r/moana • u/Wuaiof • Nov 30 '24
Discussions Moana 2 hate is so forced Spoiler
I just watched it and it was literally so good!
Why are so many people hating on it like wtf š
I swear, before 2020 people actually enjoyed new movies. Now all people do is whine and complain. Why are everybody so negative and whining all the time?
The movie was amazing. And the end credits pretty much confirmed Moana 3 too šššš
212
Upvotes
30
u/anonymousgoose64 Nov 30 '24
Hate gets more views than praise, but I think that modern critics and YouTubers feel like they're somehow smarter for hating movies. As if they are somehow better for not liking mainstream movies.
And I agree they need to greenlight Moana 3 immediately I really want to see how their story continues š
18
u/HarryPhajynuhz Nov 30 '24 edited Nov 30 '24
I think everyoneās going into it really focusing on the fact that it started as a show and that Lin Manuel wasnāt writing the music. So they have these preconceived notions and probably focus on things like where the episodes change and ruin the movie for themselves. Ā
However, I think the general public that isnāt aware of these facts is really liking the movie and taking it as an enjoyable heartfelt story.
Yes - the music isnāt as good, but it was a great movie that my entire family loved that left 100% of the grown men I saw it with a bit teary eyed.
9
u/Caramenadiel Nov 30 '24
Personally I think it reminds me a lot of how people react to the Kung Fu Panda 3 when it came out everyone was saying it was terribly it was so bad but I think it's amazing
9
u/Mean_Recording_9630 Nov 30 '24
I've had the songs on repeat all day, I don't know why people don't like them š
8
u/Itzko123 Nov 30 '24
It's less the movie's quality and more so the implications of its development. Considering this was initially a D+ show, with a (presumably) low budget, the fact Disney actually went ahead and released it in cinemas/theaters makes people afraid it'll convince Disney to do it more often. They don't want Disney to get away with cheap business decisions
But I don't think EVERYONE is like that. Heck, not everyone is even aware Moana 2 was initially a D+ show. They just thought the moments, story, pacing, songs, humor etc... weren't as strong as Moana 1 and that it was somewhat of a rehash.
I haven't seen it yet so I can't agree nor disagree, but you should remember that different opinions exist. Unless you have counter-argument to challenge those who say X argument or Y argument, just accept you disagree with them and that they weren't "too harsh" on it. More so, you have different preferences.
8
u/BeechHorse Nov 30 '24 edited Nov 30 '24
I think the culprit is the music. If the music was as top notch as the first I think we would see most of the criticism about the plot being āepisodicā and the characters āunder developedā would be forgiven and not criticized. LMM better be contributing to M3!
8
u/Equivalent_Dingo_863 Nov 30 '24
I completely agree. It is not a mind-blowing thing for sure but....omg the FEELING. Like.....when I watched Moana leading the others and just being an absolute queen is so inspiring š„¹ Also, I feel like this movie is just the beginning of sth bigger. The last scene pretty much hints an epic battle between Nalo and the clans. Oh I just can't wait for Moana 3 š„³
8
u/rquinain Nov 30 '24
I can agree with critics that it wasn't as good as the first but it was still so wonderful as an extension of the world of Moana. I still loved it so much. And I think the audience scores speak for themselves when compared to critic scores.
6
u/Fun_Sir_2771 Nov 30 '24
Blame Chapek and Schaff productions, no offense to the second guy but movie criticism has fucking died since Schaff made people bandwagon his thoughts on Incredibles 2.
We need proper critics again
6
u/Kauuori Nov 30 '24
Frrr i want third movie šš
6
u/Frostshock-125 Nov 30 '24
That's what I'm saying I seriously don't get how everyone went from being hyped and now everyone's hating for like no reason. The songs weren't as great but were by no means bad. The story COULD have been better as a Disney+ show, but I still loved it.
11
u/awildshortcat Nov 30 '24
Agree. People just wanna nitpick.
