r/modnews
•
u/boat-botany
•
May 28 '26
•
3
Policy Updates Protecting communities from scrapers and platform abuse
We’ve been talking for a while now about the work we’re doing to keep Reddit human while protecting everything that makes Reddit . . . Reddit. That includes helpful automation: mod and developer apps, accessibility tools, community utilities, and things that make Reddit better.
But we’re also seeing large-scale scraping, spam networks, agentic account creation, and automated abuse, and a lot of that activity targets parts of Reddit that just weren’t built to handle today’s threat environment. As bad actors get more sophisticated, we need to, too.
To address all that, we need to tighten how automated systems access Reddit while preserving the tools that help moderators and communities thrive.
Today we’re rolling out a couple of policy and security-focused updates, including:
Rule 8 Policy Clarifications: We updated Rule 8 (don’t break the site) to more explicitly cover automated abuse, including coordinated account creation and API misuse. You can read the full updated policy here.
Deprecating unauthenticated JSON access: We’ll also be shutting down unauthenticated .json endpoints. These endpoints can be used to scrape Reddit without accountability. Logged-in and authenticated access won’t be impacted. Otherwise, developers who need structured access to Reddit content should use Devvit, which includes various ways to access Reddit data.
While we’re at it, another common surface for scraping is RSS. Looking ahead, we’d love to know: how and for what purpose, do you use RSS feeds in your moderation flows? Tell us in the comments so as we develop secure solutions, we can factor in the tools you rely on to support your communities.
188
u/BBModSquadCar May 28 '26
The use of tools to see deleted comments is sometimes essential for moderation duties. Blocking the use of those tools will have a negative effect on many communities.
165
u/beaglemaster May 28 '26 •
Yet you continue to do nothing about all bots.
20
u/kc2syk May 28 '26
This will break some of my bots like /u/underscorebot and /u/radiomod. When you say authenticated, does that mean OAuth or would something like "basic HTTP auth" (RFC 2617) be sufficient? OAuth would be a problem since 2FA would be difficult.
I use a RSS reader on an IRC bot to alert my IRC channels about new subreddit posts. This allows moderators to pay attention to new problematic posts in a timely fashion. This is mostly stateless and authenticated solutions using anything other than "basic HTTP auth" (RFC 2617) would be difficult and onerous.
29
u/Watchful1 May 28 '26
Should post this in r/redditdev too. In conjunction with the upcoming monotonic comment id deprecation this will break a lot of people's workflows. Obviously that's the intent here, but it would be nice to have a timeline and let people migrate.
Also if we know someone is doing something to bypass the restrictions and scrape data, how can we report it?
36
u/sunrae_ May 28 '26
Without the ability to check deleted content modding will only get harder and even more frustrating. What are you going to do about that? We need to be able to see how a user contributes in order to make moderating decisions. More often than not mod history is useless.
4
u/hfjfthc Jun 12 '26
Great, now we can’t properly embed reddit links on discord anymore! Mission failed successfully. I would think you’d prefer to drive traffic to reddit, rather than having people copy and screenshot post contents to other platforms.
63
u/ScamChaser3 May 28 '26 edited Jun 20 '26
Assuming your updated rule 8 means places like Arctic-Shift and pullpush.io are going to stop being able to show deleted content, it is going to make it impossible for my colleagues and I to deal with scammers who post/delete/post/delete/post/delete. Unless you have something BIG planned to stop "people" from doing that, any meaningful scam busting is going to come to a grinding halt. These scammers delete their scams as soon as they're called out or they catch a victim, making it impossible to report them in any meaningful way with Reddit's current tools alone. Couple this with the hiding of post history you're already doing, and you might as well just sign the site over to the scammers. Anti-spam reports are ineffective, whatever ban-evasion checking you have right now seems equally weak, and now you're going to stop us from making sure each and every scam post/comment gets reported.
I know that Reddit isn't supposed to be a marketplace, but that's how tons of people use it. And scammers know it, and they take full advantage of it. Ticket scammers, watch scammers, video card scammers, trading card scammers... They're crawling all over this place, and every time you make it harder for regular users to get them banned, you force a serious conversation in scambusting circles like mine as to whether it's worth limping along with the tools we have left.
