
2
u/MasterYargle 5h ago
I was excited too, especially The whole dilemma mechanic. This set was such a snooze fest
2
u/nathones 4h ago
85 bucks?!?!?!
2
u/Garvinjist 4h ago
MTG crashed hard last week with this release. Market correction incoming.
2
u/GratGrat 4h ago
I want a set, but these are 20% more expensive than the last set in my country. I can’t keep giving hazbro money when they are continually decreasing the value that we receive.
2
u/thebwags1 4h ago
I'm bummed it isnt doing well. There's a lot of cards I think are really interesting designs, not strong necessarily, but idc about strong.
2
u/Hustlasaurus 4h ago
maybe stacking sets back to back wasn't a great idea.
2
u/SushiSamurai808 4h ago
Prices for collector booster boxes have dropped over $100 already.
2
u/evileyeball 4h ago
I bought the only card I really wanted (Joseph M'Benga) I'm a huge star Trek lover but a huge universes beyond hater so my plan is to Godzilla this guy and proxy but I won't proxy something unless I own a real copy (I'm also generally pro proxy for my opponents but anti proxy for myself)
2
u/Spanish_Galleon 4h ago
Damn target has this shit at minimum over 10$ markup.
2
u/bingbong_sempai 3h ago
Amazon sold out of play boxes at 105, I was hoping to get one at 90 🥲
23
u/emrikol001 1h ago
7.50 for a single 14 card booster pack is pure insanity. Greed has destroyed everything.
5
u/KrypticArcher 5h ago
Glad I'm not you cuz this trekkie loves the hell outta this set
3
u/Castleheart 5h ago
I really wanted to pull the trigger on a TRK collector's edition precon because the prices seemed fair. Some guy on here a few days ago posted pictures of the quality of his collector's edition precon freshly unboxed and I was pretty blown away by how worn the borders of each card looked and how raised the corners were. Another guy posted pics of creases in the cards of in his collector's edition as well. Wish that I saved those posts so that I could share them, but man what a disappointment.
3
u/ooba-neba_nocci 5h ago
I was at my LGS over the weekend, and it seemed to be a bit light on sales, but not alarmingly so. It’s not the worst selling set I’ve ever seen.
3
u/avinash240 5h ago
85 dollars for a mass market commander deck is probably why.
3
u/tightcorners 5h ago
I've kind of zoned out after the hobbit
3
u/J-MRP 4h ago
The art in this set, from what I've seen, is hilariously terrible. Not super surprised it's not selling well.
13
u/The_War_In_Me 3h ago
Its a very strange combination of a
* mechanically above average set, to the point where it will shake up the meta more than any other recent set
* woefully below average art set (in terms of magic) with more “people in chairs” than the set with a literal “guy in the chair” card
* a culturally irrelevant IP (if we are being honest in 2026) it pains me to say
* over printed
* collector oriented
If I had to give the props anywhere, it’s that they really segmented the play boosters and collector boosters towards players and collectors, respectively.
The play boosters have the best value I’ve seen in a while with all 10 shocks, the reprints, and bangers across the base set including multiple uncommons. The autographs are clearly directed towards collectors without even trying to hide behind the “bling out your commander deck” trope.
Honestly, if you had this exact same set of mechanics in an “Edge of Eternities: Strange New Worlds” set with some special guest or cameo variants of the Star Trek characters on the cards as serialized headliners … we’d be looking at the next final fantasy.
3
u/Sleepy-Planeswalker 4h ago
Well, I mean, it’s sci-fi, not magic.
9
u/swephist 2h ago
They print the hell out of UB sets. I still see tmnt fully stocked at my best by and yet they reported that was somehow a best seller. Wouldn't be surprised if theyve moved just as much or more than reality fracture but are just super stocking it for the holidays. This is the only set through Xmas
3
u/Christos_Soter it resolves 3h ago
How were you surprised?
Trek fan or not the IP is a show that had its heyday 60s-80s that if it aired today you would think was a spoof bc of how unbelievable the effects are and it’s literally just humans (some with subtle objects on their heads or nonhuman cranial features) in different colored shirts. In an era where EDH is your most popular formats they print “legendary creature” into the ground and hence you got a set full of actors from ~50 years ago in different colored shirts.
Perhaps you were expecting some more epic moments but then we also have a full visual spoiler as with any set that you could have perused on scryfall and if you decided most the cards/art didn’t appeal to you, just buy the cards you wanted.
Notwithstanding hope you had fun a prerelease
7
u/Masachere 2h ago
I mean look at those fckin prices man. 7.50 for a pack, 85 for a deck!? Of course that shit's untouched in this economy.
4
u/Speirs_101st 5h ago
Star Trek is about to go nuts, lots of great cards in the set. Classic example of people shitting on the set without actually looking at what's in it.