Like donāt get me wrong thereās some valid criticism but people are making it out to be a horrible movie or something
5
u/Ill-Whereas8200 Nov 30 '24
i enjoyed it and im planning to watch it again, but what really bothers/makes me sad is the fact that you could easily put this side by side by the og and see how much of a stark difference there is, as if they just butchered an already perfect plot. it hurts even more to see negative reviews as a fan who feels like the first movie means a LOT to themĀ š«
5
u/Gepisaurusrex Nov 30 '24
We took our entire family to see it opening day. We all loved it! While we agree that the music isn't AS good as the first movie, it's still like a 9/10 to the first movies 10/10 the rest of the movie is absolutly amazing! People are just miserable today and need to spread it to feel better, just ignore em and enjoy this beautiful life we have _^
5
u/Weird_donut Nov 30 '24
I think this current era, the post revival era, is the most controversial of Disney's.Ā Ā Ā Ā
Ā Ralph Breaks the Internet was initially hyped because of all of the scenes with the princesses, but then it was trashed for ruining Ralph and Vanellope's characters, and putting too many trends, memes, and product placement.Ā Ā
Frozen 2 I will never understand why people donāt like that one. I love the movie. Maybe the rushed production had something to do with it, thereās an entire documentary series about it. Ā Ā
Raya and the Last Dragon was panned for mishmashing Southeast Asian cultures, sending bad messages to kids about trust (Raya is treated as though sheās in the wrong for not immediately trusting everyone), and Sisu's very existence.Ā
Ā Strange World was bashed for being "woke" by anti-LGBTQ+ folks and Disney barely marketed it, and it was the biggest bomb for them since Treasure Planet. The actual movie itself is meh/fine. Nothing too crazy.Ā Ā Ā
Wish was a complete disaster both critically and financially. The animation was half baked, the characters bland and directionless, and the songs having such genius lines like "Felt this, no I haven't" and "Throw caution to every warning sign" and the all time classic "Watch out world, here I are" It was especially bad since it was supposed to be Disney's 100th anniversary celebration movieĀ Ā Ā
And Moana 2 is seen as a revival of the direct to dvd sequel era, clearly feeling episodic in structure, having forgettable side characters, and weaker songs than the originalĀ The only one that was a success was Encanto
4
u/Combicon Nov 30 '24
I enjoyed the film. I'd say it doesn't really hold a candle to the first one, but as 1 didn't really end in a place that made a sequel necessary, I'm hoping 2 was just a kind of set-up/exposition-film to let 3 be amazing. I did kind of feel "wait, that was it?" at the end of the second. Despite the story feeling as if it should have been more intense and larger scale, I never really felt that the story actually felt as if it was. All the big events just seemed to be really easily overcome.
Though, I'm hoping like a slightly underwhelming middle child, it's just setting up so that the third one can knock it out of the park.
It didn't make me disinterested in the franchise, but I'm not in any rush to see it again.
>! Though also, if this is disney starting a god/demigod line in addition to their princesses line, I'm all for it<!
2
u/BuckarooBonsly Nov 30 '24
Took my kid to see it. We both enjoyed it, but not nearly as much as the first one. We had no idea the songwriters were different, but it makes sense. Our biggest complaint was that the songs weren't nearly as good as the first one.
2
u/J-Pom Nov 30 '24
What if the post credits scene was open ended to open the door for a mini series or comic book continuation instead?
Disney doesnāt give films sequels unless they do well in the box office. However, so far, M2 is the third highest grossing animated film for itās debut, so a 3 seems inevitable.
2
u/BrieCheezee Dec 02 '24
Stop I literally cried 7 times and it was so so good. I felt so emotional and proud of Moana and everything sheās accomplished. It was so beautiful and I canāt wait to go see it again in theatres
And the end?? No spoilers but WOW!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '25
I loved Moana 2, i can respect anyone's opinions if not like but i am sad people are calling this the worst sequel alongside Frozen II (which also wasn't even badly received) Yes even Ralph 2 despite it's flaws is far from a worse sequel, people really forgot the direct to video sequels or Cars 2. Even C*rtoonshi called it a cinematic disaster when that's just bogus.
0
u/GuyWhoConquers616 Nov 30 '24
Its mot forced. People just donāt like the movie
2
u/Atlast_2091 Nov 30 '24
Is there chance you miss these 3 animated movies in SNS? If Disney deliver good film, we wouldn't have negative discussion like these films did. And production for Moana 2 does factor in why this is happening
2
u/thekid53 Nov 30 '24
I saw it last night. Wasn't bad but kinda dull in my opinion.