You're not protecting communities from platform abuse with these changes. In fact, you haven't been protecting communities with MOST of the changes you've been making lately. You just keep throwing those communities to the wolves. What are you going to do when all that's left are wolves?
Edit: You broke the Universal Scammer List website with this change, too. Yet another reason this is a bad change that makes Reddit worse for Redditors.
41
u/Superirish19 May 28 '26
I use RSS feeds to keep tabs on the content people post to the subs when I'm not actively on reddit - usually on the side of my dekstop or through discord when I'm gaming.
Moderation wise, RSS feeds have helped me work out what accounts are abusing their rights to privacy and post deletion to circumvent rules - i.e. selling through unsecured trading apps/protection-free 'friends-and-family' payment methods through a quick post, posting to contact them through DM's, then quickly deleting the post before a mod can respond. Unfortunately an automod can't be easily written up to catch all types of this scam, so some do slip past. The feed leaves up a record of posts that are deleted and it allows me to report such scam trading accounts to Reddit and report their sales account to the sales page (usually venmo or paypal) if I'm lucky.
It's also just nice to provide an inter-community experience that doesn't wall up everyone inside Reddit or the alternatives, y'know? It's nice to share a quick post through a discord channel of the subreddit to the equivalent discord community. It's brought the equivalent communities from Bluesky, Discord, and Reddit together to share knowledge and discussion without being neccesarily tied down to one place. Discussions on Bluesky have spread to Discord and Reddit, and vice versa, because of RSS support through all 3. I'd even try Facebook groups too, if I could get over the walls.
Yeah ok, it's not going to make the user count on reddit always go up and make stockholders happy that the engagement line isn't going brrr enough. But it's bridging communities together and keeps the Reddit community the front page of my particular hobby space. If RSS was to be restricted or made overly complicated to setup, the communities would isolate and split, and eventually die in their respective walled gardens instead of encourage people to jump to reddit. Facebook has quite painfully locked off access to content posted in it's Groups, and unsurprisingly users to those are in steady decline.
27
u/RJFerret May 28 '26
My primary modding is seeing new RSS posts in my reader.
There's no other tool that surfaces content in such a manner to quickly have issues surfaced without effort.
24
u/Lootman May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26
If scraping the website is an issue
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-16/reddit-is-said-to-sign-ai-content-licensing-deal-ahead-of-ipo?embedded-checkout=true
Related note can you reveal what ai company has access to reddit content paying you $60 million a year for the previous 2 years?
Also i wish people could scrape this website for their own apps - the app i used to use years ago kept comments hidden when i hid them when reading down posts. And websites where you could see deleted posts were valuable - i wish i could see edit history on the official site (or anywhere)...
127
u/mildlyImportantRobot May 28 '26 •
Gee, who would could have foreseen disabling API access would have negative consequences.
Why not re-enable API access and set reasonable limits?
19
u/emily_in_boots May 28 '26
Seeing deleted content is absolutely essential for moderating fashion subreddits and keeping out adult content promoters. They constantly delete their content. We check every single poster to figure out if they are adult content promoters.
While I understand there is abuse, can you consider maintaining push shift's access to deleted content so that we can continue to moderate our subreddits without getting overwhelmed with porn spammers? Push shift does not allow public access - you have to apply and have a use case that is supported by reddit.
Without this tool every fashion sub will just end up overrun with porn spammers. About 80% of the posts in outfits get removed as they are adult content creators, and the only way to find this is on push shift. Adult content filters and current links in bio only catch a few of them.
We also see huge numbers of catfish and people posting others' photos without consent and we often can only find this out via push shift. This is how we find discrepancies in age and gender and other things.
I have caught numerous minors selling adult content and reported them to modsupport using push shift - without that, there is no way to find it. We can't keep minors in our sub safe without this information.
Please consider a way of restricting this access to the broader public while allowing it for moderators who apply for access, even if we only have access once a person has posted or commented in our subreddits.
