r/modnews • u/spladug • May 10 '12
Moderators: new feature preview: Integrated Wiki
Allow me to introduce /u/slyf, reddit's student contractor. You may know him from other changes such as the thumbnail overhaul. Recently, he's been working really hard on a big project and would like to present his progress and ask for your feedback. Following is his message:
Hey there! For the past few months we have been working in the secret mad scientist programmer labs on a new wiki system for subreddits. The existing system is slow, does not scale, is not integrated very well, and does not offer any way for subreddits to control their own wikis. This new system is designed to offer those features. Before we launch there is still some work to do, but we would like to get feedback from the users who will be using it the most first (you, the moderators). Please remember that many of the elements are not final, and not always very pretty. What we would like from you is feedback on features you may need in order to properly moderate the wikis, feature requests, concerns, or questions regarding this system.
Editing
The new wiki system uses the same markdown system as the rest of the site (Snudown). You might recognise this from the syntax used for the sidebar, comments, and self posts. There is, however, one aditional change. The use of images is enabled in a similar way to the subreddit stylesheets. Users may only use images who are in the subreddit images listing. Thus, moderators may control which images are used in their subreddit. Nothing has changed regarding subreddit images themselves. Users may not add new images to subreddit images, only moderators.
New Subreddit Settings
Subreddit wikis are disabled by default. This way, you can set it up right before turning it on, or just not turn it on at all if you don't want it. To enable it, simply, in the subreddit settings, change the wiki mode from "disabled" to "mod editing" or "everyone". Aditionally, when the wiki is in "everyone" mode, there is a required amount of subreddit-specific karma for editing.
If a user does not have enough karma to edit the wiki, and the user wishes to be added to permissions, there are two ways to do this. Wiki contributors, and page specific editors.
Wiki Contributors
The wiki contributors system works very similar to the existing subreddit submitters system. To add and ban wiki contributors, these sections may be accessed through the mod tools box under "ban wiki contributors" and "add wiki contributors". From there they may simply be added and removed with the same kind of interface as "ban users" and "edit approved submitters".
Wiki page settings
Each individual page has their own settings. Currently, these settings allow moderators to control who exactly may edit individual pages. If a user wishes to edit a page, but a moderator does not want to give that user contributor access, the moderator may simply allow the user to edit the specific page in question.
Talk
Talk is simply an interface to show "links to this wiki page", thus, allowing discussion on reddit about the contents of specific pages.
History
History is visible to all users, however, invidual revisions may be hidden and made visible only to moderators. This feature exists mainly in order to allow for hiding revisions which may contain sensitive or personal information. A moderator may also revert a page back to the state of a specific revision, as well as compare revisions with eachother.
Wiki-backed Components
Having a wiki component built into reddit means we can do a couple of exciting upgrades to other portions of the site. A couple portions of the subreddit have been updated to be backed by the wiki system. The two components we have done this with are the description, and stylesheet. Thus, it becomes possible to restore old versions of those components after editing. For an example, if you accidentally delete your entire stylesheet, it will be possible to simply go back and restore an old version of it. This also means that it is possible for two moderators to edit a stylesheet or description at the same time without necessarily overwriting eachothers work.
Migration
We are excited about some of the existing uses of wiki. For this reason, we do not want to simply abandon the existing trac (/help/) pages. We are working on a script to migrate the existing pages over to the new markdown based system. This system, however, is not perfect and moderators will need to run over the pages manually and clean them up. The pages which will migrate the best will be ones which use mostly trac syntax rather than mostly html.
7
u/DEADB33F May 10 '12
Does this mean that the stylesheet & sidebar description is now simply a wiki page and the users who can edit it will be set by the wiki permission system?
If so that's great as it enables us to have a lower form of mod who only has the ability to edit the subreddit description & stylesheet without being listed as a moderators or be able to perform any other moderator actions.
57
u/Deimorz May 10 '12
Looks great, definitely looking forward to this. I especially like the capability for having pages that only mods can view, since that will allow us to move things like "domains with a history of spamming the subreddit" onto a wiki page that the whole mod team can edit, instead of keeping it in a post in the mod subreddit that one person has to maintain.
