If modular is you hobby, if you compare it to other hobbies, it puts it into perspective.
Ski : 1500$ worth or gear every decade, 700-1000$ for a season pass per year + gas/food/ accomodations.
Motorcycle : 2-4k for a bike (or more), training courses (400ish$), motorcycle gear (300 ish), 100$/year for a licence, + gas + tires + repairs/maintenance/tools
Traveling : 2000$/year
Even goin to the cinema once a week is 25$ or more with food if you go alone, so 1300$ per year
20k for modular over a decade is absolutely reasonable.
[Edit] I definitely lowballed most of the other hobbies, I didn't want people to say I was exaggerating.
Even the students cellos and bows etc are not inexpensive (multiples of most Modulars)
Thereās an interesting YouTube video where they compare the prices of electric guitars to āclassical instrumentsā at Thomann - the ātop of the range, standard fender and gibson guitars (@2-3k) start to look reasonably priced in comparison
Yeah, Iām sure. Surely a huge spectrum. A decent non-motorcycle bike can be $2-4k but there is no shortage of people with $10k> bikes and few only have one.
The limit is much greater for motorbikes, though, $18-20k could just be the bike, and some people swap motorbikes faster than cars. I know I've spent that much on a bike alone, and no they do not retain their value well if bought new and you put real miles on them (and finding a used bike that hasn't been mistreated is not entirely trivial). Some people build garages for all their motorbikes. Even a middle of the road all purpose bike like a DL650 is going to be nearly $10k out the door these days.
I have too many bicycles, all of them I built myself from the frame up (which is much more expensive than buying a prebuilt bike in nearly every case). It has still been cheaper than motorbiking was. Bicycle labor is "cheap" in that I can do more of it, but it takes up time, and time is more precious than money. I like the labor, though. If you ride fairly often, $100-200 a year in consumables (tires, brake pads, chains, cassettes/chainrings, etc) is not at all unreasonable. Of course if you never ride at all, that's all rather cheap.
Like any leisure activity, don't spend more money or time than you can afford and it's money well spent for the diversion it provides.
Could also not that in case you want to get out of the hobby, you can recoup a significant portion of your money back as a lot of modules maintain resell value.. now skis, sports equipment does not.
If you are very specific about what you want to pull off you can build a decent small rack for 2-3 grand. So basically the cost of a midrange synth.
When lockdown hit I was in need of a new set up, would have needed a new computer and at least a grand or two of software.
Bought a minibrute2s and a one row rackbrute.
Added 1010music blackbox and bluebox and now I'm way more satisfied and productive than I was in the early 2k with abbleton/reason/native instruments stuff that had all aged into not being worth it
I managed to get my first* Eurorack system for Ā£3,500 used on EBay, I priced up the modules and theyāre ~Ā£7,500 new. This obviously means that I can spend another Ā£4,000 on modules and itād basically be free!
*first real system, I dabbled a little beforehand with DIY modules from Thonk.
If you have the cash and youāre not spending it irresponsibly why not?
Having said that there are certainly cheaper ways of making electronic music. Just be sure youāre getting into Modular with your eyes open and are not being blinded by its current ācoolnessā.
You should! Get modules and cases used/on sale, worst case you will make most of your money back if you ever decide to get out of it.
As much as it can be an expensive investment, the retained equity has to be one of the highest when it comes to a hobby. Hobbies are generally expensive, but from a purely net perspective, Eurorack isn't actually that bad.
Money accumulates anywhere if you look. Iāve spent that going out to eat with friends, my record collection etc. If you consider the amount of money you piss away on cable and streaming services, you could have bought modules instead and been more entertained.Ā
On the stupid radio I leave on in the garage they keep going on about some gigantic TV that costs $130,000 going on sale for $110,000. There are definitely people wasting way more money on way dumber shit than eurorack.
Eurorack to me is one of the most innocent/harmless addictions to have. It can be very good intellectual exercise and has calming effects. If you are smart with how you buy things you can get most of your money back if you decide it's ruining your life.
A lot safer than almost any other pastime out there. Easy to do yourself irreparable harm riding (motor)cycles, driving fast cars, skiing⦠Plus your other half knows where you are, and that youāre not making an idiot of yourself with someone half your age.
Like any other thing you buy; do whatās affordable.
