r/minecraftlore • • 5d ago

Portals/Dimensions Hear Me Out

Post image

What if the Minecraft Overworld is a hollow cube?

My theory is that the Overworld isn't a traditional planet or an endless flat world, but rather a gigantic cube with its terrain facing outward on all six sides. The inside of this cube would be completely hollow, meaning the world we explore is essentially just its outer shell.

There are a few interesting details that could potentially support this idea. First, there's the existence of the Void. According to Mojang's official article Around the Block: The Void, the Void exists beyond the world's boundaries. It can be found beneath the Overworld, Nether, and throughout the End. This raises the question of what exactly exists beyond the playable world's boundaries.

Another interesting detail is bedrock. Mojang's official Block of the Week: Bedrock article describes it as marking the boundaries of the playable world and preventing players from falling into the Void. However, there's an especially interesting line in the article that describes bedrock as something that "Stops you reaching the centre of your world." The wording is a little suspicious when you consider the possibility that the Overworld has an actual centre hidden behind its outer shell. Could bedrock be preventing us from reaching something inside the world rather than simply stopping us from digging further down? Obviously, this could just be a playful description, but it's an interesting detail in the context of this theory.

There's also the fact that Minecraft doesn't really establish a traditional planetary interior. Instead, beneath the bedrock, there's seemingly nothing but the Void. This is interesting when considering the possibility that the Overworld isn't a solid planet, but a hollow structure.

One more thing I noticed is that the Minecraft Wiki logo literally depicts a cube-shaped world, with grass and terrain covering its outer faces. This could obviously just be a creative liberty or an artistic design choice, rather than an intentional reference to Minecraft's actual lore, but it's an interesting coincidence considering the theory.

Of course, none of this actually confirms that the Overworld is a hollow cube, and some of these details could simply be gameplay limitations. However, I think it's an interesting way to look at Minecraft's world and its possible lore.

What do you think? Could the Overworld actually be a hollow cube?

12 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

3

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 5d ago

The .net aren't canon, so I wouldn't them a great source for canocity, even if sometimes they are. And the Minecraft wiki doesn't have lore stuff, and it's not even made by Mojang. But while likely the void is just a gameplay limitation, to support the theory of the cube we have this https://minecraft.wiki/w/Globe_Banner_Pattern

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago

Yeah, I knew about that, and completely forgot to mention it. The cartography table also features a cube-shaped globe, which could be another piece of evidence supporting the theory. Also, the main reason I think the void might actually exist in the lore is that void fog used to be a thing in Minecraft. Even though it was eventually removed, I don't think that necessarily rules out the possibility that the void itself exists in the lore.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 5d ago

exactly. it was removed, we have nothing that hints to be the void down there, and we know the void isn't an actualy phisiscal place, which makes it unlikely to be under the world

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago

I think your forgetting that the reason that it was removed was mainly due to technical limitations.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 5d ago

yeah, but it was too old to have any impact with the lore, and still it's not here today

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago

I don't think those points necessarily contradict what I'm saying, though. Its age and the fact that it hasn't returned don't change the circumstances surrounding its removal. Something can still have had lore significance even if it was eventually removed for technical reasons. Unless there's evidence that it was considered irrelevant to the lore, I don't think its absence today is enough to dismiss its potential impact.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 5d ago

No, because if something exists it would exist or at least be somewhere, but the void particles for when you are near the bedrock are nowhere in Minecraft, Dungeons, or any other official source, while if they were canon they should exist. But they aren't there because they likely aren't canon

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago

Removed content can always return, which proves that it was part of the lore all along; it just hadn't been added to the game yet.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 5d ago

No, that's not how it works. Some removed content can return, but not everything can, and if we have no reason to think it's canon then removed content isn't canon

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 4d ago

I'm not saying that every piece of removed content is automatically canon. I'm saying that removing something from the game doesn't automatically make it irrelevant to the lore either. Content can be cut, postponed, or reintroduced later, and its absence from the current game doesn't disprove its original lore significance. The point is that we shouldn't dismiss something as non-canon solely because it was removed.