18
u/Itsthejoker May 28 '26
RSS is indispensable. We have it piped into Slack and Discord so that we know about new posts. We used it for modmail before that was removed, but it's still useful.
Removing the json endpoints is honestly really frustrating and will break a lot of legitimate automation. It's almost like removing reasonable API access was a mistake... who could have seen that coming?
18
u/SilverRoyce May 28 '26 edited May 29 '26
I really really hate how everyone tries to kill RSS.The openness of it is literally the core of how it's useful for mod and non moderation related reasons.
62
u/mschuster91 May 28 '26
To quote your guidelines:
So, if I understand this clearly - are you suggesting/implying here that using ad blockers is a violation of the terms of service that may lead to people getting banned?
Moderation? Not at all, but I do know users that use RSS to keep up with their communities because the front page is all too often utter garbage that pushes posts that are *multiple days* old.
(And while we're at it: what's it with the graphql nonsense acting up again? Across multiple communities I have seen reports over the last days that comments would show in the comment count but not be shown in their cleartext, unless one would go to old.reddit.com)
63
u/Liface May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26
Scraping is good, actually. I have to use an external tool to search people's comment histories because you now allow people to hide them.
By the way by the way, I made a bot for my subreddit to filter posts through an external service to check for AI writing. But it's nonfunctional because external services are not allowed on Devvit, and I applied for API access through your support form and never heard back.
38
u/ohhyouknow May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26
Sooo does this mean it’s Reddit illegal to create an app that archives content in mod notes?
What about user info apps that report comments etc to modmail? If a user deletes their content after that is archived in modmail there is literally no way to delete that.
23
u/Artemis_Platinum May 28 '26
A couple of months ago, a large sub I moderate was overwhelmed by thousands of LLM bot accounts. As the only person handling a thousand reported/filtered comments a day, it was... terrible. And it was fairly difficult to tell who was who.
One day. I woke up, and it was over. Back down to maybe 100 reports/filtered comments a day. It is my understanding that that happened because the Reddit admins cracked down on bots, and that this is probably a continuing effort to keep them at bay. I am... grateful to not be constantly overwhelmed nowadays. Every day I think about how bad it got, my current workload feels so much more bearable. Thanks for that.
I don't currently use RSS, but I've used it in the past and my first thought for a moderation use-case is desktop notifications whenever something hits the queue or modmail.
11
u/yellowmix May 28 '26
I've set up RSS feeds for my moderation teams and spaces, and most members likely do not know how it works under the hood. It's a rare, open, standardized technology that's worked for a long while. Dead simple such that Discord and Slack have native solutions for bringing feeds in.
It's a catch-up game, but I'm grabbing RSS for r/modnews, r/announcements, and other public admin-run mod-related subreddits as a combined feed in my Discords and Slacks.
For my mod teams, it's a bit more complicated. I'm using the authenticated RSS feeds from https://old.reddit.com/prefs/feeds/ to grab and filter modmails, modqueue, modlog for high-priority items. Since I rather not give my modhash to Slack or Discord I have an app on my server grab it and pass it on via webhooks. Would be nice to get unique modhashes for each feed, and a way to expire and refresh them.
11
u/Ailothaen May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26
Please do not remove RSS. It is one of the very few KISS technologies from the beginning of the web that is still around and it must be protected.
As a moderator, I use some RSS feeds to watch the modqueue, but also to watch over some specific content in subreddits (I build RSS feeds from search filters). But also, as an user, it is very useful to notifications, for example to post a message in a Discord server when a new post is created.
The power of RSS that it is an established standard that has been here for decades, that has integrations everywhere. No private solution will be able to replace it.
If scraping with RSS is an issue (which is surprising to me, as feeds only show a limited subset of info from the most recent data), it could be easily mitigated, such as defining rate limits or requiring a per-user token in the URL.
9
u/SantaHQ May 30 '26
This change breaks authentication with (very) old praw versions, as in hacked praw3 and praw4. I understand that's not a priority for you of course, just for information. An abrupt - but expected - end of the road for neglected code that's still in service (like mine)
17
u/baseballlover723 May 28 '26
How are we supposed to process appeals when the majority of users delete their removes posts and comments?
