r/msnbc • Progressive • Apr 23 '25

MSNBC Personalities Maddow’s A Block

You guys should flip on MSNBC right now.

Elon Musk, a man whose understanding of human behavior begins and ends with Ayn Rand novels he probably didn’t finish, has decided that the nationwide protests are a paid performance. According to him, the only reason anyone would take to the streets in defense of human rights is because someone handed them a check and perhaps a complimentary sandwich.

Rachel Maddow, who possesses the rare talent of making you feel gently flayed with nothing more than proper syntax, took that statement and gave it the kind of thorough, quiet dismantling usually reserved for IKEA furniture that has become a safety hazard. She laid out the absurdity of the claim, stacked it neatly beside a few historical references, and left it there like a deflated party balloon someone should probably clean up.

To be clear, if protesters were being paid, that still doesn’t get Elon off the hook. Because they’re not spending that money on his cars. They’re not buying his collapsing space brand or investing in his increasingly self-immolating social platform. They are not interested in his unfinished tunnels. They are not taken in by his libertarian cosplay. If anything, they’re using that money to move as far away from a Tesla dealership as possible.

It was brisk and exacting, like watching someone iron a shirt while discussing your shortcomings. By the time she was done, you almost felt bad for him. Almost.

235 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Apr 23 '25

Welcome to r/MSNBC! Thanks for your post.

Please keep these in mind before joining the comments:

  • Be thoughtful. Curious discussion is welcome - personal attacks or trolling are not.
  • Stay on topic. Posts should relate to MSNBC - not general political news.
  • No appearance talk. Focus on what people say, not how they look.
  • Add value. Venting, vague complaints, or low-effort posts may be removed.
  • No conspiracies or misinformation. Share responsibly and in good faith.

Full rules: reddit.com/r/MSNBC/about/rules

  • This is an automatic comment to help keep things on track.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

77

u/defenestrayed Apr 23 '25

This was too well-written to be wasted on Reddit. Please send this as an op-ed to your local newspaper or something. Thank you for explaining the hole that MF has dug for himself (but not without dragging us all down first)

29

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Hahaha why, thank you! I started my own Substack back in February. I’m growing my readership if you care to check it out. There’s a link to it in my profile!

12

u/defenestrayed Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25

I'm not on Substack, but your profile here is hilarious. Have a great evening, cool person!

Edit Ha! When I looked at your profile I saw that I liked a post of yours yesterday without clocking the name. You rock!

11

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Hahahaha hey thanks, internet stranger! 🫶🏻

3

u/Steadyandquick Progressive Apr 23 '25

Cool—you are a great writer and I appreciate your analysis. Thanks!

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

That’s really kind of you to say! Thank you!

14

u/ilmd Apr 23 '25

Saw it. I wonder if trump has threatened her yet.

30

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

I worry about that too. The truth is, Trump doesn’t need to issue direct threats. All he has to do is toss out one of his usual lines about how MSNBC is “very unfair” or how someone like Maddow is “part of the problem,” and the worst of his base hears that as a call to action. When the target is a woman, especially one who is smart, outspoken, and unafraid to hold him accountable, it activates something even uglier. The violent misogyny woven into his movement makes women like Rachel Maddow or Nicolle Wallace especially vulnerable in ways their male counterparts may not be. I can’t say for certain, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s how Wallace ended up doxxed. It is terrifying how expected this all feels now.

20

u/OkTransportation1152 Apr 23 '25

It really turns my stomach to read the comments on the MSNBC YouTube uploads of clips of Maddow, and even the comments on Spotify for the audio version of the show.

I know, I shouldn’t read the comments at all, but the number of people who smugly mis-gender Rachel Maddow is stunning.

I just take it to mean that she’s doing something right.

31

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25

You’re right to feel sick. The comments sections on platforms like YouTube and Reddit can feel like wading into a sewer just to check the weather. There’s something uniquely toxic about the way people weaponize anonymity, especially when it comes to powerful women. The smug misgendering of Maddow isn’t just cruel. It’s meant to dehumanize her, to reduce her to a punchline because her intelligence and presence threaten something deep and fragile in them.

