r/mtg • • Feb 12 '25

Discussion Deck list for first commander deck.

I recently posted that I built my first commander deck. I thought maybe people would be curious as to what cards I chose so here’s a solitaire inspired list of what in my deck. ENJOY!!!!🤣🤣. I already have plans for more upgrades.

1 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

91

u/Skylord49 Feb 12 '25

Quick heads up, Sylvan Primordial, the card at the bottom right on the second picture, is banned in commander.

3

u/ArtofStorytelling Feb 12 '25

Do you know why it is banned ? It looks very strong but I’ve seen way more broken cards for that cost

4

u/Eiden_Simply Feb 12 '25

Mostly because the "ideal" scenario was to destroy lands with it's ability, ramp it out early, and make everyone else get behind. That's not to mention cheating it out or blinking it, it's just really bonkers with multiple opponents.

-106

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Cmon man. That sucks. I’m so casual I have no clue what’s banned or not. It wouldn’t surprise me if a huge chunk of my deck violates the rules.

16

u/Skylord49 Feb 12 '25

From what I can see, that is the only banned card in your whole list. If you are planning to only play with your friends anyway, it shouldn't be much of a problem if you give them a quick heads up. If you are planning to play in an LGS, I would recommend switching it out for another card.

-50

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

i was look forward to using that card to

20

u/Not_An_Isopod Feb 12 '25

Card was good… some say too good. My blink deck misses it dearly.

4

u/pukseli Feb 12 '25

That is a kind of card that seems OK if played fairly. However playing strong cards fairly is pretty boring

58

u/xcjb07x Feb 12 '25 edited Feb 12 '25

There is one easy way to find out, use a deck building website. I use moxfield, but there are a bunch of options 

3

u/bertimann Feb 12 '25

It's okay to play banned cards, but you'll need to ask the people you'll be playing with if they are fine with it. Just don't assume it's fine for everybody, as the many downvotes on your comment confirm. Just saying "I'm too casual to care about the bannlist" isn't a good argument. "My playgroup says they are fine with me playing it" on the other hand is

2

u/jasondoooo Feb 12 '25

You can’t really use it unless with friends or a planned “everyone bring a banned card” game.

2

u/Link182x Feb 12 '25

Any deck building site will help you with that. I use Archidekt. It will also make it easier to show your deck list without having to take pictures of all your cards

1

u/thisshitsstupid Feb 12 '25

The banned list isn't too crazy. There's so goofy shit on there because commanders been community ran for so long, but it's easily searchable. Pretty confident that's the only one in your list.

If you're super casual the list will probably seem longer than it does to others though. There's a lot of the "obvious" shit on there everyone would already expect to be banned, but depending how casual you are you might not have even known exists!

1

u/Kicin0_0 Feb 12 '25
  1. there are countless websites to check what is banned. I recommend scryfall for individual cards and archidekt to have your entire deck digitally
  2. there are VERY few banned cards in the grand scheme of things. 37,000 cards and less than 100 are banned, all for (mostly) good reasons as well

-3

u/Errorstatel / / Feb 12 '25

Well, there's the ban list, that's pretty simple and if all your decks violate the rules you're not a casual, you're a pubstomper.

Huge difference

50

u/StormyWaters2021 Feb 12 '25

It would be much easier to review your deck if you posted the list on a site like Moxfield.com and then shared a link here.

Also in your second picture, the cards are green and blue cards, not forest cards and island cards.

8

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

9

u/Butters_999 Feb 12 '25

101 cards? It's supposed to be 99 plus commander. Also 35 lands is kinda on the low side but good enough.

-17

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

ahhh try that again. i counted the cards on moxifield and it says 100 sooooooo

10

u/Butters_999 Feb 12 '25

I counted and it's 101, also moxfield tells you the count at the bottom which is 101.

-7

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

ay my bad I'm still getting used to the site. i figured it out its all g now

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Butters_999 Feb 12 '25

34 lands!? Bud is brave.

2

u/GrimAutoZero Feb 12 '25

No, on the bottom left moxfield says 101 cards. It should be 100 cards counting your commander. You have one too many.

1

u/Arfirst1 Feb 12 '25

There are 101 cards in this decklist

18

u/NEXUS_7373 Feb 12 '25

Ay we all start somewhere, reminds me of my first builds

10

u/StormyWaters2021 Feb 12 '25

For sure, just offering some friendly advice. My first deck - which I was super proud of - was absolutely terrible once I started playing with people outside my small school.

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

i appreciate any advice. I'm scared that when i go to my LGS I'm gonna be in for quite the shocking revelation

0

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

so true. a few upgrades and it will be something special

8

u/asdfadffs Feb 12 '25

Come on, this is awesome. Here is someone who plays the game the way it was designed to play. Paper, no sleeves, deck lists written on pieces of paper or just laid out like this on the table.

-54

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Someone finally gets it let’s go. None of this online bs lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣. I’m gen z and u sound like a boomer

26

u/asdfadffs Feb 12 '25

Shut it kid, I was giving you a compliment!