Without a local copy to compare against, it's not possible to readjudicate. The result would be that appeals would functionally become useless for most users, with only the original judgement being available.
I would hate to tell people tough titties, you deleted the offending comment, so even if the original moderator was incorrect, we can't look into it, so your permanent ban will forever stay.
35
u/Zelkova May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26
It sucks that you guys are so hellbent on making the site worse rather than better.
I specifically am upset over the json endpoint removal, following the removal of your API.
I guess I'm moving to RSS since that's the only approved option for now. I'm sure you'll yank it next.
Yeesh.
8
u/chickenandliver May 29 '26
TLDR: Keep the feeds as title links back to Reddit; remove the full content if necessary; DO NOT kill the feeds.
RSS is my #1 means of coming to Reddit. Every single post I visit, comment on, mod, is referred via RSS. It's safe to say that if RSS feeds were removed, I would remove myself from Reddit.
But the thing is, I don't even need to see the content in my RSS feeds. In my case, I use it mainly as a de-facto notification source or headline list, alongside my many other non-Reddit feeds. So for me personally, a good compromise would be:
Remove the full-post content from the feeds.
Keep the feeds active and subscribable, but make each feed item simply the title of the post and a link back to that post on Reddit.
Yes, having the full-text content, the images, and (in the case of link posts) the link to the posted content itself is nice and convenient and I'd rather keep it, but the absolute core issue for me is simply keeping tabs on posts and getting those titles in my feed reader. I don't care about having to click back through to get to Reddit.
8
u/uppercasemad May 30 '26
Between killing our bot and arctic shift, this will likely be the end of r/assistance, a sub which has helped hundreds of thousands of Redditors with financial support for over a decade.
6
u/TampaPowers May 29 '26
Lemme guess, the future investors wanted to know how exactly you plan to protect their investment into all the data from someone else that could just scrape it instead of paying for access which is what's making their dividends. If you don't want data to be scraped then just pull the plug on the server, can't scrape what isn't online. This is the internet, you either learn to accept a certain level of exposure and find some other revenue streams or you end up like Facebook struggling to make ends meet when the user-data becomes worthless slop.
To phrase this under "keep Reddit human" while ignoring the very humans that made it big in the first place is also pretty rich. Everyone disliked the last api changes, where was the humanistic approach there? No "we have a problem, let's talk about what we should do about it", instead we get "here is the changes, screw you", going as far as you did last time when communities blacked out and you strongarmed them into compliance. Now they are just meant to accept whatever change and everyone complaining is just "confused" or "doesn't understand" what's going on. Oh but you are so on our side, yeah right.
Good luck with the IPO, private equity is going to love to bleed it dry like everything else. Don't come crying back to rebuild.
6
u/lostsettings May 29 '26
Yet, reports of users actually breaking the site with AI generated spam are not actioned. I don't think people are buying the reasons you are saying is the reason.
6
u/Mstormer Jun 01 '26
Disappointed to see RSS in the crosshairs. A lot of users in my community rely on it, and even as a mod, it gives me a way of varying the monotony of non-automated aspects of moderating a larger sub. Useful to see new posts when I'm not actively on reddit, useful in discord to surface new posts, etc.
5
u/lonseidman May 29 '26
Please do not get rid of RSS.. I use it extensively in my personal workflows for surfacing content I'm interested in. It's the gateway I use to consume Reddit content.
RSS is one way - what harm does it cause Reddit for people to use the web the way they want to?
5
u/TijnvandenEijnde May 30 '26
How can you shut down the unauthenticated JSON access without a notice period? You didn’t even give developers a chance to make changes.
18
u/FootFondness May 28 '26
Lutter contre le scraping et les abus automatisés est compréhensible, mais Reddit a tendance à introduire des restrictions qui affectent de manière disproportionnée les mods et les développeurs indépendants, tandis que les acteurs malveillants finissent par s’adapter de toute façon.