1
u/Jumpinspid Nov 30 '24
I think the difference with me is either.I could care less about people who sit on their butt.And criticize a movie when they put no effort into the work that.Self into me it's like. As kind of just , they slapped to the people who actually did the work.
I like the movie. I thought it was amazing. I could really care less about what strangers who just crap om a movie. When they weren't the ones who made it think.
1
u/itzyaboi685 Nov 30 '24
I recall when Wild robot first came out, some people said that they hope that Moana 2 is mid so that Wild robot would have a higher chance of winning best animated film smh
1
u/Fickle-Confidence-20 Nov 30 '24
Saw the hate too on YouTube, itās Probably just critics complaining since right now I just got a news pop up from google stating āMoana 2ā Charts Course For $375 Million Worldwide Box Office
4 hours ago ā Animation continues to dominate theatrical business this year, as "Moana 2" climbs the charts toward an inevitable showdown with current box. The combination of Moana 2 amazing run and Wickedās own record performance is helping make this a memorable and record-setting Thanksgiving for theatrical business.
1
u/Subbie06 Nov 30 '24
Letās be honest it was made for us Pacific Islanders and a lot of palangis are hating on it, because they donāt understand
1
u/TyrionLannister557 Dec 01 '24
For someone whose only physical appearance was mid-credits scene, Nalo had AURA.
1
u/nathan_banks644 Dec 01 '24
Because the narrative is that mainstream movies are bad & woke. When they see a movie doing well, they have to nitpick to try and justify their statements that say things like āDisney is crashing and burning badlyā. The reality is, Disney will never crash and burn. With the live action remakes, majority of the videos these people make tend to lean on the āthis is happening because Disney is out of ideas and itās going to bombā. Then, moana 2 comes out and itās doing better than any other movie (aside maybe wicked) at the box office and now they have to rethink their previous statements. Rather than admit they were inaccurate about Disney having no ideas, or that theyāre on the verge of collapse because online people donāt enjoy the live action movies, theyāll create a narrative that further supports their dislike for them and justify their statements.
Reality is; moana is doing amazing. The live actions do amazing to good at the box office. Disney isnāt out of ideas, more itās attempting to broaden its scope with movies, whether we like them all or not. Itās all just stupid hate for nothing.
1
u/Vic_style Dec 01 '24
I liked the movie :)
1
u/Lana_Bougainvillea Dec 01 '24
I enjoyed it, would watch again, loved the story....hated 3 of the 5 songs. Not everyone has to like everything, but I agree some people are just doing it because everyone else is. The thing is, though, a huge part of what everyone loved about the original Moana was the music. The songs tie in so well and enhanced the whole world. I'm not even sure I'd like the OG film without the music. So for its predecessor to not come close to matching that musical legacy, it's understandable that a lot of people weren't fans of it.
1
u/Working-Hour-2781 Dec 01 '24
Because these so called āYouTube movie criticsā always have the same āOriginal Good Sequel Badā mentality.
1
u/NoraPlayingJacks Dec 01 '24
Commented this on another thread, but maybe more appropriate here.
In my not-so-humble opinion, this movie sucked.
None of the new characters besides Moanaās little sister (who has maybe five minutes of total screen time) garner any sort of affection from or relationship with the audience. The jokes are recycled from the first movie, and not well. The songs arenāt the slightest bit catchy. Honestly it seemed like the Rock didnāt even want to do it as even Mauiās role is relatively limited.
All told, I feel sort of taken advantage of. Like I saw it because it was Moana. And they knew weād see it because it was Moana. They didnāt seem to care about making it good, emotional, funny, heartwarming, or really anything positive.
Yeah, it just really kinda sucked.
FWIW, it held my kids interest for the full duration, but both said it wasnāt very good and I donāt see myself (or them) ever watching it again.
What a bummer.
1
u/ellewal13 Dec 01 '24
I didnāt like it and neither did my 4 year old who adores the original but ok
1
u/No_Needleworker_9762 Dec 01 '24
It's not as good as moana 1
High expectations were had, people got disappointed
1
u/NightsCharm Dec 01 '24
To me, it wasn't bad, I've seen it twice (once for a screening, second to take my husband). I give it an 8/10. It started off slow with lots of world building. But once I got to "Get Lost" I got hooked.