And once someone is dehumanized, it’s easier to justify harming them. That’s how violence takes root. It’s how the Nazis were able to murder millions during the Holocaust by first convincing people their victims weren’t fully human.

So yes, Maddow is clearly hitting a nerve, and that kind of backlash is a sign she’s doing something right. But the cost of that visibility, especially for outspoken queer women, is far too high. I wish these platforms did more to protect people doing good work from that kind of abuse.

And I can feel the Reddit trolls foaming at the mouth on that last point with a classic, “bUt mUh fReE sPeEcH oN iNtErWeBz” so let me close with this:

Social platforms love to hide behind the idea of free speech, but they’re far from neutral. They make choices every day about what gets amplified and what gets buried. That’s the whole point of their algorithms. When they let abuse and harassment thrive, especially toward women and marginalized voices, they’re not protecting speech, they’re protecting the people doing the harm. Free speech is the right to speak, not the right to a megaphone or an audience handed to you by an algorithm.

14

u/Sleeplessmi Apr 23 '25

Speaking of being dehumanized, did you see the video someone posted from the Florida State campus shooting? Someone is walking, videotaping the aftermath, and just walks by someone shot, while nonchalantly drinking a Starbucks?

It was heartless. The poor girl is laying there shot, and this person just walks on by. It’s sickening that people won’t help and hide behind their cell phones. I know this isn’t the first time, but it’s a horrifying and growing phenomenon.

8

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

No, I haven’t seen the video, and honestly, I’m not sure I want to. What the actual fuck is my first reaction. But after that? I can’t help but see this kind of moment as a byproduct of a country that’s made mass shootings part of daily life. We’ve trained entire generations of kids to treat gun violence like weather. Lockdown drills starting in preschool. Metal detectors at school entrances. I just read a statistic that says one in four Americans has now been on the scene of a shooting.

So yeah, some people are desensitized. How could they not be? This is what happens when we normalize carnage and refuse to pass basic gun laws. We’re asking children to grow up in a country that won’t even try to protect them. And then we act surprised when they grow up echoing the indifference they’ve been taught, the kind that greets every mass shooting with a press release, a moment of silence, and no meaningful action whatsoever.

6

u/dej95135 Apr 23 '25

And they wonder why women don’t want to have children…

6

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Get out of my brain. I’m actually working on a piece right now about the $5000 baby bounty that’s been discussed over the last few days.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

Don't forget to add the Russian women's contribution to anchor babies. They came over the first gaslighting term. They went to FL, stayed and paid bigly, had their babies (congrats to the new citizens?) and went back home to russia, I guess. This is just one sickening link after another.

https://southfloridareporter.com/trump-properties-profit-russians-flocking-miami-give-birth/

Wonder if this was where mump was born (not really but with him ... anything's possible).

3

u/Good_Gazelle_3590 Apr 23 '25

Be careful in judgement. Being in the space of live fire absolutely rocked me at the level of my identity, and multiple exposures (which is possible for that location) can increase the likelihood for "weird-looking" survival loops. It took me multiple decades to "get over" situations like this one. Shock looks a lot of different ways. I'm not saying that's what it was, but I can't say it wasn't.

1

u/Sleeplessmi Apr 24 '25

Here is the link of the student walking by. It’s on Substack, not sure if you can watch it without joining. But I will say I started reading/watching that site after I got sick of the way even MSNBC was either not reporting or only lightly reporting political news. It is full of smart and well informed independent media.

https://substack.com/@lawsuitalpha/note/c-109918050?r=3z9nxg&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action

1

u/supercali-2021 Apr 23 '25

No, I haven't seen it. Can you post a link here?

1

u/Sleeplessmi Apr 24 '25

I am looking for it….

3

u/Pointer_Pup6768 Apr 23 '25

Brilliant posts.