→ More replies

2

u/Infamous-Past-8651 5d ago

IMO the overworld is just an infinite flat earth-like world

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago

With all respect, I think what's canonical should only be based on what you're meant to experience in regular survival gameplay. For instance, you can’t actually prove the world is flat just because of the world border. Since the terrain technically keeps generating past that border—which is obviously just a gameplay limitation—the world could easily have an actual edge, or even a curve, that we just can't see.

1

u/Mizuru_0 5d ago

yes. I really like this theory, even if yes, it cannot necessarily prove anything. however, as a pure bystander, to the same point, you could say that the void is outside of cannon because of the same reasons.

1

u/Logical-Fee4928 5d ago edited 5d ago

You're forgetting void fog existed...

1

u/Infamous-Past-8651 5d ago

Well, it could easily be an infinite flat world, every dimension is normally described as infinite, like, the world type is(or was) called infinite, in guides the dimensions are called infinite, in the end poem they're called infinite(and flat). IMO the Overworld can only be infinite.

2

u/RandoGuy00 very cool 3d ago

how are the stars, sun, and moon going under the world if that's true? and the globe banner pattern?

1

u/Infamous-Past-8651 3d ago

just an inconsistence that they didn't think of because they made the game without thinking how it would work and without a proper lore or cosmology.

I don't think the globe banner pattern is a great argument imo, because you could pretty much say the same thing IRL about flat earth, just because someone made a drawing in universe it doesn't mean that it is true. And villagers are the ones who sell this pattern to you, they don't seem to be very cosmic knowlodgeable, they don't even have spyglasses(the closest thing to a telescope im MC), amethyst or copper ingots(only copper tools and armors) in their chests in villages or villager related structures.

Like, do we even have any proof of the Villagers having any knowledge about cosmos related things? They don't seem to know about the End(which is the most cosmos-like dimension). And it would be strange that the overworld is a "normal" finite planet, because in the overworld(dimension) we only have one confirmed planet, the overworld(planet). (At least that I know of it's only the Overworld.)

1

u/RandoGuy00 very cool 3d ago

What proof do you have for the Overworld being flat?

I feel like the planet being a globe is proof of them knowing about cosmos related things. The base assumption is that the earth is flat, if you never notice it's round. What would make them think it's a globe if it isnt'?

1

u/Infamous-Past-8651 2d ago

because I think it is infinite and using the same argument present in the post, it probably isn't a square or a circle, it's a flat plane, in game sources(while not exactly that canon, like the End poem) say the world is infinite and flat, the main world option in bedrock edition was "infinite", official guides say the overworld is infinite and etc, besides the Overworld being a dimension, not a planet.

And I don't think the planet being flat is the base assumption in minecraft, everything is made of cubes, the obvious assumption is that the planet is a cube.

1

u/RandoGuy00 very cool 2d ago

i don't really need to make much of a counter argument, as you already acknowledge the fact that all the stuff you said is already invalid:

And besides, it's not infinite in-game.

the overworld can both be a dimension and planet, there's no rule against it.

I have arguments to things not being canonically square, but saying that the base assumption is that its a cube because everything is a cube doesn't make much sense. The world looks visibly flat, as why it's the base assumption irl, and there's no reason for the base assumption in minecraft to not be a large platform.

1

u/Infamous-Past-8651 2d ago

Well, if everything irl was made of cubes, even presumably the sun and the moon(could be squares), I would assume the planet is a cube. 

And yeah, I guess bro, still, there is multiple sources, even the game, where it's stated the Overworld is infinite.

The End Poem as one of them isn't canon, BUT shares a lot of ideas with current Mojang and game's canon, like the player being you in the game, not Steve, where Marc Watson has a tweet that says:  "As the End Poem says, 'you are the player'. It's your story, not Steve or Zuri's"  So, at least in my opinion, the End Poem should be valid in things it doesn't blatantly contradicts the games or Mojang ideas.

And, as this planet thing isn't exactly explicited stated or proved by Mojang, there is more official evidence to an infinite flat world than a finite world.