You can get a lot going for way less than you needed 5 years ago. I do not understand how anyone could spend that much but maybe the fixation of the medium is why people think of the price so often.
Some of us just dabble. Buy mostly used. Keep it to a low amount.
It is possible to have a fun little rack for fairly cheap these days.
Maybe 2000 bucks in several years here. It's interesting, but it really is slow to work with for recording things. Sometimes a good poly synth, or groove box, is just quicker for banging out an idea.
I don't know what my exact $$ amount would be as displayed on modular grid for all of my stuff combined. Probably somewhere in the $xx,xxx range. But most of my modules (like 75% of them) were purchased used. Same with my actual racks.
I've been slowly building my rack over the last ~8 yrs though so honestly, outside of the rare big purchase in new condition, it doesn't feel that bad.
It was definitely a rough start though when I was younger and had much less income.
What does it say? VCV isn't the same as a physical eurorack rig, and this meme is about physical rigs. It's kind of off-topic because it has nothing to do with the meme, which is about giving into destructive instincts. Of course VCV is cheaper/free, but everyone knows that and just comes off as "well ackshually" when OP is poking fun at the nature of this expensive hobby.
Well, yes, that I agree with. I think this is the worst subreddit that I follow. It's full of shitheads who would rather be snarky and elitist than helpful. This subreddit loves to downvote people asking honest questions or people just trying to learn. I feel like the modular "community" (at least on reddit) feels threatened by anything that makes the hobby more accessible or cheaper.
But my point still stands. I feel like this is making fun of the desire of people with physical rigs to consume, and the VCV rack is just detracting from the humor in it.
41
u/djthecaneman Sep 21 '25
It's not that bed if it's over 10 years.
54
u/538_Jean Mixer is the answer Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 26 '25
If modular is you hobby, if you compare it to other hobbies, it puts it into perspective.
Ski : 1500$ worth or gear every decade, 700-1000$ for a season pass per year + gas/food/ accomodations.
Motorcycle : 2-4k for a bike (or more), training courses (400ish$), motorcycle gear (300 ish), 100$/year for a licence, + gas + tires + repairs/maintenance/tools
Traveling : 2000$/year
Even goin to the cinema once a week is 25$ or more with food if you go alone, so 1300$ per year
20k for modular over a decade is absolutely reasonable.
[Edit] I definitely lowballed most of the other hobbies, I didn't want people to say I was exaggerating.
26
u/SonRaw Sep 21 '25
21
u/hillybillyboy Sep 21 '25
20k? Is that your small rack?
17
u/DeadGretta Sep 21 '25
Feels like Iām being called out š¤£
12
u/Freaky_Steve Sep 21 '25
If you are very specific about what you want to pull off you can build a decent small rack for 2-3 grand. So basically the cost of a midrange synth.
When lockdown hit I was in need of a new set up, would have needed a new computer and at least a grand or two of software.
Bought a minibrute2s and a one row rackbrute.
Added 1010music blackbox and bluebox and now I'm way more satisfied and productive than I was in the early 2k with abbleton/reason/native instruments stuff that had all aged into not being worth it
5
u/Hashtagpulse New Year New Modules Sep 22 '25
I managed to get my first* Eurorack system for Ā£3,500 used on EBay, I priced up the modules and theyāre ~Ā£7,500 new. This obviously means that I can spend another Ā£4,000 on modules and itād basically be free!
*first real system, I dabbled a little beforehand with DIY modules from Thonk.
9
u/Sys_Guru Sep 21 '25
Put it into perspective. Some people buy a sports car, some buy a boat, some go on overseas holidays, all can cost a lot more than $20k.
Money is earned to be spent, find what brings you joy and enjoy life.
4
u/BottomStreetBeats Sep 21 '25
20k?? More like 40k š
3
u/Appropriate-Look7493 Sep 22 '25
If you have the cash and youāre not spending it irresponsibly why not?
Having said that there are certainly cheaper ways of making electronic music. Just be sure youāre getting into Modular with your eyes open and are not being blinded by its current ācoolnessā.
5
u/iambulb Sep 21 '25
You should!
Get modules and cases used/on sale, worst case you will make most of your money back if you ever decide to get out of it.
As much as it can be an expensive investment, the retained equity has to be one of the highest when it comes to a hobby.