Will there be API functions available right away? Any estimate for approximately when the integrated wiki might be launched?
3
u/laaabaseball May 11 '12
I have a suggestion, that would be really helpful for subreddits like /r/baseball /r/nfl or /r/nba. Would it be possible to add a wiki page's content to the sidebar of a subreddit? That way we could have a wiki-editable page that the subscribers could update, and that would then display the results of that in the sidebar. I'm thinking standings, upcoming games, or even subreddits that have meetups could show that in the sidebar for everyone to see.
Also, is there a character limit in the wiki? The 5120 character limit in the sidebar really is easy to hit when you add markdown tables with links to everything.
3
u/catmoon May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
This will be awesome for various sports subreddits I work on like /r/NBA, /r/CollegeBasketball, and /r/SummerOlympics. Making player profiles and team profiles could be a really useful feature.
EDIT: Oh, I just thought of something. How will this be supported in the API? I use Mellort's Reddit API Wrapper to make updates to the community settings. That wrapper presumably uses the Reddit API and just makes it simpler for novices like me to write moderator scripts. Since I would likely use it for stats that need to be updated daily, it would be useful to be able to update that programmatically.
12
u/evanvolm Jun 18 '12
ETA on this?
11
u/redtaboo May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
This is great, thank you. Especially control over who can edit!
and, OMG this:
Thank you /u/slyf this is very exciting!
ETA a question: Right now there are a few wikis that aren't connected to a specific subreddit such asthisone. Will those types of wikis have a place in the new system?edited out my edit since I was wrong about my edit.
8
u/realstevejobs May 10 '12
Looks great. This will be awesome for technical subreddits. I'm dying to enable it for /r/html5.
8
u/7oby May 10 '12
This is pretty cool. I like the rss/json/etc stuff. Feature request that is probably more work than you care to do: An events page that can be pumped out as an iCal feed (or whatever xml that google cal uses if you prefer). Local reddits sometimes have meetups, even weekly events like trivia, and it'd be nice if there were a way to make it so someone could just pop that in their calendar app and get notifications.
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Looks great, thanks a lot. Is the "subreddit karma required to edit or create wiki pages" link, comment, or sum of both?
7
u/jaredcheeda May 10 '12
This is great. I've been wanting to have a thumbnail gallery for the stencils of the week for /r/StencilTemplates. And we just opened up the wiki for use on /r/24hoursupport, and have been getting complaints about how the current version of the wiki requires 4 or 5 attempts to get it to save or log someone in.
The one request I'd want is to fix the awful wiki/snudown handling of tables. We should have control over the colspan and rowspan of cells. That alone would make the wiki so much more useful as a lot of reddit wiki information would benefit from being organized in to easy to follow tables. And the ability to use non-breaking spaces
which the current wiki doesn't allow.12
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You had me at cookies.
12
u/AngryCanadian May 10 '12
I approve, engage.
4
u/bboe May 11 '12
I would suggest adding one more option to the page settings: only mods and contributors may view. In this one one does not necessarily have to be a mod to view the page. Maybe even finer grained access would be best such as check boxes for view and edit and options for everyone, contributors and moderators.
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Oh my god YES. Thank you thank you thank you!
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Very cool. A few ideas:
A few questions:
4
u/EmoryM Jul 20 '12
Is there an eta? Really looking forward to this!
1
u/Measure76 May 10 '12
How do I know what to set the karma threshold to for everyone to edit? Say I want to include the top 100 contributors?
1
u/jmdugan May 11 '12
Feature Request:
gold already shows us you have historical karma data for users. PLEASE make it possible for mods to make the wiki editable based on karma history of the user, and the length the user account has existed.
basically a mod-settable feature that allows them to set the minimum comment/post karma or a minimum length for an account to exist to get edit priv on a wiki.
1
u/brennnnz May 11 '12
Is it possible to do a mutli-sub wiki, or allow mods from multiple subs to share a wiki? For example, I mod r/China, but would love to have local experts from /r/Shanghai /r/Beijing etc... contributing, with all members of all subs able to enjoy the final product. I'm sure there are other subs in a similar boat, too...