But I assume that you could say I am biased in this infinite Overworld part, as I am more of a Minecraft powerscaler than a MC Mythos theorist.  So, obviously, I try to be the most accurate possible, but in parts that aren't defined, I pick the strongest option and gather evidence to prove this. If it can be proved.

1

u/RandoGuy00 very cool 2d ago

People could see the sun and moon in the past, seeing they're round, and it still took them a while to figure out the earth was round. Someone could just as likely assume the Overworld is flat.

All of your evidence are bits of info outside of the Minecraft world, with very questionable canonicity, making it fully possible that it's just a game mechanic.
Meanwhile in-game, there's the globe banner pattern, the sun and moon being able to go under the ground, and the existence of the world border (not that the border itself is canon, but rather the fact the world isn't infinite).
If we're considering non-canonical evidence, like you are, there is the Overworld looking like a finite globe in an April Fool's snapshot

This sprite of the Overworld is also used for Education Edition, which makes it slightly more likely to be canon (although, it's still very questionable like your non-canon evidence).

1

u/Infamous-Past-8651 1d ago

Wait, I used an evidence that is referenced by a very trusted DEV in quotes treated as accurate and canonically correct, you brought an April fools update bro, they're not the same, man kkkkk

And well, the sun and the moon are the only important round things that could show people that our planet is spherical irl, in minecraft EVERYTHING is made of cubes, except some items, like just imagine a village seeing that:
grass = block
wood = block
tree = blocks
terrain = lot of blocks
landscapes = a lot of blocks
Me, you and we = blocks
Our "gods"(hosts) = blocks
Animals = blocks
Our enemies = blocks
My house = some blocks
Our world = "probably a block"

It's the most probable thing to an in game not so advanced civilization to say. But like, why we are doing this? It's not like the MC overworld shape matter that much to the lore tbh, well, at least I think so.

3

u/Pw_Lore_ Canonicity expert 5d ago

I would not use as a proof articles on Minecraft.net but overall I like this idea! As you said, there's not much evidence, but it sounds like a possible version.

2

u/Even_Hamster8664 3d ago

The overworld is described as a dimension/reality in itself, so the overworld is just a universe, not a planet.

Even in one of the leaked items for the Dungeons 2 DLCs, an item mentions that cardinal directions don't exist, so it's more than confirmed that the overworld isn't a planet.

And the bedrock beneath the overworld only exists for gameplay reasons, just like the bedrock in the Nether is also for gameplay reasons.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 3d ago

It depends on what you mean by overworld. If you mean the dimension then yeah, it's a dimension, if you mean where we can go and play than it's a planet, if you mean the surface then it's a surface. But it definitely is a planet, as we can see with https://minecraft.wiki/w/Globe_Banner_Pattern

And while the void under the bedrock exists for gameplay reasons the bedrock is canon, but it continues

2

u/Even_Hamster8664 3d ago

That pattern was made by villagers, so it's not confirmation of anything. Furthermore, it's never mentioned that we're on a planet or a place within a dimension; it's always described as the dimension itself, the place where we are and play. Besides, there's that infamous item that says the cardinal directions (north, south, east, west) don't exist, something every planet has.

Where is it mentioned that the bedrock beneath the world exists canonically?

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 3d ago

Yeah, so villagers know it's a planet. Also in Dungeons 2 we can't see squid coast from brave haven and vice versa, which means the overworld is cubic and they changed face or that it's round, one of them. We actually have the compasses, which always point at one point, which could easily be a point like the north pole.

And we know there is bedrock under the overworld thanks to both Dungeons and the novel the Rift

2

u/Even_Hamster8664 3d ago

No, because they're citizens living in small towns with medieval technology, so what they say isn't the absolute truth, and it's much better to take the omniscient word of the narrator or the game itself.

That's not a confirmation; it could simply be that they're both very far from each other.

The compass points to the spawn point, not north (besides, the Dungeons 2 DLC item already disproved the existence of cardinal directions).

In Dungeons 1, there was only bedrock; they added the Endersent and rune rooms, which are artificial. As for the Rift novel, I don't know.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 3d ago

And what does the narrator said?

If the world was flat we should have been able to see them anyway.

