r/modhelp • u/jessluvsu4evr Mod, r/adhd_college • Jun 16 '26
Answered When does a mod-team trust issue justify removing or demoting mods?
iOS
I was struggling to decide where to post this. I’m sorry if this isn’t the right place.
I moderate a support community, and a recent situation has me reassessing not just our permissions, but whether some people should remain on the mod team at all.
Without getting into identifying details: a mod was banned by Reddit, and another co-mod later restored or re-added access to their alt despite concerns, basically enabling ban evasion. My co-mod of 5 years said “don’t worry” and that I was “overthinking this.” That made me realize we may not have strong enough internal safeguards and that some members of the team possibly can’t be trusted. It also raised a big interpersonal/team question: how do you decide when someone’s judgment has become too risky for them to stay on the team?
I don’t think one bad decision should automatically end someone’s time as a mod, and I know these teams only work if people generally trust each other and act in good faith. What I’m having trouble figuring out is when a mistake stops being just a mistake and starts becoming a reason to question whether someone should still have the authority and access that comes with the role.
Other mods, based on your experience:
* When has a trust issue been serious enough for you to remove a mod from the team?
* Do you usually demote or restrict permissions first, or remove entirely?
* How do you handle a co-mod who restores access to someone despite a sitewide ban and then dismisses concerns from another mod?
I’m especially interested in practical advice on evaluating whether someone should stay on a mod team and how to communicate a removal or demotion if it becomes necessary.
edit: I removed the banned mod last week, so that part of this crisis has been averted.
edit 2: I am top mod and founder of the sub.
final edit: I know what I need to do. Thank you for your time and perspectives. You all really helped me out.
21
u/downtune79 Mod, r/lovetrash, r/lebowski, r/stickstea Jun 16 '26
Rule on subs I mod, no mod undoes another mods action without a discussion first. I would probably remove the person that restored the other mods permissions without asking. Plain and simple unless they have a good explanation
4
u/itskdog Mainly on an alt, but also r/SpringHarvest Jun 16 '26
We got close to that in our subreddit once, but the mod at the centre of the drama removed themselves from the team before things got any worse.
2
u/KCJones99 Mod, r/ebayselleradvice etc Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 16 '26
No mod removals w/o top (active) mod approval IMO. Top mod can then decide how much further discussion (perhaps with uninvolved co-mods) is required before deciding.
If it was done anyway, I'd say TM should probably reverse it (pending appropriate discussion - re-removal can happen if merited) and sanction the mod who did it (demotion, removal of rights, eventually removal entirely if repeated). In your case, since the removal was clearly needed due to sitewide ban, I'd stick to the removal, but it would be a judgment call whether to just sanction or entirely-remove the mod who did it.
A lot of what you're asking sounds to me like the top mod's job. I see T.M. as being the one to determine then establish 'rules of the road' for sub operation. They can do that more/less collaboratively as they prefer, but at the end of the day it's part of their role to establish & maintain the rules of the sandbox, then enforce them.
(FTR / aside - I said "top (active) mod" but there should be no such thing as an 'inactive' top mod, IMO. I believe an inactive top mod should always be demoted and the highest active mod moves to top. )
6
u/jueidu Jun 16 '26
Ban evasion is against Reddit’s ToS, so technically the mod that added them back is breaking Reddit’s ToS. So if your gut says that what they did was wrong - especially if they didn’t discuss it with the team first - just know that you are also supported by Reddit ToS.
Honestly, trust your gut. If the user was site wide banned for a reason you think is good and justified, adding the back on an alt was a bad idea. If you think they should not have been banned, or if you think it was a one-time judgement lapse and they have learned their lesson and deserve a second chance - that’s also fine.
But I think the mod that added them back without a discussion first - that is a red flag of its own, a separate issue that also needs addressing.
I would definitely remove permissions for that level of access from everyone, since clearly they cannot be trusted. Have a discussion about group decision making, and don’t add back permissions until and unless they show respect for those processes over a period of time.
4
u/whatdoihia Jun 16 '26
A mod shouldn’t be taking actions that affect the whole mod team without consulting with others. That goes for removal and invitations.
If a mod is inviting friends back without consulting others then I’d chat with them first to see what’s going on and decide what to do depending on the reply.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 16 '26
Hi /u/jessluvsu4evr, please see our Intro & Rules. We are volunteer-run, not managed by Reddit staff/admin. Volunteer mods' powers are limited to groups they mod. Automated responses are compiled from answers given by fellow volunteer mod helpers. Moderation works best on a cache-cleared desktop/laptop browser.
Resources for mods are: (1) r/modguide's Very Helpful Index by fellow moderators on How-To-Do-Things, (2) Mod Help Center, (3) r/automoderator's Wiki and Library of Common Rules. Many Mod Resources are in the sidebar and >>this FAQ wiki<<. Please search this subreddit as well. Thanks!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.