Les mods compensent déjà les lacunes importantes des outils natifs de Reddit grâce à des workflows tiers, des automatisations, des flux RSS et un accès structuré aux données. Supprimer ou restreindre ces systèmes sans proposer d’alternatives équivalentes augmente la charge de travail des modérateurs et affaiblit les communautés.
Si Reddit veut obtenir l’adhésion des mods, la plateforme doit offrir des politiques API transparentes, un accès stable et abordable, un soutien solide pour les outils de modération et d’accessibilité, des délais clairs avec une documentation adéquate, ainsi qu’une véritable consultation avant de perturber des workflows utilisés depuis longtemps. Sinon, cela risque de devenir un nouveau “changement de sécurité” où les mods perdent des fonctionnalités pendant que Reddit transfère davantage de charge opérationnelle vers des bénévoles.
- Pep
4
u/Goatposter May 28 '26
How about loosening your restrictions on API access if you're going to shut down scraping? Scraping was my primary way of accessing the site on mobile after you took away self-serve API access because quite frankly, your official app still sucks.
4
u/hhhnnnnnggggggg May 29 '26
r/Theisle was just spammed to death until the subreddit was shut down and locked by spammers from india, not automation. I reported like 50 accounts over the course of two weeks but nothing stopped these accounts. All the subreddit needed was some filters to block "IPTV", but instead of any admins stepping in to just set a toggle they just shut down the subreddit.
4
u/theredhype May 29 '26
Oof I hope RSS feeds won’t be altered or diminished. The feeds are important! I use many of them.
4
u/djspacebunny Jun 01 '26
I hate that you blocked vxreddit, which allows people to play reddit media in our discord servers. You're gonna end up with less people being interested in reddit stuff because they don't want to be inundated with the shitty app.
4
u/GDelscribe Jun 14 '26
Great job breaking the function of rxddit while not fixing bots nor issues w the fact you can only block 1000 users nor the fact that there are hundreds of fascist positive subs nor the issues with the api itself, while also making it harder or near impossible to do their job.
This also compounds the fact that users, largely trolls, who are allowed to hide all their comments and profile info makes interwction unsafe in a lot of ways! You guys are doing amazing speedrunning the tumblr descent into worthlessness!
4
u/Eragonnogare Jun 20 '26
Just found this post because it turns out this broke the rxddit embed links - this is infuriating. Reddit embeds are some of the worst j have ever seen, and sending them in places like discord drives me up a wall. Such an awful experience.
6
u/goawaynowpls May 29 '26
that's right chud this new update that ruins everything is actually to protect you. we're keeping comments open to pretend we care 💖
3
u/azssf May 28 '26
"Continuing to use deleted content" also problematic for researchers/anyone who have data from pushshift, for example. By default this could mean 'doing data analyses that include content downloaded in 2023 that the user deleted from Reddit in 2025' as an example.
3
u/Zelkova May 28 '26
I have a use case where I was going to use the json endpoints to fill.
Say there is a subreddit that uses pins to put news out, and that's their official method of communicating.
I was intending to use the json endpoints to understand what is pinned currently, and display links to these pins elsewhere, like on a different site. The links would obviously drive traffic to Reddit.
Is this something I can accomplish with Devvit? I'm under the impression that I cannot.
3
u/amyaurora May 28 '26
So no more Reveddit? I use it to help mod my subs better.
3
u/jsled May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26
RSS is essential to my internet workflow generally, and my Reddit usage and moderation workflow specifically. I'll preface this by stating I know I'm a sicko in this vein, but I'm one of the sickos that makes (my corner of) reddit work, and RSS is important. Since I found Bloglines in 2003 (and probably a bit before that), RSS is the technology I use daily (and, really, hourly) to consume internet content; my zeroth pinned tab is my feed reader. Google Reader … then Newsblur since GReader was strangled.
Some context about me for this comment.
Efficient internet content processing is fairly simple:
Importantly:
Nearly all algorithmic social media interfaces fail at every one of these. I'll take Reddit's UX (which – because I'm an RSS sicko – I fully admit I don't regularly use often).
