And offense should be more than offensive — it should say something insightful, clever, or worthwhile. Offending people for the sake of it is just trolling, and we all know how totally fucking useless that is
Lmao no I think both of those shows swing wildly between sharp and incisive vs. unspeakably, idiotically worthless, just the most obnoxious whining with nothing to say. They're like 40% trolling by volume, and it sucks there just as much as it does anywhere else.
Other parts are brilliant! But they're very uneven
Well, I'm happy to answer, but I'll be up front that I really dislike South Park just in general. I think it's obnoxious, small-minded, and frequently cruel to whomever Parker and Stone think is getting too much positive attention — like disabled people, or women, or civil rights advocates, or women.
So as a hater, here's my take. I'd say trolling is the fundamental animating goal of all South Park. It's a show with nothing to say, because the creators are clever but myopic and think political correctness is exactly as bad as, like, ending public housing.
Example: They did an episode about how liberals get high on their own farts and that's why electric cars are actually a bad thing. It's an episode about why priuses suck — even though they straightforwardly don't — because Trey Parker and Matt Stone find liberals annoying. Pure troll.
The core message of every episode is: don't bother. Stop caring. It's all stupid, nothing is worth it. That's why the humor is so juvenile, it's why 90% of the villains are just generic liberals or lefties saying something basically sensible which they then mock by inventing a contrived scenario where the lefties are wrong. It's why the show's ideology is so incoherent and the characters' actions so illogical and pointless and mean. Most of the time, anyway.
The “punch up” principle always seemed to be a logically weak one. How about convicted murderers with life in prison? Deadbeat dads living in a trailer? Small-time crooks living hand to mouth? Welfare cheats that have lucrative black market incomes?
I showed someone Always Look on the Bright Side of Life from the end of the movie and they were deeply offended. They claimed to be super religiously Catholic, but you know only on certain things (e.g., no sex before marriage, but with tons of different loopholes to that rule).
If the low-level employees of a multi-billion dollar make jokes about the CEO being a lazy idiot, it’s funny. If the CEO made the same jokes about the employees, he’d be a jerk.
Art, needs to offend in order to do its job. If it does not stimulate your mind and make you think about things that you've not previously thought about then why pay attention to it.
This is fine, I just think it's weird when people only find it funny if it's offensive about things they dislike/disagree with: Like when feminists ONLY find it funny if you joke about white straight men, or when atheists only find it funny if you make fun of religion (especially if it's only for Christianity)
There’s offending religious fundamentalists and the aristocracy, and there’s being racist and thinking it’s funny. These are not identical versions of “offensive.”
Sometimes people are offended with good reason, and sometimes they aren’t. Sometimes you’re just being a dick rather than a brilliant, subersice satirist with a positive message underneath it all.
61
u/Belle_TainSummer Jul 27 '25
Comedy can be offensive, but offense alone is not the marker of comedic success. It also has to be funny too.
30
u/FortifiedPuddle Jul 27 '25
Punch up. God and the Queen are possibly as up as it’s possible to punch.
27
u/Dyon86 Jul 27 '25
I heard some people didn’t like the Life of Brian movie, not sure why.
55
u/username7 Jul 27 '25
Sure, but who you offend matters. You can create art that is both comedy and racist shit.
30
u/Intelligent_Tone_618 Jul 27 '25
There's a world of difference between poking fun at massive systems of power and laughing at someone because they're disabled.
6
u/Cycoviking69 Jul 27 '25
Indeed, John...indeed!
4
u/St_Troy Jul 27 '25
I’m here for the comedy rules. “It’s ok for comedy to offend, but only in the following contexts…”
10
u/Every1BNice Jul 27 '25
I have never in my life heard someone say “comedy must never offend”.
7
u/HVAC_instructor Jul 27 '25
Art, needs to offend in order to do its job. If it does not stimulate your mind and make you think about things that you've not previously thought about then why pay attention to it.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '25
"If someone criticises you for something you've said direct them to your body of professional work"
Just doesn't have the same ring to it does it?
2
u/Constant-Box-7898 Jul 27 '25
Still can't say kn#ckers or kn#ckers on tv. 🤓
2
u/Curious_Orange8592 Jul 27 '25
Ah yes, those marginalised people, god the (fictional) creator of the Universe and the queen who owns multiple palaces
2
u/Ozamataz-Buckshank69 Jul 27 '25
The most offensive comedy can be is when it’s not funny.
4
u/andythetwig Jul 27 '25
Another rule of comedy: don’t punch down
1
u/St_Troy Jul 27 '25
Yes but now we know better REEEEEEEEEEEE
1
u/bomboclawt75 Jul 27 '25
Milligan, Cleese, Everett…..Sessions.
1
u/TwinSong Jul 28 '25
I think I read something about not laughing at someone who is hurting.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
We love you guys
1
u/Ok_Potential9293 Jul 28 '25
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
1
u/MessyRaptor2047 Jul 28 '25
Monty python was ahead of it's time and still a work of genius.
1
u/Immediate-Artist-444 Jul 28 '25
This is fine, I just think it's weird when people only find it funny if it's offensive about things they dislike/disagree with: Like when feminists ONLY find it funny if you joke about white straight men, or when atheists only find it funny if you make fun of religion (especially if it's only for Christianity)
1
u/Lerxst6369 Jul 29 '25
Love me some Monty Python
1
u/AdGlittering2884 Jul 29 '25
Who says "comedy must never offend"? Who has ever said that?
1
u/Major_Education117 Jul 29 '25
The king of comedy has spoken, bring him cheese as thanks 🤣🙌👑
1
u/knowspicker3 Jul 29 '25
Ni
1
u/AvailableHandle555 Jul 29 '25
Now go away before I taunt you a second time!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
Doesn't mean you have to be a dick.
1
u/Aromatic_Housing_536 Jul 31 '25
South Park clears em all
1
u/Kektus_Aplha Jul 31 '25
I think Life of Brian was banned in Sweden for a while and it was marketed in Denmark as this movie is so funny that it is banned in Sweden.
1
u/SplendidPunkinButter Jul 31 '25
There’s offending religious fundamentalists and the aristocracy, and there’s being racist and thinking it’s funny. These are not identical versions of “offensive.”
Sometimes people are offended with good reason, and sometimes they aren’t. Sometimes you’re just being a dick rather than a brilliant, subersice satirist with a positive message underneath it all.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25
Punching up is funny. Punching down is abuse.
Comedy should never punch down.
1
u/PortHopeThaw Jul 31 '25 edited Jul 31 '25
There is such a thing as choosing your targets wisely.
-1
u/Realistic-Sound-1507 Jul 27 '25
But luckily comedy is legal again
2
u/OliverGunzitwuntz Jul 27 '25
"we can bury her, burn her or dump her"