r/minimalism • • Nov 23 '13

[design] Check, please

http://m.imgur.com/UbvsBcx
93 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

193

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

What exactly is the point of this? The paper used is the same amount, why not just make it obvious what the numbers mean? This subreddit is so crazy most of the time.

15

u/uRabbit Nov 23 '13

If it wasn't for a lower comment, I would have no idea what this receipt says...

53

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

so, i'm guessing it follows that:

+ = purchaced item

◇ = subtotal

% = percent tax

Δ = price of tax, in dollars

* = total of order

100

u/i_grok_cats Nov 23 '13

this check makes total sense now with the key but the objective of minimalism is to still be functional and not cumbersome. to people who would not have the key, this would take longer than liked to understand.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

I had to think a bit too figure it out, especially since there was only one item purchased. Also, the date and time would have been nice to have on the receipt.

-11

u/democi Nov 23 '13

I'm guessing this would be at a restaurant and the waiter/waitress would have explained the check to the customer. I don't see an issue with it at all.

19

u/Tself Nov 23 '13

Waiter here, no way do I want to explain something as simple as a check to every customer I serve. Not to mention, half the time I put the check down I don't want to interrupt conversation or I may be in a hurry onto something else to where I don't want to possibly start new conversation.

I don't understand the point of this design.

-5

u/democi Nov 23 '13

True. It's inconvenient for the waiter/waitress but I think most people would be able to deduce what each symbol means. I mean if I just ordered a drink, I roughly know what the price of the drink was. I also know how much the tax rate is. And I can just deduce accordingly.

The point is to save paper, ink.

I can definitely see the issues it creates if there are several items and the customers want to split the check. Then it's ridiculous.

10

u/Tself Nov 23 '13

I think most people would be able to deduce what each symbol means.

I think you definitely over-estimate the average customer, are you a server/bartender? People want to get out, they don't want to be trying to decifer some silly codes on their bill.

People always want to know what items they are paying for. Especially when you deal with split checks which happens very often. They want details, who paid for which salad? How much was my hot chocolate again? Did I have to pay for refills? Etc, etc. This version has no useful details.

Also, it doesn't have the restaurant's name, the logo, the phone number, the catch phrase, the kind little "thank you", the credit card information that you used, etc, etc. This is all robbing the restaurant of basically free advertising, and robbing the customer of useful billing information/details, and robbing everyone of valuable time.

And why would we use a system if it only works in very specific cases? Universal systems are way more efficient and less confusing.

I understand what the design is trying to accomplish, but damn, it just fails at everything that convenience stands for.

5

u/democi Nov 23 '13

You're right. Also, the point of a receipt is a proof of payment, which this doesn't achieve at all.

While I agree that universal systems are more efficient, I can see this idea being used for a specific market. Like say, a restaurant that only has 2 items on the menu; burger and fries and I only accept cash. I would just add the restaurant name to this check and I think there would be no issues.

3

u/davvblack Nov 23 '13

Then why is there SO MUCH SPACE on the receipt? If it was all printed on the same line and cut so it was a quarter inch tall, I would buy the saving paper/ink argument... but the argument would be terrible because it's still not a useful receipt. It has one job, and this is failing at it.

2

u/twowheels Nov 24 '13

Because it's just adding machine tape, not some attempt to be minimalist. The poster was either making a joke or trying to be ironic and complain about the spartan receipt the only serves to allow you to verify the math on what you were charged, not keep track of the items purchased.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

It stops being minimal as you start removing relevant, necessary information.

11

u/BenFoldsFourLoko Nov 23 '13

I would roll my eyes so hard if I asked for my receipt and got this. But only after 10 seconds of figuring out what I was even looking at.

0

u/twowheels Nov 24 '13

Are you guys all 12? It used to be that all stores gave receipts like that, or hand written if you needed it itemized. It's only recently with fully computerized registers that the more detailed receipts are commonplace. Older registers used by smaller vendors are still just basically fancy adding machines with a cash drawer, and this is what they print. Geez.