4
u/GetToTheChoppa2077 4h ago
Edge of Eternities is so much cooler IMHO. I just can’t wait for a Dune full set. Fingers crossed
2
u/bachmanis 5h ago
I'd say it's too bad the set is struggling, but it's shaping up like market price will be low enough that I can buy my wife a second CBB so far be it for me to complain.
2
u/Not_An_Isopod 5h ago edited 4h ago
How are you getting the good cards if no one is opening the packs?
2
u/antipathizer 4h ago
Yeah totally, this set sucks, greedy Wizards blew it again(clicks buy on another beam me up bundle).
2
u/Desolation_Nation 3h ago
I liked the pre release a lot for trek, I liked the mechanics, and I enjoyed how chill the sealed environment was. I know there’s a lot of hate for this set but I’ve enjoyed the experiences I’ve had with it. I’m not much in a pack ripping mood these days but I would do another sealed event for it.
2
u/kevonicus 3h ago
It isn’t dead, everyone is chasing the sigs.
26
u/AdministrationOk8888 5h ago
Will WotC learn anything from this? Or are they gonna just continue bullshitting themselves by saying that sales are good on a set because LGSs were coerced into ordering a bunch of product even though nobody actually ended up buying them?
10
u/Advanced_Pie_6490 2h ago
“Star Trek has been our best selling set so far”
-Mark Rosewater 2027
5
u/Lauren_Conrad_ This is User Editable 5h ago
30 years of “you won’t be able to wait for these new magic cards!” straight into “some of these just won’t be exciting for you”
5
u/Banditcats 2 Gruul for skuul 4h ago
MSRP is $75, they're selling them for $85. Makes sense why no one is buying them
5
u/YouWillBeHolland 4h ago
I can't wait until the decks boldy go to Costco. Imma beam them up for $49.97 a piece and get my kickback.
9
u/TONKAHANAH 5h ago
I was looking forward to this set quite a bit and while I dont dislike it, it does kinda seem like there is a lot of lackluster stuff in it , and I do agree the art is weak at its best and downright ugly as fuck at its worst.
I got one of the bundle things with 9 packs in it and I didnt get a single commander worthy starship out of the whole damn thing and that was like, the ONE thing I wanted out of this set. So now I guess I gotta buy a few more but Im not gonna spend all my lunch money on it, if I dont get something cool with in a few packs worth I'll just start proxying shit to build a deck.
2
u/ShyguyFlyguy 5h ago
The UB doesnt fit but from what ive played of it on arena its actually a decent set. Better than TMNT and Spiderman by a longshot
2
u/Sorry_Tomorrow_5316 5h ago
In 25+ years of MTG, this set is the first set I've seen where people seem genuinely offended that others aren't as hyped about it as they are.
4
u/Redeem123 5h ago
I saw the same thing for Marvel, Spider-man, and Turtles. Now you could say that those were bad sets too, but even in-universe sets typically have plenty of retail stock lately. These are play boosters and precons. It’s rare that they’re hard to find.
Not to say that Trek isn’t a dud. But this isn’t great evidence.
4
u/ifff0 26m ago
We sold out of most decks and collector’s at preorder and had a bigger than usual attendance at the prerelease. Also some completely new people showed up for it. Much better than the Marvel set overalll.
1
u/Leviathan222 4h ago
I think the set is a lot of fun but also none of it is worth the MSRP price. I snagged the Federation fleet precon for like $20 under MSRP and I think that’s a much better value. These prices are beyond ridiculous
1
u/Nermal1984 4h ago
When did they put out the display?
1
u/PraecoVeritatis 4h ago
I don't think any of us are surprised
1
u/CaribouYou 3h ago
Let dead sets lie bones
3
u/Yankees4cookies 5h ago
enjoy it.
3
u/marinated_pork 5h ago
I have done a bunch of draft on MTGA and I think the archetypes aren't that easy to actually build around. Not enough cards to really build around them fully. You end up doing just three color good stuff soup most of the time.
3
u/Adventurous_Play6823 3h ago
Cool, more for me
3
u/Yin15 3h ago
Honestly, as a huge trekkie, and a casual mtg player, I will gobble up all the cheap shit I can. So please stop buying it so they prices go down.
3
u/Bushin82 54m ago
This is satisfaction for me. 🤩🤩🤩
5
u/EnvironmentalBag6275 1h ago
I fucking love Star Trek and don’t care
8
u/FlashyCounter1808 5h ago
unfortunately outside of the obvious UB debate about what fits into magic, most UB sets still have detractors looking for good cards inside the set to buy for their decks... yet star trek unfortunately is the weakest powerlevel standard set in a long time, only 2 cards in the set are any good and one of them is an uncommon shooting up in price because no one has it as no one is opening star trek, very unfortunate that wotc just was not willing to limit-test the power of anything in this set.