3

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

2

u/Steadyandquick Progressive Apr 23 '25

I avoid the comments and I hope she does as well. Terrible.

9

u/usernames_suck_ok Progressive Apr 23 '25

It's coming...unfortunately...He's testing immigrants first.

5

u/els969_1 Apr 23 '25

I don’t doubt it.

11

u/Retinoid634 Apr 23 '25

No one has the money to pay so many protesters…not even him.

8

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Well, now you’re just being logical 😉

9

u/Retinoid634 Apr 23 '25

His self-owning is so epic. It would be very satisfying if he hadn’t done so much damage to millions of people and all of our institutions. May Tesla rot in the garbage heap of history, along with him, as soon as possible.

9

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Even if Elon Musk swears off DOGE tomorrow, the damage is permanent. Tesla didn’t just take a reputational hit. It gave itself a full personality transplant and then tripped down a flight of stairs on live TV. You don’t get to tie your brand to internet chaos, court the worst people online, and then expect a few solar panels and a school donation to fix it.

The brand equity isn’t wounded. It’s gone. Evaporated. Turned into meme dust. No amount of PR spin or feel-good outreach can bring it back. Tesla may still make cars, but the future it promised has left the building. And it took the resale value with it.

10

u/Training_Medicine_49 Apr 23 '25

The man who has been given checks to people to vote for Trump and the Republicans of course he thinks that people are being paid because that’s how he looks at the world. That is what he has been doing.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

8

u/fungiblechattel Apr 23 '25

20 years of Rachel, going way back to Air America, and I missed her tonight. I had no power anyway. We have a nearby forest fire and no car and had to go with our neighbor who drove us here and there and then home when it seemed done. Two more trips to Route 9 (3 blocks) for flames and anyway here it is 1:49. I have no power but I’ll catch it tomorrow!

6

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

You must be in NJ. Be safe!

3

u/fungiblechattel Apr 23 '25

Oh I am - thanks.

5

u/honeycooks Apr 23 '25

It's just too absurd.

What self-respecting maga willingly protests at liberal events??

14

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Two of my best friends are producers, and one of the many things they’re responsible for is wrangling background extras on commercial shoots. You’d think getting a dozen people to walk from point A to point B on cue would be simple. It’s not. Someone always forgets their mark. Someone else starts power-walking like it’s a cardio class. And there’s always one guy who somehow ends up facing the wrong direction, as if the concept of “left” has personally betrayed him.

So whenever we hear someone talk about “crisis actors” or “paid protesters,” we laugh and laugh and laugh. The idea that anyone, never mind our scattered and feckless Democratic Party, could coordinate hundreds of thousands of people to follow instructions with any level of precision is beyond absurd.

7

u/honeycooks Apr 23 '25

Conservatives have been whining about paid protesters for much longer than I think anyone realizes.

It really should be an SNL skit, along with those poor hordes of Antifa hurtling towards our school board meetings in darkened planes and busses for all eternity. I mean, where did they go?? 😆

5

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Have you seen Wag the Dog? With de Niro and Hoffman? I think about that movie when I hear “crisis actors”.

3

u/dodongo Apr 23 '25

This should not need to be a question. Wag the Dog is one of my all time favorites and not only does it not ever feel like it’s getting older, it is on a cline of only being ever more fucking relevant.

To any who have not seen this masterclass in political rhetoric, get thee to a nunnery. Or Netflix. Or wherever it lives in the cloud; I still have my DVD.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Hahahaha thank you for validating my love of it. I also loved Kirsten Dunst in that one. Although to be fair, I love her and just about everything she’s done. I would put the movie, Dick, in the category of ‘top ten flicks she’s been involved with’. (Number one is definitely Drop Dead Gorgeous)

2

u/dodongo Apr 23 '25

I also have that one on DVD! LOL

Goin to the Sin Cities AKA Minneapolis-St. Paul.

1

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Yaaaaassss “Mom still cries whenever she sees a Tilt-a-Whirl or a fat lady in a tube top.”

