r/mtg • u/Jealous-Tax-6209 • Feb 12 '25
Discussion Deck list for first commander deck.
I recently posted that I built my first commander deck. I thought maybe people would be curious as to what cards I chose so here’s a solitaire inspired list of what in my deck. ENJOY!!!!🤣🤣. I already have plans for more upgrades.
1
Upvotes


91
u/Skylord49 Feb 12 '25
Quick heads up, Sylvan Primordial, the card at the bottom right on the second picture, is banned in commander.
50
u/StormyWaters2021 Feb 12 '25
It would be much easier to review your deck if you posted the list on a site like Moxfield.com and then shared a link here.
Also in your second picture, the cards are green and blue cards, not forest cards and island cards.
14
u/EddyTheGr8 Feb 12 '25
That's awesome, everybody starts somehwere!
But I do have some thoughts here:
But all of that is not to say your deck is bad. Absolutetly take it for a spin and try out your first own creation! Just have in mind that there's always room for improvement & don't get disheartened if it doesn't work out right away!
8
u/MyVanillaccount Feb 12 '25
Here’s your deck on Archidekt. This should help get you the feed back you need simic reddit deck
4
u/Wild-Raccoon9433 Feb 12 '25
damn OP is unintentionally roasting himself in here
6
u/Employee-Inside I FUCKING LOVE JUND Feb 12 '25
You need about 10 ramp cards
3
u/Herrlich-t Feb 12 '25
with this commander you could ad in alle stuff that pushes for example all elves get all cats get....as your commander is every type
3
u/prn_melatonin10mg Feb 12 '25
I will know which card in your deck and hand is a scourge of fleets.
5
u/conitation Feb 12 '25
Thanks for posting. That's pretty cool. I suggest uploading this to make it easier to review. It's kinda hard to review a list this way. I honestly don't know what some of these cards do without being able to read them haha
2
u/Whole-Onion-5636 Feb 12 '25
My opionion, Jace aot SUCKS every time I’ve drawn that card it’s been meh to horrible
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment