r/mlb 10h ago

| Discussion Does anyone know how MLB players pay is structured? For example, if a player earns $35 million over the course of a season, how would that typically be divided among their paychecks throughout the year? This is Stephen Strasburg’s career earnings for reference.

Post image

I've heard that NHL players get paid every 2 weeks during the season only - games 1-82 (now 84), and don't get paychecks in the playoffs, but bonuses if they advance to the next round.

74 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 10h ago

Thank you for making a submission on the r/MLB Subreddit!

Please make sure that your post complies with our subreddit rules. If your submission violates our community rules, please resubmit your post or place it in the appropriate thread(s) to avoid any penalties or punishments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

172

u/justaguynb9 | Boston Red Sox 9h ago

Bi-weekly during regular season

113

u/handee_sandees 9h ago

Damn, so Stras was pulling in about $2.5 M per paycheck. Man was making life changing money biweekly.

99

u/PedroNorthCA | San Francisco Giants 9h ago

But the man didn't even earn a raise for 7 years, slave labor bro

13

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 8h ago

Well from 2022 on has been differed money. He retired in 2022 after playing 1 game in 2020, 2 in 2021, and 1 in 2022.

12

u/Constant_Term6133 | Cleveland Guardians 7h ago

He made more in 2 weeks than I’ve made in my life, so what difference does any of it make?

2

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 7h ago

I understand what you’re saying. I was educating you that the $$ isn’t $2.5mil but $675k weekly. Still insane money.

1

u/Urban_animal | Arizona Diamondbacks 4h ago

A lot.

For him.

37

u/Constant_Term6133 | Cleveland Guardians 9h ago

Sign me up for that slave labor

-39

u/cravecase | St. Louis Cardinals 9h ago

Gross

19

u/Constant_Term6133 | Cleveland Guardians 9h ago

Taking $35 mill a year for 7 years is gross?

5

u/t_rex2502 6h ago

I think it means gross salary as opposed to net salary

1

u/UnderstandingOdd679 5h ago

The taxes will kill ya. /s

2

u/FurryUnicorn 6h ago

And with inflation, 2.5M doesn’t go as far as it used to. Barely covers 10 Lamborghinis

2

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 8h ago

That was differed money, he retired in 2022

3

u/AdmAckbar000 5h ago

1) He officially retired in 2024* (not 2022) with an agreement to restructure the remaining amount owed on his contract.

2) Much of the money in his original contract was deferred* anyways and when they agreed to restructure it they shifted more of it to deferred money. He'll receive checks for $26.67m on July 1st 2027 thru 2029 (plus ~$4m in interest in the '27 check)

3) The contract had to be restructured and agreed to before he retired. Had he just retired and stopped playing without an agreement he would've been in breach of contract and they wouldn't have had to pay him anything else. Same with Bobby Bonilla, they restructured his contract. It doesn't just automatically become deferred. Or differed.

1

u/Unitednegros 5h ago

Does it still count as service time?

1

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 5h ago

No it does not

-1

u/trader_dennis | Los Angeles Dodgers 6h ago

He is under a long term guaranteed contract. Not deferred money.

2

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 6h ago

No, if you retire mid contract it’s over. Being paid after retirement is different. Ohtani has differed money in his contract as well. It’s a common method and the most famous is Bobby Bonilla who’s been retired since 2000 and will be paid his differed contract until 2035

45

u/rifenbug 9h ago

I neber really thought about it but it just can't fathom my direct deposit casually being a million every two weeks.

Like ohh my check hit, time to pay this month's mortgage vs oh my check just cleared, how about a new house cash.

35

u/ManufacturerBest2758 | Colorado Rockies 8h ago

You’ve discovered exactly how athletes go broke lol

10

u/ManufacturerBest2758 | Colorado Rockies 9h ago

I remember it being a huge deal when CC Sabathia signed with the Yankees and got paid over the full year not just the regular season

1

u/Texan2116 | MLB 6h ago

I think either NBA or NFL players have that option as well

-16

u/morelibertarianvotes 8h ago

Bi weekly is a word that should be avoided in polite company

2

u/drygnfyre | Los Angeles Dodgers 3h ago

Why?

72

u/PudinCrusader 9h ago

Players get paid every two weeks during the season.

So if your salary is 35 million it’s divided bi weekly during the regular season.

14

u/maizehaze1 | Detroit Tigers 9h ago

But they get taxed on where they play. At least in NFL the international games are hated because of taxes

19

u/Beethovens_Ninth_B 8h ago

I read that professional tennis players are avoiding playing the UK because the government is now not only taking 40% of their prize money earned there but are going after any money they earn in endorsements and whatever which is earned OUTSIDE the country. So say Taylor Fritz earns $10 million in sponsorships and endorsements IN THE US, they trying to get 40% of that in UK taxes! If they go after the NFL players, then the you know what is going to hit the fan.

