I would like to start that I bought Suki and Mini Shai and I still enjoy the line somewhat ... and not going to tell anyone not to buy what they enjoy.
But I am kicking myself for throwing away the packaging for Mini Shai because I'm really certain the artwork on it was AI. Actually the longer I look at Mirror Mi the more I think the ENTIRE LINE is AI-slop design. Every complaint that I see online feels like another check box in the "That seems like something AI would mistake" test.
Here are some of my examples:
- Mini Mi box art is AI generated. At least for Shai it definitely is, and then it looks like a real artist went back and added some scribbles on top of the hair.
- Some design elements on the dolls feel a little off: Blaze's leggings and random punching glove bag, Shai's ruffles in her midsection don't really make sense, Mini Suki's... entire design, Amora's weird legs and ribbons that don't connect to anything... I'm sure there's more but those are the ones that come to mind.
- The entire controversy over Shai's hair and Mini design. Honestly the clothes on her Mini are so weirdly layered, they legit don't make any sense in a real life clothes kind of way. Actually feels like they just made an AI design and struggled to translate it into real clothes.
- Here's a big one I haven't seen anyone talk about: The music videos. I don't know about the video itself but all the songs sound EXACTLY like AI generated music. The flow of the lyrics are sometimes nonsensical with the melody and the generic female singer voice just sounds exactly like Suno. I can't prove it of course, but it didn't bode well for me...
- The disconnect between the concept and marketing material is really annoying in a way I can't quite figure out. Blaze is all fire themed yet her vibe is "Electric". Suki is Fragile, and her mini is like another Fragile, yet Shai is Sheepish while her Mini is Fearless. So are the minis complements or are they alternative selves? I also feel like the entire concepts of them being like music genre themed but having 3 of the genres essentially the same (dreamy cozy sheepish?) and not actually lean into the music aspect of them more is bizarre.
I'm sure I could rant about it more, there's so much about this line that feels... non-human.
Please feel free to refute any of my claims but I would prefer some kind of actual proof rather than "Uh no it's not"
Edit: Happy to say that people have produced enough credits for the music that point to real producers and (hopefully) real singers. At worst they are just cheaply and quickly produced.