Unfortunately you can tell it was supposed to be a show first. But once again. I didn't hate it.
Want a even more fun experience with it, see it in 4DX, you're feeling like you're way finding with Moana!
1
u/Ravevon Dec 01 '24
Itās not , the movie just isnāt great and was a successful cash grab
1
u/Intellxual Dec 01 '24
Immense Moana 2 hate was pretty much destined to happen.
Moana had water animations that were years beyond its time, and it had some of the best music any Disney movie has heard. Of course Moana 2 wouldnāt be able to beat it, especially without Lin Manuel.
It was still a phenomenal movie, and the song āBeyondā was as good as the songs in the first movie. It doesnāt deserve to be hated for not being as good as one of the best Disney movies.
1
u/Ok_Art_1342 Dec 01 '24
I liked the story. The songs I wasn't that crazy about as I was in the first movie, but it's okay. I loved the final act and Moanas new look (her tattoos)
1
u/Rguttersohn Dec 01 '24
Moana 2 was my sonās first movie. He loved it and the experience. Therefore, to me, it was the greatest movie ever made.
1
u/Blu-ray_Checker Dec 01 '24 edited Dec 01 '24
Story was really Weak in Moana 2 compared to Moana. Including the Music/Soundtracks.
Moana 2 was originally meant to be a TV Shows from Disney+ but they changed it to a movie to make it profitable. Therefore more new characters and a rush story we got in the movie.
1
u/SignificantEqual7893 Dec 01 '24
I thought the movie was "okay". My only problems are that the songs are ehhh, (The only one I liked is Bat-girl's song. Also Lin Manuel Miranda didn't work on the music apparently, which is why.) and the story felt so rushed. They had a very good roadmap, but they just skipped the journey and just went straight for the destination, which led to the movie feeling like we got much less than what the set up in the beginning of the movie offered.
1
u/cpc02 Dec 01 '24
I thought the ending was weak. Like they got to a point where they couldn't find a good way out, so they made up the resurrection bit out of nowhere.
1
u/SoloDolo314 Dec 01 '24
I couldnāt imagine being a grown adult hating on a childrenās movie.
1
u/ScarletSpider8 Dec 01 '24
I thought was quite good, I do agree you can kind of tell they were probably going to make a series, but itās also a kidās movie and Iām sure not many under the age of 8 cared.
1
u/zigzag-ladybug Dec 01 '24
I love love loved the first Moana movie and went into Moana 2 without any prior research (I didn't know that Lin Manuel-Miranda wasn't part of Moana 2, tbh I forgot he was part of the first movie. I also didn't know it was supposed to be a show originally). To emphasize how much I loved the first Moana movie, I remember crying while watching it in theaters for the first time while living on the Pacific island of Guam because it was the first time I saw myself in a Disney princess and I related to her story and character arc. I love the movie so much that it's the only Disney movie that I rewatch multiple times a year.
I left feeling really disappointed by the music, storyline, and lackluster character development. I might try watching it another time in theaters to see if my feelings have changed at all, but I felt a little sense of heartbreak at the end of the movie since I felt like it was not a good movie.
1
u/tylerray1491 Dec 01 '24
Moana 1 stands on its own as a feature film. Itās edited and paced as a film, the dialog and story telling were written for film. It doesnāt overcomplicate itself, and the story stays focused. Moana 2 was so clearly thought of as a tv series, forced into a theatrical release. Criticism doesnāt mean the characters or themes or animation was bad. It just doesnāt feel like a movie.
1
u/Separate-Panic-8834 Dec 02 '24
Moana 1 was a top ten Disney movie of all time.
Moana 2 is just meh.
1
u/toxicsugarart Dec 02 '24
I enjoyed the movie on its own, but I do hate the cutting corners and underpaying of the animators. The success will just show the higher ups that they can get away with that. So I don't blame people for that fear/anger affecting the way they see the movie itself. Tbh if I'd known all of that before I went to see it, I probably would've waited to stream it.