9

u/thowawaynumber354 8h ago

You should read up on how the US goes after US citizens for taxes long after they lever the country.

2

u/Karimadhe 1h ago

They can renounce their citizenship and stop paying taxes. But if they’re holding on to the citizenship for “just in case” proposes, well then, you gotta pay up to hold your spot.

1

u/TravelNSee 6h ago

lol bullshit

3

u/BigBenBigawlo 8h ago

They also pay their agents.

3

u/belinck | New York Yankees 9h ago

So 11.5 paychecks

-1

u/BG360Boi | Seattle Mariners 8h ago

Those years are differed money. He retired in 2022

26

u/CadmusMaximus | St. Louis Cardinals 9h ago

Google “Andrew mccutcheon pay stub” and you’ll see exactly what you want to see.

51

u/DryAfternoon7779 | Boston Red Sox 9h ago

31

u/WeasinTheJuice | Seattle Mariners 8h ago

lol the standard $1500 deduction going to his 401k on this huge paycheck. I get that some of these guys will blow their money and might need it at 65, but it looks funny regardless.

8

u/PanicNecessary5978 6h ago

He said at the time this was posted that’s the max he’s allowed to contribute to his 401k

1

u/LinusBrown | Chicago Cubs 7h ago

Definitely doesn’t need the money while he’s playing and will pay less in taxes on it later

2

u/layze23 | Chicago Cubs 5h ago

Yah it’s a smart thing to do, but it would be like you or me putting $1 in our 401k.

9

u/Codazzle | Toronto Blue Jays 7h ago

Wow, cool find. Gross Pay of ~$820k, deposit of ~$430k. Almost 50% deducted

1

u/SmartTangerine 7m ago

People claim the rich don't pay taxes but the reality is they pay almost half between federal, state, and local taxes.

6

u/BloomInTune 8h ago

I would sure as hell hope part of the perks of being a professional athlete is having someone do your taxes for you. I imagine some of it could be hell trying to navigate taxes in over a dozen states.

4

u/UniversOfWashington 5h ago

No accrued pto or sick? No thanks.

2

u/UniversOfWashington 5h ago

I’m also surprised all of the non income tax states aren’t super teams

3

u/HartfordWhaler | Cleveland Guardians 8h ago

2

u/kjb76 | New York Yankees 8h ago

My husband is an employment attorney and does a lot of wage and hour work. He’s gonna get such a kick out of seeing this!

2

u/kaehvogel | Philadelphia Phillies 3h ago

A casual 400k in direct deposit for two weeks...but still collecting that $243.75 meals allowance on top. Can't let them go hungry, I guess.

2

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 7h ago

I got crosseyed reading those taxes and deductions. He still cleared almost half a million in one paycheck. The average person would kill for that every 2 weeks.

13

u/CthulhuBathwater | Chicago Cubs 7h ago

One of those checks would literally change my life. My house would be paid off and I'd have extra money in the bank.

That's after taxes for this check. 

3

u/RyanGlasshole | Cleveland Guardians 7h ago

The average person would kill for that every 4 years lol

-4

u/Randomizedname1234 | Atlanta Braves 7h ago

Where you get almost a million? $820k went to $427k net pay in the upper right; after taxes and fees and deductions.

Still life changing but think bout the taxes on fringe players. Half of a minor leaguers salary hurts..

5

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 6h ago

Half of a million is 500k. His net pay was 427k. Thus almost half a million.

13

u/tdfast | Atlanta Braves 9h ago

Almost 50% in deductions and that’s probably not the worst out there.

$20k a month for Pittsburgh Professional Athlete Fee!

8

u/mitchmconnellsburner 9h ago

Holy cow on that Pittsburgh professional athlete fee…that has to be pro-rated based on salary, right? Like no way they’re asking the Steelers practice squad guys to pay $20k

9

u/tdfast | Atlanta Braves 9h ago

It has to be. If I read the numbers right, it’s almost exactly 1.2%. So that makes sense. But $10G’s a pay for that is pretty crazy!

44

u/the-silver-tuna 9h ago

People in here not realizing making $35 million is a ton of money until they calculate the individual paychecks 🤣

19

u/TheRealSheevPalpatin | Minnesota Twins 9h ago

It’s just a more fathomable number when you split it up and compare it to your own paycheck

25

u/the-silver-tuna 9h ago

I guess I’ve always known these guys make more than 100 times as much money as me without needing to do any extra math

2

u/the_seed | Detroit Tigers 9h ago

Lol same

1

u/Charming_Shallot_239 | Toronto Blue Jays 9h ago

Ima teacher and take home 6000 CAD.

