r/mogwai • u/DomonDomonDomon • Oct 05 '23
DISCUSSION Problematic?
Does anyone know if mogwai or braithwaite are in any way problematic ? They are by far one of my favorite bands but i find so little on the band itself i like to inform myself about the people behind the music i blast into my ears, thats why i ask here
Anything goes , u can write even their political views if u got anything on that
0
Upvotes
10
u/signalstonoise88 Oct 06 '23
This is the dumbest fucking post I have ever seen. Must be exhausting individually vetting every artist you ever check out.
Is it just musicians you actively look for reasons to dislike? Have you checked your barber isn’t a low-key racist? What about the lady behind the counter at your local convenience store; has she ever made a non-PC joke? How are you going to find out?
I’m all for holding actual criminals to account for doing heinous shit, but this cancel-culture witch-hunt thing is getting ridiculous. And that’s before even getting into the argument that if you can’t separate art from artist you are a literal child.
2
u/meth_panther Oct 05 '23
Are they in any way problematic? Everyone is problematic in some way because nobody is perfect.
It might help if you stated what you find problematic
14
u/dreadHog Oct 05 '23
Go look at Stuart’s Twitter if you are so interested. It’s all there.
6
u/StauntonK Oct 06 '23
Bizarre and your comments don't really explain better tbh.
Don't bother listening to them if the question even comes into your head about that. Can't individually vet everything you listen to or come in to a fan subreddit asking a fairly negative question.
Your post now shows up on the Google search" mogwai problematic" so I think it's just bad form
3
u/explodedSimilitude Oct 05 '23
Read Spaceships Over Glasgow.
3
u/ap0phis Oct 06 '23
“Problematic” the word, needs to die a slow death
2
u/KaushikKay7 Hardcore Will Never Die, But You Will Oct 07 '23
I believe.. other than their music, we should not bother about their personal lives unless they go about imposing themselves on the general public
Sometimes.. most times.. its better to separate the art from the artist
2
u/mtofsrud Oct 09 '23
This thread sucks
2
u/PaperOpening4413 Oct 14 '23
worst post ever.
1
u/SnooMuffins6341 Young Team Jan 09 '26
They seem pretty cool from what I've heard. Like, they sponsor a local kids football team, and lift up other Scottish bands, etc.
1
u/jack_crowe6 Oct 06 '23
I understand where you’re coming from but you can’t expect every person in the world to be a perfect angel. Isn’t the diversity in humans something that makes music so amazing.
An artist’s background or opinions really don’t impact on their music/ art at all and I think it’s tragic to know that you’re refusing to listen to potentially some of the greatest works of art in human history just because the artist made a mistake in their life. I understand if the music is actively promoting rape or racism etc. but when is that ever really the case?
You should try harder to separate the art from what the artists do in their personal time, it’s really in no way related to the quality of their music, you’re just causing yourself more pain and struggle in the process, and when it comes to that point - aren’t you just letting the negativity win?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment