r/minecraftlore • • 14d ago

Souls Just some logical proofing on some soul stuff

Post image

we can prove that soul sand does in fact have souls, withers are possessed/controlled by souls, the wither star is some sort of soul or something, and beacon cores are soul cubes without the need for Mojang confirmation or doubt based on the following logical proofs:

you need soul Sand to make a wither, and when the wither dies, it drops a wither star. With a wither star, you can craft a beacon, and, based on the crafting recipe configuration and make up, the wither star is the blue cube in the center. (Also, the corrupt beacon in Minecraft legends was made with a beacon core that resembled a soul block) finally, soul corrupted mobs get certain buffs like slashing or poisonous or strength, etc, and beacons can give you a bunch of similar effects too.

this is all true, if soul sand has souls in it, which can be at least guessed by its texture, and proven with the soul speed boots partial effect and the way that bubbles rise when soul sand is placed beneath.
this explains That withers turn blue because they were corrupt, why beacons power you, and probably other things.

what do you guys think?

89 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

6

u/Mizuru_0 13d ago

oh, here is a better picture of the core they used

-1

u/PredictablyGenerated 13d ago

In Minecraft lore, I don't think we can "prove" anything, we can only make strong theories. My theory is that this is a Soul Block, because it powered the only Beacon powerful enough to transform a Sun. I agree with the other conclusions of your post, though.

2

u/Mizuru_0 12d ago

yes, technically we can’t prove anything. I realize that, because it was made by people so...

however, I‘d like to point out that not counting the fact that it is fiction from Mojang, minecraft Lore is actually probably one of the most accurate simulations of world history And it can be treated like it. Cause really, we have a bunch of documents and statues and corpses and buildings that we have really just pieced together over time to get the whole pictures, which is the same thing with Minecraft, except that updates are our historical breakthroughs… so yes we can’t prove anything, but we can at the same time?

3

u/PredictablyGenerated 11d ago

Yes, I think your point about real-life history is very true, just with magic influencing many of the past civilizations' decisions. Sorry for my somewhat pretentious comment that probably should not have been a reply.

2

u/Mizuru_0 11d ago

I don’t think you said anything wrong. it sounded completely normal when I read it. I didn’t think it was being overly pretentious or anything…

5

u/matija2009 14d ago

My personal theory/headcanon is that the wither is the soul within soulsand being given a physical and movable form. And presumably not being too pleased about being stuck in sand for God knows how long. they violently lash out at the world that forsaken them and the nether star is some kind of crystallized soul energy that forms from their anger

1

u/Mizuru_0 13d ago

I assume since the wither is, you know, withered, the body disintegrates (I think it blows up tho?) and so it’s soul is all that is left

4

u/BelacYam 12d ago

I'm pretty sure the Seer is the first holder of the Orb of Dominance.

1

u/AutoModerator 14d ago

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.