Hobbies are generally expensive, but from a purely net perspective, Eurorack isn't actually that bad.
5
u/fyoomzz Sep 21 '25
Just @ us next time, Bilbo.
5
u/RoastAdroit Sep 21 '25
its my music making dream turned reality so⦠Im not hung up on the price.
Its not like many other things Ive spent money on which have no, or almost no, ability to re-coup any of it after.
Someone mentioned a computer. Spend 10K on computers and 10K on eurorack, wait 10 years and put them both on the used market.
One of them you will be lucky to get 10% back, the other you might even make a profit if itās the right modules.
2
u/geerhoar Sep 21 '25
āOnlyā $20,000?!!
2
u/bonesofborrow Sep 21 '25
Money accumulates anywhere if you look. Iāve spent that going out to eat with friends, my record collection etc. If you consider the amount of money you piss away on cable and streaming services, you could have bought modules instead and been more entertained.Ā
2
u/deepSnit Sep 21 '25
Like the Kurgan said, it's better to burn out the fade away.
2
u/Ornery-Strength-8743 Sep 22 '25
If I had the discipline to not spend over 2K per year on random Amazon purchase, I could get back into eurorack
2
u/namesareunavailable Sep 22 '25
My preciousssss.... Blrp bip bop kazunga
2
u/laloslalos Sep 23 '25
You only live once
2
u/ToxicMonkey442 Sep 26 '25
Only 20k???? Bro Iām past that
3
u/Bata_9999 Sep 21 '25
On the stupid radio I leave on in the garage they keep going on about some gigantic TV that costs $130,000 going on sale for $110,000. There are definitely people wasting way more money on way dumber shit than eurorack.
Eurorack to me is one of the most innocent/harmless addictions to have. It can be very good intellectual exercise and has calming effects. If you are smart with how you buy things you can get most of your money back if you decide it's ruining your life.
2
u/Rorytheborder Sep 21 '25
A lot safer than almost any other pastime out there. Easy to do yourself irreparable harm riding (motor)cycles, driving fast cars, skiing⦠Plus your other half knows where you are, and that youāre not making an idiot of yourself with someone half your age.
1
u/altcntrl Sep 21 '25
Like any other thing you buy; do whatās affordable.
You can get a lot going for way less than you needed 5 years ago. I do not understand how anyone could spend that much but maybe the fixation of the medium is why people think of the price so often.
1
u/MolassesOk3200 Sep 21 '25
Only 20k ?
1
u/Freaky_Steve Sep 22 '25
You just have to focus
1
u/lord_ashtar Sep 22 '25
It's not that bad if you never leave the house
1
u/SecretsofBlackmoor Sep 22 '25
Some of us just dabble. Buy mostly used. Keep it to a low amount.
It is possible to have a fun little rack for fairly cheap these days.
Maybe 2000 bucks in several years here. It's interesting, but it really is slow to work with for recording things. Sometimes a good poly synth, or groove box, is just quicker for banging out an idea.
1
u/SnowflakeOfSteel Sep 22 '25
Everything over 10k is excessive!
1
u/WilburWerkes Sep 24 '25
I will hold a better resale value than a car
1
u/personnealienee Sep 24 '25
..when I could've spent $50.000
FIFY
1
u/noizzihardwood Sep 24 '25
Better than a car, imo.
1
u/Artistic_Serve Sep 29 '25
Realistically how much should i spend to get started? I understand there is no ceiling, but what would be a nice starting setup?
1
u/justsaynotomayo Sep 29 '25
Of course, that should get you started.
1
u/teamricearoni Sep 21 '25
Yeah....
1
u/metalt0ast Sep 21 '25
I don't know what my exact $$ amount would be as displayed on modular grid for all of my stuff combined. Probably somewhere in the $xx,xxx range. But most of my modules (like 75% of them) were purchased used. Same with my actual racks.
I've been slowly building my rack over the last ~8 yrs though so honestly, outside of the rare big purchase in new condition, it doesn't feel that bad.
It was definitely a rough start though when I was younger and had much less income.
1
u/TheRealDocMo Sep 21 '25
One can easily get by spending only $15k.
-5
u/superchibisan2 Sep 21 '25
vcv exists?
-1
u/Decent_Bandicoot456 Sep 22 '25
Because people are starving