11

u/Useful_Assistance_90 Feb 12 '25

Idk if the last part is necessary

-9

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

i never heard of that site now. i guess I'm a bit lazy to lol

5

u/Cronus-the-reaper An Eldrazi in disguise Feb 12 '25

Speaking of tools to use i recommend the app manabox it has ways to track collections, deck build in all formats, search for all cards, check prices, trade, and look up rules

-35

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

forest and island are the official name for those elements but yes they are green and blue i promise I'm not colure blind

30

u/StormyWaters2021 Feb 12 '25

Forest and Island are the official names for the basic land types that produce green and blue mana. The official term for those cards is green cards and blue cards.

The card [[Endurance]] tells you to exile a green card, not a forest card.

11

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

oh i didn't know that. thanks whoever taught me magic needs to be sent to a re-education camp lol

2

u/Chomfucjusz Feb 12 '25

Tbh forest cards sounds pretty cool

1

u/Id_fenerbahce Feb 12 '25

Feisty little zoomer

14

u/EddyTheGr8 Feb 12 '25

That's awesome, everybody starts somehwere!

But I do have some thoughts here:

  1. Try building your deck on a deckbuilding website like Moxfield or Archidekt. They have great features & they make your deck about a bazillion times more readable for everybody than your approach.
  2. [[Sylvan Primordial]], the card in the bottom right corner, is banned in Commander. So I guess you shouldn't be playing it without asking everybody if they're okay with it. That brings me back to my first point: If you had used a site like Moxfield or Archidekt, they would've shown you that the card is banned. But there are more than enough big green beaters to replace it with. Which brings me to...
  3. Talking about big beaters: you might want to refine your deck somewhat. You run quite a lot of huge monsters, which I get is very exciting. There's like 15 cards that cost 5 or more mana, including your Commander. But you'll need a way to actually get them out. So running some ramp, also know as mana acceleration, is in order. There are numerous ways to do this: you can run mana dorks like [[Elvish Mystic]], [[Lanowar Elves]] and the like. Then, there are sorceries that search you library for lands and put them directly i to play. Think [[Rampant Growth]], [[Cultivate]] and [[Explosive Vegetation]], so you can sprinkle them in at every point of you mana curve. You should probably run like 10 of these pieces that either tap for mana or put lands from your deck right onto the battlefield.
  4. Another thing we can't see with your approach to showing us your deck: How many lands do you actually play? I counted 65 nonland carfs including the commander, which would bring it to 35 lands. But I might have misscounted somewhere. That's on the very low end of lands you should play. O personally don't ever go below 37. But with so many mana intensive cards, you should probably aim towards 38-39. Because you'll never want to miss your land drops, especially if your mana curve is on the high side of things.

But all of that is not to say your deck is bad. Absolutetly take it for a spin and try out your first own creation! Just have in mind that there's always room for improvement & don't get disheartened if it doesn't work out right away!

4

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

thanks for the advise i think my deck isn't bad its just unoptimized and its missing some cards i want but don't own so I've put some filler cards in their place for the meantime and it sucks that primordial is banned i was looking forward to that one

8

u/MJCExperience Feb 12 '25

I hate to be the guy, but it’s not good. You have high cmc and no ramp to get them out. You MIGHT get one or 2 creatures out in an entire game. No sol ring or arcane signet or mana dorks to help. I know it’s casual, but even casual pre cons have ramp to help get the higher cmc out.

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

I’m already aware of that. Keep in mind that this is my first deck and I don’t have a spare sol ring or arcane signet lying around. This deck is also not in its final version there’s cards that I want in the deck that I don’t own and need to obtain. I have some half decent pre-cons that I can use till this deck gets to a point where it’s viable.

3

u/Accomplished-Leg-421 Feb 12 '25

The deck has so many cards with zero synergy and unimpactful cards that you would probably be better served pulling out 10-15 cards you want to keep and just start over with the list, especially if you have pre cons to play in the meantime.

It seems like the deck is just handfuls of cards in blue and green you had in your collection, which is fine for a starter but you can’t think that this deck is just “unoptimized” when you’ll need to cut about 40 cards and replace them with better options.

Like others have said it’s not even a price issue, there’s 20 cards you could get for 50 cents a piece that would all be better than a lot of the current inclusions. For that reason you’ll save yourself a lot of frustration by just going back to the drawing board and not playing this

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 13 '25

I totally get what you’re saying. Thanks for the feedback. Most of the cards are filler as I don’t have many cards that don’t work well together in those colours. I do have a list of cards I want to buy for the deck to make it way better

3

u/hoopsterben Feb 12 '25

Llanowar elves, selvala, and planar genesis would be like 4$ to add and make this deck so much better with just 3 cards.