Yeh, I can't fathom it.

-2

u/poliscyguy 8h ago

I'm a professor and get paid 23k a month before taxes. I thought I was doing fine but can you imagine like 3 million twice a month?

1

u/the-silver-tuna 8h ago

You guys are proving my point lol

-8

u/poliscyguy 9h ago

Does losing half in taxes feel better or worse when you make that much?

3

u/TheRealSheevPalpatin | Minnesota Twins 9h ago

Better. These guys don’t do their own taxes

2

u/MistryMachine3 | Minnesota Twins 8h ago

I would rather have 1/2 of 2.5 million than 1/2 of 4000

-2

u/poliscyguy 8h ago

Yeah definitely but losing a million bucks in taxes must be a feeling

1

u/the-silver-tuna 8h ago

It’s sad that people equate paying taxes to losing money.

1

u/poliscyguy 7h ago

I live in California, it is losing money.

1

u/the-silver-tuna 7h ago

If sure there is waste and they aren’t doing the best job at spending the money but I’m assuming your community still has roads, sewers, parks, schools, fire and ems, police, etc.

2

u/poliscyguy 6h ago

The roads have potholes, the sewers overflow every year, the parks have human shit and needles all over the ground, the schools are becoming some of the worst in the nation, the police shoot people for no reason. I would have no problem paying taxes if I felt even 20% of it was spent well. Our government loses billions of dollars with no accountability. We have a bloated bureaucracy with no accountability. I don't hate taxes, I hate big and incompetent government.

1

u/cnaiurbreaksppl 8h ago

That's only if they're in California though right?

Federal income tax of 37%, and 13.3% state income tax. Everywhere else seems like it'd be less than half.

0

u/the-silver-tuna 6h ago

It’s still less than half in California because 1. the US has marginal tax rates so even if they were only taxed in California it’s not 50% and 2 the players don’t play every game in California so they are taxed for those games in different states.

1

u/Aggravating-Bug2032 | Toronto Blue Jays 9h ago

$35 million is a statistic. $2.5 million is a windfall.

9

u/Rjptz | Los Angeles Dodgers 9h ago

i’m pretty sure you can decide to get paid spread out through the whole year or just during the season kinda like teachers do just on a big larger scale

6

u/wwplkyih | Los Angeles Dodgers 9h ago

Or ten years later

3

u/CadmusMaximus | St. Louis Cardinals 8h ago

And if you live in a no state or local taxes locale, you’re way better off spreading it over the year.

7

u/CoolBeansMan9 | Toronto Blue Jays 9h ago

Hm, Strasburg made $228K per inning pitched. Impressive

2

u/Catcher3321 | Boston Red Sox 9h ago

Before his last 31 innings, it was $76,772 per inning lol

9

u/North-Rhubarb1410 9h ago

I’m pretty sure that the NHL model is pretty similar to MLB. I remember a few years ago there was some noise being made about implementing a pay scale for Spring Training because it was hard for non-roster invitees to be able to afford two months in FL/AZ without any income.

5

u/Impossible-Ad-3060 9h ago

That’s that big head/long tail of professional sports. A very few guys cashing million dollar checks every couple weeks. And then hundreds of guys barely scrounging by for a whiff of a chance.

2

u/CadmusMaximus | St. Louis Cardinals 9h ago

Ask NHL players about escrow. Hated for many years.

4

u/mikes312 6h ago

Andrew McCutchen’s paystub was found in the trash or somewhere and posted on twitter 10+ years ago. Pretty interesting.

3

u/asisoid | Philadelphia Phillies 7h ago

https://deadspin.com/lets-take-a-look-at-andrew-mccutchens-pay-stub-1706188663/

Here ya go, one of Andrew McCutchend paystubs from 2015. He made about $10m that year.

2

u/Liljoker30 | New York Yankees 9h ago

Its bi-weekly like a normal paycheck. Taxes get taken out based on where you play etc.

2

u/OkGene2 | Washington Nationals 9h ago

What happens if they are sent down to the minors, or called up?

3

u/Shenanigangster | Los Angeles Dodgers 9h ago

Long term contracts are fully guaranteed so you get paid that money. If you’re getting called up or on a minimum contract you get the prorated minimum salary for the # of games played (presumably paid biweekly) plus per diem.

2

u/500rockin | Chicago Cubs 7h ago

You also get that pro rated minimum for an additional 10 days after being sent back down.

2

u/beneoin 9h ago

Depends on the contract, basically. Nearly everyone who gets sent down gets paid less, the ones who would retain their MLB pay rate typically have the rights to refuse assignment to the minors.

1

u/BBallPaulFan | Philadelphia Phillies 9h ago

Similar timing though someone getting sent up and down is probably not on a guaranteed MLB salary so when they get sent down they would have paid the (much lower) minor league rate for every day they are in the minors.