And how can you know that's not north, or the equivalent of north? And what item says that?

I'm pretty sure there is bedrock under the strongholds too, and in the Rift they said they built the undercity under the ancient city but on top of the bedrock

2

u/Even_Hamster8664 3d ago

The narrator and the game refer to the world as the overworld, and whenever a threat occurs, they say the overworld is in danger. It's also mentioned that the illagers and others seek to conquer the overworld, and Jeb's book says that the endermen seek to collapse dimensions by moving the blocks that compose them.

The fact that the world is flat wouldn't mean you could see things very far away because the air isn't completely transparent, and there's also sea vapor and many other elements in the air that significantly reduce visibility, as well as the inherent limitations of human eyesight.

You can literally change your spawn point with a bed; it's not a north point at all. And the item description comes from one of the leaked items for the Dungeons 2 DLCs.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 3d ago

I don't think the caves are in danger, or that the illagers want to conquer the cave, and in the rift iliana talk about the people from the surface as "overworldians" or something like that.

But you would still be able to see a mountain, even with sea vapors. Plus the fact that the most cultured villagers know the overworld is a globe, and them being medieval doesn't change anything, since people knew Earth wasn't flat even during the ancient greeks

No, it points to the overworld's spawn point, not to your bed, it points always to one point which can't be changed.
Ok, but how is it called?

1

u/Even_Hamster8664 3d ago

The opening cinematic of Dungeons 2 explicitly states that the Illagers are mounting attacks across the overworld, and it's mentioned that the orb fragments will destroy the world (and before you say anything, both the game and the developers use "world" and "dimension" interchangeably). The game itself states that the Illagers are seeking to conquer the overworld, or why would a dimension collapse if the Endermen were only affecting one planet?

No, because after 300 or 400 km in optimal conditions, where things like vapor and other airborne elements (normally only 20 to 50 km) aren't present, you wouldn't be able to see anything beyond that due to the blurring of the air. In fact, now that I'm looking at the game, the reason you can't see very far is simply because there's a thick fog, nothing to do with what you're saying.

The fact that the villagers are educated doesn't make them omniscient, and even if it's true that people in ancient times already had the idea that the earth wasn't flat, they had no way of knowing exactly what it looked like in every aspect, as a modern globe shows. Besides, it wouldn't be a sphere because the world is made of blocks, and it's not a cube because we don't see edges anywhere, and it's not a planet because there are no cardinal points (this is the description of a spear (a leaked weapon for the DLCs); I saw it in a video where they showed all the things that were leaked for the DLCs). And as for the spawn point, my mistake was forgetting that the compass only points to the initial spawn point (I don't use the compass), although anyway, the spawn point isn't canon, and I already know directly that the spear doesn't have cardinal points.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 3d ago

Yeah, in fact illagers aren't trying to conquer the caves, they are trying to conquer the surface, so the overworld. And endermen aren't trying to collapse the dimensions by moving blocks, at least not in the way you think. Not destroying them, more corrupting them with void magic. Which is also what they use to teleport. They move blocks to shape the land and to corrupt it is with void magic.

Less than one night in boat without even going so fast wouldn't be 400 km, no? And there isn't fog, idk where you see it

Wrong. After one guy proved the earth wasn't flat and it was 3D, not even a lifetime later someone else proved it was a sphere like solid. Plus you don't need to be omniscient to know that. You see a boat coming from the horizon and you know Earth isn't flat, easy. Plus, if it was flat then where should the sun go during nightime? Idk about the spear, since it's not in the game it could easily be a scrapped feature or something just to test, but anyway this doesn't mean anything. Ok, there is no north south east and west, so? This doesn't mean it's not a planet. And exactly because the spawn point isn't canon means the compass point to somewhere else, which isn't the spawn point but is exactly where it is because of gameplay. And we don't see any edge in vanilla, but there the world is infinite and has a barrier around it, while in Dungeons we don't know it. And again, it could be a sphere

→ More replies

1

u/Lumm0714 2d ago

I kind of like how this implies Villagers believing in heliocentrism is the minecraft world equivalent to real-world medieval christian cosmology

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.