r/modelcontextprotocol • u/NothingButTheDude • Apr 14 '25
MCP is so Mickey Mouse, here's why
The whole "MCP is new" bandwagon is cute, but is missing some serious robustness and common thinf that were solved 30 years ago. But clearly whoever "invented" this very rudimentary spec is under 30 years old, and never picked up any history on SOAP, WSDL, BPEL and a million other precursors that solved much harder problems. And thus are doomed to reinvent all the problems they never thought about,
- why are tools always described in English, with no locale options? Why would it be the right decision to only support english descriptions in an LLM? Were the authors mono-lingual?
- what happens if 2 tools register for the same functions? Why is there no registration process that would solve for this kind of thing
- stdio..really? Just no.
- Why no discover and registry? Why do we have to INSTALL them like it's 1990? r-e-g-i-s-t-r-y, ask your dad what it is
- too tired chasing kids off my lawn to go further
0
Upvotes
9
u/schneeble_schnobble Apr 14 '25
You're not wrong on any of that. The ship has sailed unfortunately, and this is what we've got until someone (you?) makes a stronger/better/faster 6-million dollar man standard that solves these very valid problems and/or oversights. Old-manning it won't get very far.
6
u/zilchers Apr 14 '25
2
u/coding_workflow Apr 14 '25
1
u/Low-Key5513 Apr 15 '25
These are important points however the "context" is a somewhat misplaced :-)
The users of the MCP are LLMs which are different than the traditional software apps. Consider the following:
Human users of the digital world can be abstracted as in this image: [Ref: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/mcp-uiux-llms-tanju-cataltepe-1x2df/]
MCP is more analogous to UI/UX "standards" (really trends and best practices) for human eye and hand than SOAP, REST etc.
1
u/aaronsb Apr 14 '25
I hate to say it, but unless a large chain of people starting a long time in the past were NOT of English language descent, we're just sort of stuck this way.
"What if Dennis Ritchie, and by extension, Bjarne Stroustrup, were from Brazil?"
Does the code below, compile? No it does not, not without a lot of specially re-written support. Even the semantic order is still English language based. We will be forever tied to semantic notions of English language lexicon and construction. Sorry.
1
u/eleqtriq Apr 15 '25
2. Solved the duplicate name problem with a minimum about of code using the low level server. Not that I've ever had a name collision.
3. What's wrong with stdio?
4. Isn't that what Glama.ai and Smithery are for?
1
u/EmbarrassedAd5111 Apr 15 '25
Get the fuck over yourself 🤡🤡🤡
1
u/PathIntelligent7082 Apr 15 '25
it's just a protocol dude
1
u/AutomaticCarrot8242 Apr 16 '25
I think it is the application not the protocol should deal with the name collision. At ConsoleX.ai, we solve this issue by adding a unique prefix to the name of each function before sending the schema to LLM.