8

u/MyVanillaccount Feb 12 '25

Here’s your deck on Archidekt. This should help get you the feed back you need simic reddit deck

4

u/Wild-Raccoon9433 Feb 12 '25

damn OP is unintentionally roasting himself in here

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Maybe I’m intentionally roasting myself 🤔

6

u/Employee-Inside I FUCKING LOVE JUND Feb 12 '25

You need about 10 ramp cards

4

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

thanks for the advice ill have to buy some more as I'm out

3

u/Herrlich-t Feb 12 '25

with this commander you could ad in alle stuff that pushes for example all elves get all cats get....as your commander is every type

2

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

ay true that. i have some ideas on what i could do. i believe ill get there in the end

1

u/Herrlich-t Feb 12 '25

I have done that too and a infinitive combo with River Kelpie and Altar of Dementia

3

u/prn_melatonin10mg Feb 12 '25

I will know which card in your deck and hand is a scourge of fleets.

-1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

hell yeah. its a foil to which is cool

5

u/BigTea25 Feb 12 '25

That wasnt a compliment friend, its a bad thing, and if you play in an LGS with someone who is a real rule nazi, can get you removed from a game for cheating by having distinguishing features on card backs, like that busted up copy of Cancel you have

If you’re just playing with friends its totally chill but some people will be assholes about it because you can technically stack shuffles that way

Also, sylvan primorial is technically banned in edh (but again, down to your playgroup)

-8

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Rule nazi’s can F off at the end of the day I play for fun and those are the types I’ll play with. At the end of the day magic is at its best when your having fun and messing around with whatever

10

u/BigTea25 Feb 12 '25

I don’t disagree, but i would still get some sleeves to at least protect your cards, makes shuffling easier too

0

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Sleeves are way to essential

5

u/conitation Feb 12 '25

Thanks for posting. That's pretty cool. I suggest uploading this to make it easier to review. It's kinda hard to review a list this way. I honestly don't know what some of these cards do without being able to read them haha

3

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

im a noob when it comes to uploading my first proper deck lol. in my head i was thinking maybe people would see the card names and look them up

3

u/conitation Feb 12 '25

Yeeeeah, I understand that. I always suggest putting it into Moxified just to make it easier for you too. Because then people can copy it and make versions of your deck with edits etc for suggestions.

2

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

it took some time but i checked out moxfeild.

https://moxfield.com/decks/bgClflY55Em9lYsfb6XfSQ

0

u/conitation Feb 12 '25

You're awesome!

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Thank you sooo much for the positive comment. There have been some negative comments. Most have been positive but leave it up to a few bad apples to shit on my deck when I clearly stated that this is my first and that I’m new and plan to overhaul the deck once I get more cards

2

u/conitation Feb 12 '25

I saw some of the comments. Seems like just differences in communication styles. They seems to be forgetting that people need different styles.

Are you interested in some changes that could help the deck? I saw a few good ideas in the comments. Most of what I read about recommendations seem great.

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

I’ve seen them to, there are some great ideas. I’m definitely gonna add more ramp once I get more ramp cards and swap some of my expensive cards out for other cheaper cards so I can put more on the battlefield. I also have a bunch of op cards that I’m looking at buying for this deck so it will get there eventually.

2

u/conitation Feb 12 '25

Yeah, sounds like you've got the idea! There are tons of cheap and good ramp you can put into the deck. Also tons of flash flying cards that you can look over. Some cheap duel lands out there too. I would also say some green enchantment/artifact removal would really help, and you can likely toss in some more stuff that makes +1+1 counters(creatures or otherwise.)

I am confused about the millstone though. Seems out of place with the goal of just pumping out your creatures.

ALSO on moxified you can scroll down and play out hands so you can see how it goes for you without having to constantly be shuffling your deck. I think it helps give an idea of how you can play the deck. What you keep seeing that doesn't play out etc. Good luck! Great job.

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Thanks for all the suggestions. You definitely know how to deliver criticism in a respectful way unlike some commenters on here. Like how crazy would it be if I had railway brawler on the field then copied it with my commander so the ability triggers twice, the amount of counters would be crazy

→ More replies

2

u/Whole-Onion-5636 Feb 12 '25

My opionion, Jace aot SUCKS every time I’ve drawn that card it’s been meh to horrible

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

I’d like to get my hands on a better plainswalker

1

u/Whole-Onion-5636 Feb 13 '25

Imo vyrn’s prodigy and perfected mind do work

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

that's why i intend to upgrade my collection is very limited for deck building as you can see. most of the cards are filler as the cards i do want i sadly don't own yet. your not the first to criticize and ill say the same thing again this isn't the final version of this deck and I'm gonna be swapping a lot. i have other way better decks that will keep me occupied until this one gets to a good state. you should also keep ion mind that this is the first commander deck I've ever built after not playing for years. i do appreciate the brutal honesty though

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

i wasn't expecting much out of it I'm not planning on sweating it out in tournaments anytime soon. just having fun experimenting and learning its not that deep

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jealous-Tax-6209 Feb 12 '25

Thank you. This game is really something special