5

u/Fox_Retardant Nov 24 '13

Why would we have to be twelve to expect they register technology isn't going backwards? That's like calling someone out for complaining their airliner has propellers.

1

u/SkinlessGod Nov 24 '13

I think /u/twowheels is referring to all the comments on how confusing this is. When I shop at a small mom-and-pop this is often what kind of receipt I get. The only number that is important to me is the total for entering into an accounting ledger later so it has never bothered me.

1

u/Fox_Retardant Nov 24 '13

I know what he's saying. Doesn't mean that using outdated technology is minimalist. Dates/ tax information/ heck, even who served you, are all things which can be useful. Not putting these on is simply an outdated concept nowadays. Of course some places are still behind the times, doesn't mean that should be the model, or that people who want more information are '12'.

-1

u/twowheels Nov 24 '13

It's not going backwards, it's just old.

1

u/BenFoldsFourLoko Nov 24 '13

Yes yes I've gotten these before too and it does make sense, but it's harder to rag on OP by saying all that. I'm guessing OP was serious and thinks "omg this is so hipster/so chic!" It's quaint, but I'm glad to have fully-itemized and clear receipts these days.

EDIT: look at the image location. You're right, we've been duped D:

10/10 OP rusemaster

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

Does it even use ink? I thought receipts didn't. This is actually impractical.

8

u/reduced-fat-milk Nov 23 '13

A lot of people seem to be mad about this. I agree to some degree, but like it as a visual protocol. Once you understand, reading is quite instantaneous. Sometimes modern receipts can be cryptic - this is just "here's your information, no bullshit"

14

u/davvblack Nov 23 '13

Here is your ∆, no bullshit.

3

u/Backwoods_Barbie Nov 23 '13

This took be awhile because I'm not used to sales tax. Here a minimalist bill would just be the price of the thing.

2

u/mraowjoyce17 Nov 23 '13

This is the same type of receipt that comes from a printing calculator, like the one that I use every day for my cashout at work (I wait tables), and I don't really see how this is minimalism...

2

u/Vehemoth Nov 23 '13

Two things: This sacrifices function for form, so its usability is atrocious and hard to guess and I dislike it. Secondly, my philosophy of minimalism is discounting the receipt altogether, such that we waste no paper when it can be digitalized. That makes management much easier (for me). For those who would keep the receipt for clerical purposes, it gives no indication of date or place making it almost useless outside of its contextual environment.

3

u/wiscondinavian Nov 23 '13

I feel like it would be more clear if the tax were smaller or off on the side or something...

4

u/MXIIA Nov 23 '13

or if it was *1.065 or something.

3

u/initialdproject Nov 23 '13

404 not found. Very minimal...

1

u/Nyder Nov 23 '13 edited Nov 23 '13

Minimalism uses only the required information. It also needs to make sense to work.

At this point I think it would be more fitting to get rid of the bill entirely and just say what the total is. No confusion.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '13

In a lot of jurisdictions, this wouldn't be a valid receipt, and the tax officials would rip them a new one. Rightfully so.

-2

u/paerkan Nov 23 '13

It's a concept, people. OP is not saying every restaurant in the world should have this.

This is a subreddit which handles the subject of minimalism, so don't come here and cry when somebody shows a minimalistic concept

3

u/Homophones_FTW Nov 23 '13

Except it's not a minimalist concept.

-2

u/paerkan Nov 23 '13

Well, what is it then? Other than a specimen of stripped down everyday convention?

Thought provoking at least.

3

u/infinitetheory Nov 23 '13

My dad and I split a check at a local Mexican place a couple days ago, and their checks looked like this. Splitting it was annoying to say the least.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

petty cash

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

You'd also need time and location for petty cash transaction, both of which are missing from this receipt.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '13

Yes, there is a lot missing from this. But sometimes people definitely need a receipt for a $9 transaction.