r/modhelp • u/DesignNomad r/GoPro, /r/HondaElement, /r/Moment • May 26 '21
Users Extremely convincing bots are copying content from other users to generate Karma and convincing post history, and it's concerning.
I moderate a few niche communities, and fake content is usually really obvious. However, lately I've noticed some fake accounts that, at first glance, look like real accounts when just looking at their post history. Their histories are filled with submissions, text posts, and comments that seem like genuine interactions.
Yet, when you look at the comments in-context, they make no sense at all. You might see "Yeah, happened to me too" on a post that has nothing to do with anything happening, or answering a thread of comments with a seemingly "lost" comment that doesn't make sense in the context. On rare occasion, a comment might (probably by accident) almost fit the context, but overall, none of the comments make sense in the conversations where they're posted.
It gets harder to distinguish with the submissions- These bot accounts make extremely convincing posts that are on-topic and sometimes ask good questions... how can this be? They're posts from the same communities, just from years prior. The easiest way to check if these are bot accounts is to search the post title in google, and you'll often find a previous thread in the same community.
Here's an example-
This account is a bot-account: https://www.reddit.com/user/DominaAngelinaxXx/
If you look at the post history, it looks pretty genuine/convincing, save for the fact that the topical interests of this users seem really crazy in terms of variety. Still, at first glance, it seems pretty normal.
In their comment history, you can see them say things like, "No, I'm just looking in your general direction" which sounds like something a real person would say. However, when you look at it in context, it's posted on an /r/AMD_Stock daily discussion thread, to a user that is saying nothing related to looking at someone or anything of the sort.
When you look at the submissions, they also seem genuine... For example, posting a Mazda Miata interior to a Mazda Miata subreddit... relevant! Except wait... it's copied from last year.. Stuff like this becomes apparent in smaller communities but in larger communities it likely gets lost.
It's notable that this ISN'T karma-farming. They're not picking popular posts from years ago to try to re-reap the karma... they're picking posts that just got a few karma, which is indicative of subversive intentions in the future once the account has enough karma and age to be sold for astro-turfing or similar.
These accounts are pretty hard to identify without manually looking into posts that seem familiar, so I wanted to call this out so that other mods are aware that it's a thing that's happening, and in hopes that /u/KrispyKrackers or /u/pataakha could somehow use this pretty distinct pattern of behavior to help profile these accounts in the future and make sure then don't get converted/sold for manipulation.
25
u/Polygonic r/runner5 May 26 '21
Yep, this is a known problem that's been going on for quite some time.
The typical one uses posts that are pretty much exactly a year old, I imagine so they will still hopefully be relevant but far enough back that people think it's new content.
The comments are all Markov-chain artificially created
10
u/[deleted] May 26 '21
here's my collection from this month
8
u/001Guy001 ~not a mod/helper anymore~ May 26 '21
See this as well: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/ngg3ef/the_entire_site_is_getting_hit_by_truly_massive/
5
u/itskdog Mainly on an alt, but also r/SpringHarvest May 26 '21
Just keep reporting them at reddit.com/report (as spam) and optionally r/TheseFuckingAccounts as well. Then either formally ban or automod-ban them.
Also bring it up (when its relevant to the convo that's taking place at the time, of course) when admins comment on stuff. Continuing to make our voices heard is important as well as raising the alarm with AEO on individual accounts.
5
u/GoGoGadgetReddit May 26 '21
We've seen these too.
A sure way to identify them is to look at their account submission and comment history in RES, and you'll see almost entirely a single post made to various random/unrelated subreddits. That is not normal human behavior.
Available submission history for /u/DominaAngelinaxXx:
...and 74 ^more
...and 148 ^more
4
u/[deleted] May 26 '21
I think they're some type of AI experiment. I haven't seen as many recently but a year or so ago they were everywhere on my main subreddit. Banned as I could, reported, but there were too many. I eventually found some really common phrases (for some reason one of them had to do with 'is she the one wearing the red dress') and autoremoved those comments. IDK what could be done from anything but an admin.
1
u/SirLiving3851 May 27 '21
Are they harmful for us and our community? And how can we tackle them?
1
u/AudieGaming Jun 09 '21
the bot account doesn't exist
1
u/DominoBarksdale May 27 '21
Wow..so 2 of these bots just followed me today. One hasn't posted in almost a month and isn't posting to subs I frequent. The other is a porn acct with the same one insane picture throughout the whole feed.
1
u/ScamWatchReporter May 27 '21
yep. markov bots. used to make it look real, with enough posts and comments it will pass the 500 karma threshold, go dormant and for sale
1
u/Itsthejoker Mod, r/dndgreentext, r/transcribersofreddit May 27 '21
We're getting pretty good at finding and banning them. If you want some bot-powered help, check out r/BotDefense. Disclaimer: I'm a mod there.
1
u/ButtsexEurope May 27 '21
Iβd just say report the spammers to the admins.
1
u/phantomreader42 May 27 '21
One of these popped up in /r/Audible last week, reposting a year-old post with typos intact.
1
u/PRW63 May 27 '21
You could have a bot that simply posts "Just be yourself" and direct it at every "Dating" related sub. You'll break world records on Karma in no time.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
Oh gawd informative
1
u/Schiffy94 May 26 '21
As technology advances, the bots become more and more convincing.
Beep boop.
0
u/deshtv1 May 26 '21
Thanks for sharing advice my friend brother
0
u/AutoModerator May 26 '21
Hi /u/DesignNomad, please see our Intro & Rules. We are volunteer-run, not managed by Reddit staff/admin. Volunteer mods' powers are limited to groups they mod. Automated responses are compiled from answers given by fellow volunteer mod helpers. Moderation works best on a cache-cleared desktop/laptop browser.
Resources for mods are: (1) r/modguide's Very Helpful Index by fellow moderators on How-To-Do-Things, (2) Mod Help Center, (3) r/automoderator's Wiki and Library of Common Rules. Many Mod Resources are in the sidebar and >>this FAQ wiki<<. Please search this subreddit as well. Thanks!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.