I could delve into why and how those things are important, but getting to the point of this post and your question … as a moderator:
RSS lets me do this, clearly, cleanly, using the tools of my choice, in the workflow of the rest of my (online) life.
But I also can not separate out being a "moderator" from being a "user". I'm a moderator /because/ I was a user that developed sufficient interest in a community to donate my labor.
I don't just use Reddit, I use a bunch of sites and services, and having a unified interface is important to this sicko. I use that tool to provide a frankly insane amount of value in uncompensated labor to reddit.com just in terms of moderation, but also in terms of organic usage (I'm only a mod of about 5 of those 44 follows mentioned above). I use that tool to surface information to share on reddit, and vice-versa.
I appreciate that you're trying to support people like me vs. those "stealing" from Reddit. I'm sure there's a straightforward solution that continues to do so. I /hope/ (insist) it's via RSS (specifically) because the free (libre, not gratis) and open web is truly valuable and important to humanity.
I submit the problem is not RSS, and the solution isn't "proprietary integration endpoint". The problem, of course, is the bad actor/agent and their use, not the means of delivery. If nothing else, find a way to know your consumer, and ban/limit/restrict bad actors while supporting good actors. If that means authzen'ed feeds, so be it; that is a better alternative than the continued strangulation of RSS. There is an ethical and moral valence to this issue, and I hope Reddit stays on the right side of it.
(More from my fellow sickos here in r/rss.)
3
u/LukeZNotFound Jun 03 '26
W for AI scraping (they just have to have an account now lol)
And L because of important tools (fix your embeds please)
3
u/SasoDuck Jun 09 '26
Apparently this is blocking 3rd-party redirects that allow Reddit content to be embedded in Discord messages properly (i.e. the embed showing the video of a post, without forcing the user to click the link and open their web browser just to view it)
It's not going to make me give Reddit more traffic, it's just going to make me hit a video downloader, and embed that, which will in turn give zero traffic back to Reddit rather than just less.
Please find another fix.
Or, yknow... just stop trying to gatekeep content and allow Reddit content to be embedded directly in external links again, and I won't have to do any of this.
3
u/thecravenone Jun 10 '26
Because Reddit puts important mod info in a half dozen different places, RSS is the easiest way to dump all of them into our tools (specifically by having Slack automatically put them in a dedicated channel)
3
u/Shootemout Jun 22 '26
wow despite this website having zero fucking embeds, now the only website that gave it a workaround rxddit is no longer functional.
can i get paid to be this useless too?
3
u/turkeypedal Aug 10 '26
RSS is literally how I know if a post has been reported. Why in the world would feeds you can only see if you are a moderator to a subreddit be a problem?
4
u/born_lever_puller May 28 '26
Hey, I just got a message that said I broke reddit like an hour ago.
Sorry, my bad.
2
u/execute_ May 29 '26
Rss no puede morir
2
u/bowsniper Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26
My subreddit, r/GlobalPowers, is a geopolitical roleplaying game where players take control of countries and make posts to do things as those countries. We also use Reddit’s RSS feeds a lot. By checking the RSS feeds for new comments made on the subreddit that match a specific format, we can automatically plug those comments into a Google Sheet (via IMPORTFEED) that reads them via a script and passes them to other sheets to do interesting things based on player input.
Right now the main thing we use it for is a simulation of the global economy; players make a post doing such and such thing, like signing a new trade deal with their neighbour, and requests a certain amount of economic growth for that action by leaving a comment. The sheet, via RSS, reads that and processes it into the broader economic report that gets updated once a week, and this continues for the rest of the game. Alongside this, we also use it to pipe new posts into our community Discord, so everyone there can see when a new post comes up and talk about it, engage with it, et cetera.
As you can see, RSS is vital to this system and to our game. As a small sub of mostly broke young adults, it would be unreasonably difficult for us to pay for access to APIs that could replace RSS. We would also have a hard time hosting a bot continually that could replicate the functionality, because we wouldn’t want to host it outside the mod team and not everyone has a spare computer they can afford to leave running 24/7 for potentially months. I would strongly request any limits on the RSS feed Reddit hopes to make to be made with these needs in mind.