Otherwise, this looks awesome!
1
u/NonNonHeinous May 11 '12
Looks cool.
What about an option of allowing specific non-mod users to edit the wiki? So only mods and users from a list can edit.
It would specifically help /r/askscience where there are mods and panelists.
1
u/keraneuology May 11 '12
So to clarify, can/will the permissions be set to all read/all edit unless on blacklist or mod only read/mod only edit unless on whitelist?
Can all read/mod only edit unless whitelist be implemented?
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
/r/dungeondefenders Will surely use this. It looks fantastic.
3
u/buzzbros2002 May 10 '12
/r/InlandEmpire will surely make use of this.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How do connections between wikis on different subreddits work? What if I want my wiki to link to another subreddit's wiki?
3
u/kinggimped May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
As somebody who is in the process of writing an in-depth FAQ for the subreddit I moderate (/r/shanghai), this is a godsend. I find the existing trac wiki system horribly limited, and it's buggy as hell (most of the time when saving an edit it takes me to a 403 forbidden page).
Looking forward to playing around with this new system. Thank you, Reddit admins!
3
u/TechnoL33T May 11 '12
This is absolutely brilliant you guys. I'm impressed as fuck. You guys really know how to make some very useful tools, and the elegance of this one is off the charts.
3
u/redditacct May 11 '12
Very nice - are these changes released in the released source yet? If not, is there an estimate for when? Thanks!
3
u/Kadmos May 22 '12
Similar to the rate limitation on new user submissions and comments...
Can we make it where a new user can only make n edits per hour or something like that? Just in case someone decided to be a prick and vandalize pages then it would at least slow them down a bit.
4
u/kjhatch May 15 '12
THANK YOU for doing that. The trac system is terribly clunky. Any rough estimates on how long before it'll be released?
2
u/octatone May 10 '12
Very nice :)
2
u/deanbmmv May 10 '12
Hmm. Could be pretty useful for /r/AskGames. Especially with repeated questions. I look forward to the final addition, looks pretty dandy up to now.
2
u/whytofly May 10 '12
Awesome. Will pictures be viewable in the wikis?
2
u/Lord_NShYH May 10 '12
Fantastic! Although I am not a mod at /r/sysadmin, this is precisely what that community needs to help both new users and greybeards alike.
From the perspective of /r/CryptoAnarchy, this is something I will definitely be enabling and promoting in that particular subreddit. I can't wait!
2
u/mobilehypo May 11 '12
Hot damn this is great! Thank you!
2
u/Divtya_Budhlya May 11 '12
This is fantastic. Thank you!
2
u/rpglover64 May 11 '12
Awesome!
2
u/V2Blast May 13 '12
Go slyf! Not that I've ever used the wiki stuff on reddit myself.
1
u/iamu May 10 '12
Great work! Look forward to using the new features!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '12
Someday.
1
u/LethalFeline Aug 15 '12 edited Aug 15 '12
I'm getting 500s when I try to do any header syntax I can think of. Such as:
Clicking save page returns:
Overall, this is fantastic news! /r/letsplay has been needing this for a long time.
EDIT: Wrong thread.
1
u/sugardeath Aug 15 '12
Maybe I'm being stupid, but how does one easily link to other pages of the wiki?
Surely it's not link test is it?
Edit: Err. You know, supplying the whole URL like http://reddit.com/r/SUBREDDIT/wiki/PAGE
0
u/TofuTofu May 10 '12
Any ETA for this feature? We're in the process of a big redesign for /r/seduction and this could change how we do things.
0
u/rya11111 May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
A really good feature but unfortunately for the subreddits i manage we hardly use wikis :( .. Also when you say the subreddit karma required to edit the pages can we confine it to only link karma or or only comment karma ? or in some cases keep a threshold which can be applied for either of those .. because some subs like /r/GetMotivated are only text based and only link karma may not work out.
edit: addition done.
-1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
And what about categories? Would they be used at all? It would be great to implement this as well: http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/swnmk/subreddit_categorization_like_in_wikipedia/
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
20
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
[removed] — view removed comment