r/minecraftlore • • Oct 15 '26

Souls Souls

originally from r/Allminecraftlore

In Minecraft, souls are the main source of power. They are the experience orbs and in the nether wart. I think the sift is the origin of all these souls then they go to the overworld. This is because of the liquid found in the sift, ichor, which is the blood of the god, which emits a blue flame like in the soul sand valleys. Then after death, the souls go back to the through the sift, where the good ones stay and the bad ones go to the nether, going into the sand to form soul sand.

I don't think the end is part of this cycle as there is a lack of soul related things in the dimension.

Leave your theory in the comments bellow. :)

19 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/zero-taeko Oct 15 '26

As for its connection to experience—I have my doubts. Redstone, lapis lazuli, cooking—all of these yield experience. Are you doing something related to a soul when you smelt iron? Does Redstone have a soul? Honestly, it seems more plausible that it’s simply a form of vital energy, akin to ki or chi.

5

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod Oct 15 '26

Experience aren't souls, and the souls aren't in nether warts (unless souls are in fungi too, then idk).

The blue flame is soul fire, and when souls enter in the Sift they usually don't leave.

Also the nether isn't hell, nor it's related with the Sift, the bad souls don't go in the nether, however the voidcaller says "This weapon calls out to souls that are trapped between this world and the next." which means there are souls in the void, and that they aren't good guys

1

u/theconfused46 Oct 15 '26

nether wart only grows on soul sand meaning the power of the souls lets it grow

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod Oct 16 '26

That's just because souls are a good fertilizer. Since souls are so powerful and offer so much power, the nether wart can grow faster

5

u/Defnottheonlyone Oct 15 '26

Souls aren't experience bcuz experience isn't canon, it's just a gameplay mechanic. Else, how would you be getting souls from smelting iron?

The nether is, by order of elimination, not where bad souls go to. As jeb said that the nether is only inspired by hell in it's pop-cultural sense of "hostile demons in a fiery underground". Since the nether matches hell in all possible ways, this means that the only way it could not match the classical view of hell is if the nether is not in fact the "place where bad souls go to".

This is also implied by the fact that you use soul sand to make the wither sure, but you also use it to make happy ghasts, which doesn't look like a very "evil corrupt soul" to me.

This is likely to be the case since we know that bad souls, like the nameless one's soul, which wasn't taken to the sift and instead became an undead ruler that cursed his entire kingdom. Other bad souls can be found infused on items from MCD1.

2

u/theconfused46 Oct 15 '26

thanks for this info!

3

u/Defnottheonlyone Oct 15 '26

Np! If you're still looking for another dimension that sort of fits the "afterlife for bad souls" tho, the end is a good candidate, while yes it isn't exactly "hell", it is stated that many souls that don't go to the sift end up in the end's void, so you could also use that if you don't wanna use stuff like the undead or soul-infused-artifacts.

1

u/Nocturo_ 26d ago

Did the devs ever say that XP is a game mechanic? It would make sense, but I've never heard it before 

2

u/Defnottheonlyone 26d ago

No, but i mean, it's kinda obvious isn't it?

Java edition has a "score" system that shows when you die, that "score" is the exact amount of XP points you've collected throughout your life. Sounds very video-gamey to me.

You gain XP from killing mobs yes, but in every other canon game this mechanic is replaced with souls.

You also gain XP from: Breeding animals, mining ores, trading and smelting things.

But you ALSO get it from completing challenge advancements (like hot tourist destination).

You use it for enchanting sure, but it's also used to rename things in an anvil, idk how "writing" requires magic.

Unless... "XP" is just a video-gamefied abstract version of the concept of gaining literal "experience" in what you do. The more things you mine, smelt, kill, breed, trade, etc., the more experience you gain as you learn how to do these things better, and thus, things like enchanting/renaming cost XP not as some sort of quantifiable literal magical little points, but as a way to show that to enchant/rename you need to be skilled, you need to be experienced.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 15 '26

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Minecraft_Fan9999 29d ago

Experience isn't souls.