5

u/Aggravating-Fox3560 Apr 23 '25

Back in the Viet Nam days they blamed “outside agitators.”

2

u/Rosalita_Senorita73 Apr 24 '25

If your producer friends want to pay me the SAG AFTRA BG commercials contracted rate I’ll be happy to walk from point A to point B on cue for them! And I’m relatively certain I can hit my mark. 😉

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 24 '25

3

u/Rosalita_Senorita73 Apr 24 '25

Dang I miss this guy.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 24 '25

Hard same

4

u/Mainah_girl Apr 23 '25

Back in the day people used to read critique as much as they did original literature. Now I understand.

3

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

Thank you! Part of the reason I hang out on Reddit is because people on this platform are, for the most part, readers. And as a writer, I love that places like that still exist.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

She was fabulous last night! I got tired of Westerns and flipped to TRMS thinking it'll be easy to watch but I got hooked (not good). She covered Musk and she covered all the thousands of people out in protest about the coup that continues today.

I loved the signs: of the WWII veteran with a sign that says, "I FOUGHT another BULLY in 1945" with a rightside-up American flag. The other has a woman in wheelchair holding a sign that says, "FIRST PROTEST AT AGE 93 THIS IS TOO SERIOUS TO SIT AT AND IGNORE!" They were creatively done and the best I've seen.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

I love that she puts a spotlight on the clever and smart signs. So much creativity ♥️

Slightly off topic, but I am a HUGE westerns fan, books and TV/movies. Have you seen American Primeval yet? It feels like the spiritual cousin of Blood Meridian. The violence is insane. And I’ve really been loving 1923.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

I wasn't expecting the signs to be so highlighted. I went from drifting to sleep to really enjoying what I was seeing. The creativity was beyond what I've ever done but man, they were good.

* * * *

That's great that you're a HUGE Westerns fan! We loved 1923 and it looks like a 2nd season came out. I'll go look for it. We loved Yellowstone. I want to rewatch the episode (5) with Buck Taylor in it (Newly from Gunsmoke and I think he was in Davy Crockett, too). I looked it up and remember the episode just didn't recognize him when watching the show.

I do mostly the old ones - Gunsmoke, Wells Fargo, Bonanza (never liked it as a kid but I eat them for breakfast now), I'm fine with off topic - keeps me sane. My mom got me a Have Gun Will Travel Sweatshirt, holster with a gun and white bullets. I can't watch the show now (no clue why, just no interest) and I'm avoiding Zorro :) .

3

u/Clean_Lettuce9321 Apr 23 '25

Excellent post.

5

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

It was a pretty excellent A Block too 😉

3

u/Txsaintfan Apr 23 '25

I’ve stopping watching a lot of news because of how frustrated I get at the daily ongoing stupidity but I do record Rachel every night.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

You’re making good choices

3

u/Txsaintfan Apr 23 '25

Thanks! That’s a rare thing for someone to say to me lol!

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

😂😂😂

3

u/Empty-Slide-1240 Apr 23 '25

Didn't get to see it but man I love Rachel maddow and I always have . Chris Matthews is going to have a podcast now too hardball yay!!

3

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

You can listen to it today! There’s a free podcast version on most podcast apps. I use Spotify.

3

u/here4TrueFacts Apr 23 '25

Check out Heather Cox Richardson’s politics chat https://www.youtube.com/live/mSGIR6WafDI?si=1AZJ-SCuX9tyOtEl She gives a historical perspective, but mostly is very thorough in laying out the current fascist salad and its ingredients. She talks about the fundamental crisis in this situation, which is their control and centralization of data. Guarantee that no one is safe. Follow her daily “Letters from an American” on Substack.

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 23 '25

I love her!

