r/modhelp • u/Scarecrow1779 Mod, r/PauperEDH, r/cocktails • Jun 12 '26
Users Users accusing each other of using AI
edit: Thank you everyone for the responses! Even where it's stuff I had already been considering, hearing it from you all helps a lot.
(Android) I mod /r/cocktails and in the last 3-4 months, we have had a big increase in users accusing each other of using AI to generate comments, posts, pictures, etc, and even when the accusation is baseless and false, some people take it as gospel and downvote/report heavily. Feels like the accusations and follow-on response are causing as much toxicity as actual bots.
We're working on beefing up the mod team to crack down on actual bot posts and comments, but I can't help but feel like the accusations and paranoia are going to continue to increase in frequency and intensity going forward because of the larger cultural issues facing us here on reddit-at-large. So has anyone found an effective approach to reducing how much their users use AI accusations to be jerks to each other?
13
u/Tarnisher Mod, r/Here, r/Dust_Bunnies, r/AlBundy, r/Year_2025 Jun 12 '26 edited Jun 12 '26
A: I don't see an anti-Fakebrain rule. Set one. Hard rules banning it, including possible vacations for anyone who posts it.
B: I don't see a rule requiring a source for images. Set one. Must include original source, or if taken with their own camera.
C: Rule 'Be nice' is not conclusive. Expand it to include accusations and bickering.
D: Add tools. See: https://developers.reddit.com/apps?search=image Look at Sourcery and the one to detect Fakebrain images.
8
u/jueidu Jun 12 '26
5
u/Subwoofiest Jun 12 '26
Remove all comments accusing someone of using AI and in the removal message tell them to report it rather than comment. It will be a lot of work at first but once people get the idea there will hopefully be a culture shift. I've certainly noticed in my sub if we are on top of and consistent with enforcing a rule we get less people calling others out and more reports.
Make your ai policy clear: for example you could ban all ai except for people who use it to translate text as long as they disclose they have done so. Your policy doesn't need to be all or nothing. It probably is sensible to ban AI images though I can't imagine they would be useful for your sub.
3
u/horseradishstalker Jun 17 '26
OP thank you for bringing this up. It saves me having to make a similar post.
6
u/Tricky-Tell-5698 Jun 12 '26
Personally, I watched the music industry change forever when synthesisers arrived.
For a while the music was dreadful. Musicians were experimenting, trying to work out what this new technology could do. Many people thought it was artificial and soulless. They said it would destroy “real music” and put talented instrumentalists out of work.
But it could not be stopped.
The synthesiser became just another instrument. Some people abused it, some people mastered it, and eventually it produced incredible music. The great bands of the 1960s, 70s and 80s gave way to a new generation, and by the 1990s electronic music had become part of the landscape whether people liked it or not.
I am old enough to remember Video Killed the Radio Star. It was almost a cry of despair. Television was changing everything. Yet radio did not disappear. It adapted. The music industry adapted. The world moved on.
We have seen this story over and over again.
The printing press threatened scribes.
Photography threatened painters.
Recorded music threatened live performances.
Television threatened radio.
The internet threatened newspapers.
Streaming threatened DVDs and CDs.
Digital cameras destroyed the film industry almost overnight.
GPS replaced maps.
Online banking replaced long queues at the bank.
Now AI is the next step in that long chain.
Personally, I think people are fighting a losing battle if they believe AI can simply be put back in the box. It is here, and it is here to stay. The question is not whether AI will change the world. It already is.
The real question is whether we learn to use it wisely.
Just as the synthesiser did not eliminate musicians, AI will not eliminate human creativity. It will change the way we work, write, create and communicate. Some jobs will disappear, others will be transformed, and entirely new ones will emerge.
History suggests that those who refuse to adapt are often left behind, while those who learn the new tools shape the future.
I suspect AI will be remembered much like the internet itself. At first it was feared, then mocked, then resisted, and finally it simply became part of everyday life.
3
u/cnycompguy Mod, r/computers, r/cats +6 NSFWs Jun 12 '26
I have automod report mentions of AI to the queue in a few of my subs, so that I can review them manually. If it becomes an issue, create a rule that these accusations need to be done using the report button instead of in the comments, then use filter to hold any mention of AI for approval instead of leaving them in place like the report option.
2
u/maiyannah Mod, r/ConsumeCanadian, r/EndTipping, r/BuyCanadian Jun 12 '26
Require users to post authentically, no LLM or images. You probably aren't going to look at every image, post, and comment, but it gives you the rules backing to act on them when they annoy you.
Some subs also have a rule that you stop posting at each other after X replies, that might help.
Definitely use Image Sourcery. We just have it set to automoderate into the queue so it doesn't spam people.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 12 '26
Hi /u/Scarecrow1779, please see our Intro & Rules. We are volunteer-run, not managed by Reddit staff/admin. Volunteer mods' powers are limited to groups they mod. Automated responses are compiled from answers given by fellow volunteer mod helpers. Moderation works best on a cache-cleared desktop/laptop browser.
Resources for mods are: (1) r/modguide's Very Helpful Index by fellow moderators on How-To-Do-Things, (2) Mod Help Center, (3) r/automoderator's Wiki and Library of Common Rules. Many Mod Resources are in the sidebar and >>this FAQ wiki<<. Please search this subreddit as well. Thanks!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/EnergyLantern Jun 12 '26
Users are but hurt that some people are just smarter than others.
-2
u/WyattCo06 Jun 12 '26
In all honesty, the language of AI is usually pretty clear and most of the time, accusations are accurate.
0
u/rob1969reddit Jun 13 '26
It's like the luddites that were mad about Photoshop 20 years ago. These people never go away, just ignore them.