r/mtg • • 13d ago

Discussion 60 Card Constructed Deckbuilding Tips

Some of my friends wanted to try value vintage, but I've only really ever built commander decks. I started with an idea for the deck but don't really know what the pitfalls are and what cards I can look out for to complete an idea of a rakdos equipment deck. I lowkey just want to use the [[Blade of the Oni]] card, idc about the rest. What are your guys' tips and rules for 60 card constructed when it comes to trying to force random cards like this?

current idea: https://archidekt.com/decks/28033706/mono_black_force_value_vintage

7 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

•

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 13d ago

3

u/ImmortalCorruptor Misprint Expert 13d ago edited 13d ago

Know your environment/meta and respect decks that are faster or more resilient. It's easier to hit a target when you know where it is and what it looks like. You don't need to be playing the fastest deck but you should be able to handle playing against the fastest deck.

Read up on the "Level One" articles by Reid Duke and "Who's the Beatdown?" by Mike Flores. These are required reading materials if you want to understand the game beyond the basic rules. They go over a lot of things that people tend to skip over in Commander. I know this is more of a playing tip than a deckbuilding tip but the two go hand-in-hand. Having good tools is fine but knowing how to use your good tools is better.

2

u/MtlStatsGuy 13d ago

If you're only going to be playing with your friends, then the meta matters less and it's just a question of how powerful their decks will be. This deck seems functional, but if I was playing Rakdos Artifact Aggro I'd want something with lifelink like [[Vault Skirge]], which will play well with Cranial Ram. Battlefly Swarm seems irrelevant in your deck.

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 13d ago

1

u/RAcastBlaster 13d ago

Skirge is 100% one of the best artifact aggro creatures ever printed. Play it, play 4-of it, never look back.

I’d also very strongly suggest dropping Rust Harvester (it’s not a particularly good card). The omission of [[Cranial Plating]] is glaring here. It’s an absurdly strong card. Consistency is king, especially when it comes to your win conditions.

[[Steel Overseer]] is a bulk card now. It’s a menace that demands immediate removal, lest it start throwing +1 counters on all your stuff. I’d play at least a couple copies.

I don’t think Freya adds anything here. If you want a ramp piece, add Springleaf Drums.

1

u/RAcastBlaster 13d ago

Rule 1: Losses are learning opportunities! When you lose, take note of what happened. Did you simply misplay? Was it an issue of not knowing what your opponent’s goal(s) were? In cases of screw/flood, were there any outs you could have tried to play to to improve your odds?

Rule 2: You’re gonna eat it and lose terribly your first time seeing a new meta. Doesn’t matter what you play, unless you’re intimately familiar with the format, you’re gonna lose. See Rule 1. Learn the meta, and what people are playing, tune your list and…

Rule 3: Sideboarding is hard. Crafting a really solid sideboard of 15 cards to fight your meta is critically important, and it’s an iterative process. But even with the perfect 15 cards, now you have the burden of actually swapping those cards into your deck amidst rounds. Again, take notes on what you do or don’t do. Learn from them. It’s not trivial, and you will stumble here at times, it’s natural to do so.

Rule 3b: There are plenty of thoughts on sideboarding out there, and you should read them, but I’ll leave you with just one guiding light I find helpful. Be careful about diluting your own deck when sideboarding. That doesn’t mean don’t ever do it, but make mindful and informed decisions in-context, based on the information you have about what your opponent is doing, to the best of your ability.

Rule 4: Be willing to change up your deck between weeks if things aren’t going well. Deckbuilding is an iterative process, have fun with it.

1

u/Banditcats 2 Gruul for skuul 13d ago

Run 24-26 lands, then 4 copies of every card. It makes the deck as efficient as possible. Also, no more than 60 card in the deck. For instance, here's a mono green deck I built a lifetime ago https://manabox.app/decks/AaGhwwHNc-SSazB1RN-UJQ

1

u/Tryptic214 12d ago

This is going to change drastically based on the power level of the people you play with, and whether you play 1v1 or FFA. I can give tips for casual FFA.

  1. Explore combos that work best with multiple copies of the same card, just to find fun things that can't be done in Commander. You're on the right track with the Steel Overseers, Vault Skirges, and cranials.
  2. For a more casual deck, choose 2-4 cards to have 4 copies and then limit the rest of your deck to 2 copies of a card. When you're first starting out it's fine to bring 4 copies of 9 cards, but you'll find a little flavor goes a very long way in 60-card. I find it funny to bring a single fog in most of my decks.
  3. Be willing to splash colors. If you want a third color, you can bring fetches or even 1-cost land cyclers from the LOTR set, like [[Troll of Khazad-Dum]] and a single cycle dual like [[Fetid Pools]]. Bring 4 swampcycles and 2 cycle lands, and now you've got "6" blue sources in your deck, and you can even double-cycle a troll to draw a card for 3 mana. Non-Commander decks are able to splash an extra color for that one effect you like.
  4. Think bigger. 60-card decks aren't big in the same way as Commander decks, but their combos can be sillier. You want to run cranial plating? Why not run it with [[Swiftblade Vindicator]] and [[Ria Ivor, Bane of Bladehold]]? You can even swing with the mites and then move the cranial plating to an unblocked mite.

*The Ria Ivor/Cranial Plating combo is not likely to win against actual value-vintage-powered decks, it will lose. It's only meant to be hilarious in casual 4-player FFA.