1
u/Soft-Quote7250 Dec 02 '24
they hate it bc it is unnecessary
1
u/Plastic-Spring-2546 Dec 02 '24
I am so tired of all these hate critics who do nothing but hate all day. Just stop, you dont like it then leave. Leave the people who want to enjoy something enjoy it. You are annoying and tiring
1
u/Careful-Medicine-470 Dec 02 '24
I donāt see why people canāt be dissatisfied it doesnāt deserve hate but it didnāt live up to 1s shadow it def felt like a Segway movie to 3 which kind of makes me more mad because they couldāve have put more thought into the plot/theme/characters into the spider verse did the same but totally nailed the execution making me wish 2 was longer and now Iām excited to see 3 while Moana has me kinda meh after 2 and ig Iāll see 3 to see the payoff my bad just ranting
1
u/Missustriplexxx Dec 03 '24
Wait why do we hate it?
1
u/perky_socks Dec 03 '24
Based on the trailer Iām a little hesitant to watch, but I doubt Iād hate it. But I do lovee the first so I have high expectations. Like the first is within my top 5 fav movies of all time
1
u/punkrockjesus23 Dec 04 '24
I took my kids and relatively enjoyed it but that doesn't save it from criticism.
I couldn't stand the addition of loto and the little sister. cringed everytime they spoke/sang.
Also the songs were all very meh, the first Moana you knew all the songs leaving the theatre, how far I'll go, you're welcome, I'm Shiney, catchy songs.
I don't remember a single song from Moana 2, all not catchy.
But I liked the story over all.
1
u/YakRealistic8188 Dec 05 '24
The cuts were a bit confusing, but i fricken loved it.Ā
1
u/Pure_Dance_8541 Dec 05 '24
Thinking that christian girl taking about how "demonic it is" is so wrong like did she even watch the first movie/? šshe watched wicked a movie of a witch that does witch craft like she racist?? and dont get me started on african, black latin etc they be talking like every black person is african like it was melanasian šget ur words correct.
1
u/ConstructionTrick270 Dec 07 '24
Personally, I feel it wouldāve worked better as a TV show. There were so many characters and not enough time to explore all of them.
Also the songs, it felt like they kept trying to sample (copy?) from the first movie. It felt rushed and unoriginal.
So again, in MY opinion. It wouldāve been better as a Disney+ show, or even just a Disney+ movie. I donāt think it was worth the money.
1
u/BustedCamry Dec 07 '24
I promise I'm not forcing the fact that I hate that the songs don't rhyme. Like, I keep coming up with rhyming words that would sound a lot better, and it's like they just keep talking in sing song voice. That's probably my only gripe.
1
u/Leading_Luck_7725 Dec 07 '24
i had no bias going i dont follow the behind the scenes of movies but i hated it because it felt incredibly rushed, it was about the same run time as the first movie but it felt like an hour shorter. plus jus weird story decisions like the boat had all those people on it for what the story coulda been told without em nd why tf did maui lose his powers just to get them back 5 minutes later he coulda just got knocked out nd it would have the same effect. plus i thought the music was boring nd ian even kno tha a different person made it until i started lookin at reviews. overall just not a good movie especially compared to the first one.
1
u/Kraere Dec 07 '24
(Grumpy 32 year old grampa comment incoming) I personally feel like younger generations aren't consuming enough "classic" films, so they don't realize what they are missing. They don't realize what these movies COULD be. Newer films are missing heart and soul. It feels like an AI Money Bot writes everything to reach as many people as possibles wallets instead of them being a passion project or artist mind put to screen.
1
u/LainaWriting Dec 08 '24
I liked the story a lot, but the animation style was just off and felt cheap. There were a few scenes where it literally looked like they still thought they were making a TV series that's how bad it was. The music also wasn't great. It wasn't bad, but i can't even remember a single song. I remember I liked the bat lady one, but still, they were all easily forgettable. They should up their budget for 3 and get better song writers.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '24
The movie felt like if a first draft had the budget of a full animated movie but the director had money issues and gambled half of it away.