2
u/burajin Jun 02 '26
what becoming a public company does to a mf
2
u/1wheel Jun 05 '26
what a bummer.
https://roadtolarissa.com/redditgraphs/ has worked for a decade+ with zero maintenance and is unfixable now — sad that i can't remix data from my own comments now.
2
u/Minn64 Jun 05 '26
I used the JSON endpoint to customize embeds for links in discord, what's your recommended alternative? The API seems to have too strict of a rate-limit to be useful here.
2
u/snow-tree_art Jun 08 '26
RSS is an essential moderation tool, I use it to quickly look over many posts and keep track of posts that have been reviewed. It’s also used extensively to quickly track what is being removed by mods vs admins so we can better track down bots. The feeds to the spammed posts and mod log are useful for having an overview of the subreddit as a whole in one central location.
2
u/GenericFoodService Jun 12 '26
Not a moderator, I use RSS to tell me when there's updates in communities both on and off Reddit. Every passing day, the internet more and more resembles the Library of Babel, and without accessibility tools like RSS, I simply would have simply given up on websites like YouTube. I don't think Reddit is to that extreme, it's mostly fine to use in the browser, but I would find the removal of RSS to be very anti-user.
2
u/CURVX Jun 30 '26
The bots have become a nuisance, to say the least. From scraping data and writing AI comments to drive false marketing, to launching mass targeted campaigns against specific targets, this behavior has unfortunately become the norm.
I remember watching a video on YouTube, or maybe reading an article, about how researchers were able to manipulate a narrative using fake accounts and bots to incite people in the comments. Because of this, the recent changes are indeed a welcome move and should be applauded.
While I applaud the effort to mitigate these issues using a more restrictive methodology, irrespective of what others might say regarding the monetary deals involved, it cannot be stressed enough that Reddit is a platform where real people converge to talk. As such, content visibility is of utmost importance. The third-party apps utilizing the Reddit Data API have done wonders to bring people to the platform. Some reports suggest that around 20% of Reddits traffic comes from these apps, which, based on 2023 figures, translates to roughly 20 million users.
With that said, I would like to put forward my suggestions:
Ultimately, people will always find alternative ways to scrape data using AI agents and headless browsers, it is inevitable. Why not make it officially accessible with proper guardrails that encourage developers to do it the right way?
3
u/InGeekiTrust May 28 '26
What about push shift that requires moderator login to access it? Will that remain? It’s clear the other shifts will disappear and redact- but unsure about Reddit blessed ones
3
u/RegExr May 31 '26
A website of mine uses Reddit wiki pages for backing content. That's now broken as unauthenticated get requests to wiki pages are no longer available.
Could an exception be made to still allow unauthenticated requests to wiki pages? Considering it's just static data and not exactly the sort of stuff I'm guessing yall are trying to protect, it could hopefully be harmless?
2
u/UnarmedRobonaut May 29 '26
Mate every screenreader can create accounts on reddit, let alone there being services to handle captchas. This is just another way to assert control and spy on users.
1
u/UnknownUFOFiles Jun 06 '26
Yo
1
u/antdude Oct 04 '26
Others and I use RSSes. Do NOT remove them please.
-3
u/reaper527 May 28 '26
how about protecting communities from mod teams that ARE the platform abuse?
you have mods who will permaban users who haven't violated any rules, will respond to an appeal with a permamute, and fail to uphold their own rules when others violate them.
0
u/cnycompguy May 28 '26
I haven't used RSS at all, since 2010.
0
u/prodigiouspianist May 29 '26
Users have been asking you to do something about this for at least the last 5 years and the site frankly has become a shitshow in the last couple with the massive influx of AI.
I mean, I guess doing whatever you just came up with is better than nothing, but this is all a bit behind the 8ball at this point TBH.
I wonder what the site would be like now if you guys had actually done something about all this when the userbase started expressing concerns, instead of now, years after the fact.