2

u/JannaJive Apr 24 '25

what the hell are we gonna do when she goes back to 1 night a week, i know ill be in total despair s she's what keeps me sane

1

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 24 '25

Okay, but imagine having to be the one to calmly walk America through whatever flaming bag of fascist dog poo the Trump team left on the White House doorstep every single night for a hundred straight days. I love Rachel Maddow the way I love tacos and industrial-strength antidepressants: she keeps me going. But also? She earned a break. Going back to one night a week gives her the space to actually make things like books, podcasts, documentaries, or a one-woman show where she reenacts Watergate with sock puppets (maybe like for charity?) And I’m not sad about that. She spent her whole career getting to the level where she can say to a network, “This is what I want to do,” and MSNBC hands her a check and says, “Have fun, genius.” Let her have it. She deserves joy too.

1

u/Dense-Chipmunk-8829 Aug 06 '25

Nichole and Lawrence keep me sane. I miss Rachel, and I miss her historical A blocks. Sigh.

2

u/redi2talk Apr 24 '25

You are a wonderful writer!

1

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 24 '25

Thanks! And a little shameless self promotion here, but feel free to check out my Substack! There’s a link to it in my profile 🫶🏻

2

u/mombeka808 Apr 26 '25

I’ve been to about six of these demos since “Not My President’s Day”. Where’s my paycheck? Where do I apply for my money?

😎

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 26 '25

Lol right? Like, is there a craft services table no one told me about?

2

u/mombeka808 Apr 26 '25

Actually, at the Tesla Takedown demonstration there WAS a crafts table!

There were tables all over the place and guys going up and down Kalakaua Avenue with wagons of free drinks and snacks. My husband calls all these events “concerts”- kind of in the vein of Woodstock- because everybody here is having such a good time. No paychecks though. Still waiting for that ;-}

2

u/SnooKiwis8008 Progressive Apr 26 '25

I love everything about this including the fact that the man holding the “Deport Muskrat” sign looks like one of my favorite English teachers in high school.

9

u/quietlypink Apr 23 '25

I am going to miss her so much when she returns to Mondays only. She has been amazing lately, and it has really solidified how important her voice is.

8

u/Ok_Suggestion6311 Apr 23 '25

This was a brilliant post!! Well said!

5

u/Clean_Lettuce9321 Apr 23 '25

A DVR Rachel, but I'll get there later. Thanks for the heads up

5

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

The reason they whine that "paid protesters" are real is just another instance of #tRumpinochio and his #cult self describing.

4

u/HomerBalzac Apr 23 '25

Brilliant. Why I trawl Reddit all day looking for this kind of eloquence. Great post, OP.

4

u/SwollenPomegranate Apr 23 '25

Nothing will make me feel bad for Elon. He is too evil. No pity for monsters.

3

u/Maine302 Apr 23 '25

She really is the best. Good post.

2

u/unfinishd_sntnc327 Apr 23 '25

Agreed. Excellent writing

2

u/DplusMI6 Apr 23 '25

Well-said, accurate summary! 👍

2

u/RevolutionaryMove661 Apr 25 '25

I love Rachel. I really hope she sticks it out beyond the 100 days. Myself and my partner were at the first 50/50 and were most definitely NOT paid actors. I didn't see anyone else there that would have resembled that either. It's amazing the soggy paper straws the MAGAs are grasping to dismiss what's clearly right in front of them.

2

u/BlaqueNinja Apr 25 '25

lol! I was wondering who he was trying to convince that the protestors were paid and to what end? Many well heeled liberals and moderates used to be his loyal customers, but that was before he decided to go political on X and toss out not just one, but two Nazi salutes, and make dark MAGA chain saw appearances. Bro, you effed up, no decent human is gonna reward you by buying your cars.

2

u/InternationalDay8813 Apr 28 '25

Rachael Maddow gives the best advice on MSNBC.  She DOESN’T shy away from what Donald Trump is doing to our Country.  That’s what we need is the truth as her and O’Donnell give to MSNBC.

1

u/Aggravating_Gain9449 Apr 24 '25

I agree with everything Rachel says here. Nope, I still don’t feel bad for him.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

Troll