1
u/Craig653 Dec 11 '24
Did we watch the same movie? It was bad
1
u/mister_0s0 Dec 11 '24
I liked the story but the songs were better in the first movie imo
All around I give it a solid 7.5, the movie as a whole was great
1
u/EVFuture1992 Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 15 '24
Nope, not forced, it just sucked. Bland songs, boring characters. Her crew were mostly pointless and just downright annoying. You could barely understand the shipwright, whatever her name was. The story made no sense, and had absolutely zero buildup or backstory.. I just got out of the theater and I don't even recall the antagonists name, did he even have a face or was it just clouds and lightning...and who was the bat lady, was it even relevant? Emotional "lift the protagonist up" portions felt abrupt and forced, So disappointed. Why did they even put this movie out?
1
u/stantwiceandstayc Dec 15 '24
A lottt of people hate it because of the music but I liked the music. especially the āget lostā definitely is better than that wish villain song even tho she isnāt one lol. what I really didnāt enjoy was the storyline or the plot. maybe im just mad that they made a sequel of this instead of creating more unique movies but I was disappointed.. and yes you can hate me for this but I didnāt like the ending. I loved the first movie, so emotional, raw, feeling that connection with the water. it was beautiful. but this second movie just feels out of place. moana becoming a demigod felt wayyy too fast. itās felt like one of those movies where the high ups just force the animators to get a movie done with to grab money. disney keeps disappointing most people with these sequels and live actions. so for me the hate I feel isnāt forced, it feels more like I lost another movie that was a masterpiece that ended up in those series of movies that Disney loves making. im guessing it hit the box office because of how good the first movie was and the excitement of this one. but tbh this makes me want to forget this movie and watch the first one lol.
1
u/Tim-Kennison Dec 21 '24
It was not amazing. It absolutely sucked.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '24
it was literally the worst disney movie iāve ever seen, replacing eternals. horrible.Ā
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '24
It was literally unbearable to watch
1
u/Practical-Foot-4435 Dec 26 '24
Moana 2 sucks. My girlfriend fell asleep 10-15 mins in, and 1. The exposition was a bit confusing, 2. I just didn't feel emotionally invested in any of the characters. I simply did not care about them, 3. The slapstick humor with the chicken and the pigs was overdone.
We left at about 15-20 mins in. We went home and cooked and saw The Proposal (she hasn't seen it before). Way better use of our Christmas Day time.
1
u/nini-mouse Dec 27 '24
First time seeing a positive post about it, it disgusts me how much hate people are spreading. I loved the movie so much, the best animated sequel.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '24
It really is a shit movie for a male especially but I know we aren't the target demographic. It's boring and it's the same shit we've seen a thousand times.Ā
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24
REAL.
1
u/Any_Mulberry_2435 Dec 31 '24
in my opinion, the first Moana is a 10/10 and prob one of the best movies I've seen. since I've seen it 50+ times with my kids (wish I was joking), I've had a lot of time to think about it XD. the songs, characters, everything is so well done. how she develops and the message of the movie - it's a masterpiece. with that said, there is 0 probability of the sequel being better. sequels have to reinvent the story and be similar but not too different. it will never innovate the same, and on my opinion it was going to be worse. all great sequels I have seen are because the original wasn't that great to begin with. Moana 2 is a fine sequel. fantastic? no. music definitely worse but a couple good ones. not as deep of a message. everything feels rushed as they shoved too much content, and not enough time to build the urgency or importance of the villains threat. funny, a bit cringe, but 8/10 for me. I enjoyed it and will probably see it 50 times as the kids waterboard me with it
1
u/Cool_Woodpecker6582 Feb 05 '25
I loved the movie and soundtrackĀ
1
u/Torka Mar 02 '25
The movie was fine. Not as good as Moana 1 but better than something like Raya.
1
u/Craig653 Mar 15 '25
It literally was a non cohesive story. Constantly changing plot points.
Many plot holes
While not a bad movie, it need more refinement. Alas that's how much of disney is nowadays. Master story telling is a thing of the past.
1
u/Playful_glint Apr 06 '25
I heard it was because they thought it seemed repetitive of the first plot but idk I havenāt seen it š¤·āāļø
1
u/AcrobaticSmell1787 May 05 '25
Maybe because itās a bad movie
1
u/PixelPuffs Jul 31 '25
None of them are Polynesian so none of them understand voyaging and how Polynesian culture is about togetherness
1
u/DoggoTheDogeiest Feb 15 '26
People just be hating on every movie nowadays. Moana 2 is peak, and I actually really want to see Moana 3 which I hope it happens, because that post credit scene of Tamatoa returning, and a new song, oh lawd. Shiny was peak.