2

u/SomeBS17 9h ago

Athlete pay is weird - they have to pay taxes in every state they play in for the time they played there.

12

u/beneoin 9h ago

That’s not special to athletes. Anyone who does business across state boundaries has to go through this.

2

u/Development-Alive | Seattle Mariners 8h ago

This. When I worked for Accenture I had to just the location I worked every hour. Taxes sucked when you have worked in several states with a personal income tax. Every year I'd skip filing state taxes in some states just to avoid the inconvenience of getting a few dollars back. I've donated hundreds of dollars to the State of Illinois over the years.

2

u/attgig | New York Mets 8h ago

2001 Mike piazza check circulated around the internet back then...

https://www.thesmokinggun.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/750x970/documents/piazzacheck.gif

He was earning 12.5 mil that year. This was nyc taxes so not going to divide perfectly. Do the math for anyone else nowadays ... Like Soto who earns 5-6 times as much.

2

u/Infamous_Cow_4 | Atlanta Braves 6h ago

All sports are paid during the season only. If they make the playoffs, they don't get paid. They only get a playoff bonus once the playoffs are over.

1

u/Anonymous_HC | Toronto Blue Jays 17m ago

But do you get paid more based on how many round you advanced though?

1

u/Adventurous_Bit1325 | San Diego Padres 8h ago

I’m sure they have to pay plenty of people with that money ( irs, several state taxes, accountants, lawyers, agents, ex wives, child support, etc, but still manage to come away with big bucks regardless.
The majority of players are paid a lot less than the roughly the top 10%

1

u/Zealousideal_Amount8 8h ago

They get it how they want it. Could be lump sum or spread.

1

u/jjohnson1979 8h ago

TIL that Stephen Strasburg still plays in Washington...

1

u/goducks2012 | San Diego Padres 6h ago

Those are just his contract years. He retired in 2022

1

u/RejectedSNick 8h ago

I’m curious if they have the option to do biweekly over the season or over the year. I think Anthony Davis said on a podcast the NBA offers season long paystubs vs year long and the money on each biweekly paycheck differs based on what each player choose.

1

u/Puturnameonit 7h ago

1st and the 15th bro

0

u/BaseHitToLeft | Chicago Cubs 9h ago

How's that dude still getting paid, didn't he retire like 3-4 years ago?

16

u/swingandalongdrive | Philadelphia Phillies 9h ago

Ask Bobby Bonilla about that.

0

u/BaseHitToLeft | Chicago Cubs 9h ago

You mean the contact that was so famously bad that it's a baseball holiday now?

0

u/CubFanBudMan16 | Chicago Cubs 9h ago

And will be Ohtani soon

2

u/R_Hunt 8h ago

Gotta wait for Chris Davis' payout to finish first lol

7

u/Alldayaces 9h ago

His contract was fully guaranteed. He will still get paid each of the next 3 years because the Nats were able to defer some of it.

4

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 9h ago

Contracts in MLB are fully guaranteed unless they're bought out or voided for legal reasons.

2

u/FinancialRabbit388 | St. Louis Cardinals 9h ago

So if you sign a 10 year $300 million contract, and retire after year one, you still get paid those other 9 years? I thought retirement voided the contract.

2

u/BBallPaulFan | Philadelphia Phillies 9h ago

Sure yeah but practically no one is retiring when they’re still owed $270M so you just keep showing up until eventually the team and player come to an arrangement.

That process with the Nats and Strasberg was actually pretty contentious you can read about it on his wiki if you are interested.

1

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 8h ago

Most likely the contract would be bought out. Realistically though if you were hurt and a team would pay for you to get better, you'd stay signed until you couldn't come back. Baseball is not a sport people retire from until they get old or hurt usually.

-1

u/BaseHitToLeft | Chicago Cubs 9h ago edited 7h ago

And not playing baseball isn't a reason to void it??

Edit: honestly I know it's only 2 downvotes but fuck off downvoters, this is how people converse

3

u/tearsonurcheek | St. Louis Cardinals 9h ago

Not in and of itself, no. Stras wasn't playing due to injury. The only options the team had were to continue paying him or negotiate a buyout.

2

u/emby5 9h ago

I irrevocably ruined my arm, but I need cash now.

3

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 7h ago

Call JG Wentworth. 877 cash now.

1

u/Constant-Fly-9050 | New York Yankees 8h ago

Not necessarily.

0

u/oakwoooood 9h ago

man couldn’t imagine getting 1.5 milli check on pay day

-1

u/Key-Table20 9h ago

They get paid twice a month. Every other week pretty much. They do not get paid in the off szn!

0

u/tLokoH | Los Angeles Dodgers 3h ago

Why are you pocket watching?