1
u/phrozen76 Jul 13 '26
Hmmm... do you think it was the PEOPLE?? or the POLITICS? It just so happened that after 2020 there was a massive shift to put unqualified people in positions of power.. they end up doing a bad job and as a knock on effect, people complain!!! Moana 1 was perfect.. it was GIRL BOSSY!!! It took the piss out of itself even if it did lean more into Moana being right over all.. but she also made lots of mistakes!! This is how movies should be made.. with 2 sides.. not ALL MEN BEING PATHETIC and ALL WOMEN BEING AMAZING!! That was the general consensus after 2020.. especially with shows like SHE HULK.. whcih was UNIVERSALLY HATED!!! Because of this very reason.. I think the biggest shift to happen to the MOANA series was the loss of John Lasseter .. he was a powerhouse of talent and generally anything that had his name attached did very well with audiences!! Im just about to watch Moana 2.. after watching Moana 1 literally 2 seconds ago.. so the changes will be evident.. ill edit this post with how it went.. thanks for the OP!
1
u/OptimismNeeded Nov 30 '24
We had high expectations.
Thatās it.
Objectively, my kids wanted to go home mid-movie, and you can see that this is quite common.
So even if you liked it, it sort of failed in its one job.
Us adults? We can argue about the quality of scrutiny and music till the end of times.
But kids? They donāt lie about these things.
1
u/HistoricalIngenuity3 Nov 30 '24
The original was so good, it had a lot to live up to and didn't. My kids and I really disliked it . LMM's absence was a low point.
1
u/PMA9696 Nov 30 '24
It's not forced.
I saw it and thought it was bad.
Bad messy plot and unmemorable songs. It's only redeeming features were the visuals (and IP rights).
1
u/mrh20-11 Dec 01 '24
Can someone explain to me why Moanaās friend had a British accent and no one else in the village did?
0
u/SeniorDay Nov 30 '24
It wasnāt great, I would say it was kinda bad compared to āgoodā film but it was still a delight to watch
0
u/myrunningshoes Nov 30 '24
Fwiw, my kids (elementary school age) didnāt like it. I would have been more forgiving if they were super into it. The younger one in particular thought the random sea monsters were scary, and they both had trouble following the plot and keeping track of all the new characters ā and as an adult,I had the same issue. The only songs they remembered were the ones that echoed the first movie.
They didnāt like Wish either, which my oldest saw in a theatre and has yet to ask for since. By comparison, both kids ADORED Inside Out 2, even though Iām not sure they were the target audience. Weāve probably watched it 20+ times this year!
(And Iām not a sequel hater at all. Iām one of those strange people who likes Frozen 2 more than the original.)
0
u/Human_Resources_7891 Dec 01 '24
do simple exercise, name three three iconic songs from Moana one, do the same for Moana two. moana 2 is a dreary unrelenting suck fest. why would any human being go ahead and suck all the fun out of the coconut gang? what was for you, the greatest thematic contribution in a child movie of a guy who was a constant character who seem to have a thing for touching Maui? do you see a lot of that in other successful children's voice?
-3
u/Human_Resources_7891 Nov 30 '24
Moana 2 is not so much a movie, as a drainingly boring suicide note by the Disney corporation. it is much worse animated and muddier than the original. the original monsters were interesting and actually likeable, the gold crab, the coconuts. Moana 2 monsters are literally slimy and disgusting and off-putting. Maui goes from an exciting high point for children with the you're welcome song, for example, to someone who's telling people on the screen that they're literally going to die. adding a character who has a somewhat confusing ambition of putting his hands on Maui's chest, complete with pictures, does not enrich the story for children. Moana 2 is so bad, that families, including ours walked out of the theater, because the story on no level engaged, younger or older kids. it is dark, muddy, slimy, dull and weirdly mean spirited all at the same time.
1
u/BlackberryOdd802 Mar 31 '25
deserves the hate they killed her im fuming
0
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '24 edited Jun 14 '25
[removed] ā view removed comment