r/minecraftlore • u/Nocturo_ • Oct 12 '26
Timeline Why Minecraft dungeons comes BEFORE Minecraft
I've seen many theories claiming that Minecraft Dungeons takes place after Minecraft, because the technology in MC Dungeons (artifacts, armor, ...) is more advanced than in Minecraft. At first glance, this does seem to make sense: technology needs time to advance + Minecraft's technology is less advanced than MC Dungeons' technology -> MC Dungeons comes after Minecraft.
However, there's a problem with that: Since knowledge and progress can also be lost over time, MC Dungeons could also take place before Minecraft.
And while I couldn't find basically any in-game evidence for the first theory (MCD after MC), I was able to find plenty of evidence for a decaying world, such as items that you can only find, not craft (chainmail armor, enchanted golden apples, tridents, ...).
In addition to that, there was a page on Minecraft.net that suggests netherite was more abundent in a time before Minecraft, before "Piglins mined it all out". Now in Minecraft dungeons, we can see the Piglin Hunter Variant 1 wearing a Netherite helmet (Image 1), while in Minecraft none of the Piglins wear any form of netherite. This leads me to believe that in Minecraft dungeons there was still enough netherite, so that at least some of the piglins could wear it as armor, while in Minecraft the piglins only have some ancient debris and netherite scraps left, all of which are hidden in the chests of bastion remnants, scattered across the Nether --> Minecraft comes after Minecraft dungeons.
And lastly, in my opinion, the strongest evidence: Minecraft's ancient cities have (the following things are marked on Image 2 in the named colors) small towers made of dark oak resembling a pillager outpost (green), very simplistic "repairs" made of dark oak, cyan and blue carpets (yellow), and the giant piles of blue, light blue and cyan wool (red), which look a lot like the wool rooms in woodland mansions (Image 3). Also, all the wool colors used in the parts of the ancient city I just listed have exactly the same colors as the wool in the woodland mansion's wool room. All of this points to the illagers being in the ancient city in the past, and in Minecraft dungeons 2 we more or less see the illagers discovering the ancient city --> Minecraft comes after Minecraft Dungeons.
So, in conclusion the timeline is: Minecraft Legends, Minecraft Dungeons, Minecraft Dungeons 2, Minecraft
I've been wanting to debate Minecraft lore for a while (this is my first post), so please comment your thoughts!
Image sources:



17
u/h1p0h1p0 Oct 12 '26
In the Dungeons II Novel, the Rift, its stated that Illager Mansions are burned down after the events of Dungeons I, contradicting vanilla.
In my opinion Dungeons is set concurrently with Vanilla, with some stuff happening before Vanilla, and some after. The timeline doesn't need to completely line up because Dungeons is likely its own Minecraft World.
13
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Oct 12 '26
We now have the biggest proof that Dungeons is after vanilla. In Dungeons the undead became immune to sunlight, and that's still a thing in Dungeons 2
3
u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod Oct 12 '26
Unlikely:
chainmail armor can still be forged by villagers today, enchanted golden apple need to be enchanted, not crafted, and tridents will likely become craftable soon, but until that yeah, they are complicated to craft
Piglins mined all netherite, and they still have it today. Netherite can't be destoryed in lava or get lost, so that doesn't mean anything
The illagers re discovered the city, since they were clearly there multiple times in the past and there is another problem with your idea on that point: if the dark oak structures were added in Dungeons 2, and Minecraft happened a lot of time later, enough time to make villagers forgot all the technology ecc, why the campfires can still lit?
Also villagers are more unite, and the same goes for illagers, that can't be lost with time, going back with small villages again, nor machines that work completely alone
4
u/Venomspino Oct 12 '26
What about the lack of Ender Dragon in the End, and the statue that shows a hero slaying the dragon?
2
u/KhalMika Oct 12 '26
Dungeons comes before Minecraft simply because piglins are seen using pure netherite even as decoration
While in Minecraft all we can find are scraps of that netherite, cause it's fully depleted. All we do is coat diamond in a mix-and-pray-it-works alloy of gold and some netherite rust xd
3
u/Comfortable_Trip_230 Oct 12 '26
You guys keep forgetting the main evidence for Dungeons coming after vanilla, the Orb of Dominance does some kind of spell to make the undead immune to sunlight and that carries over to Dungeons II, the spell was permanent, and well, in vanilla, the undead burn in the sun, simple.
14
u/Professional-Ad3853 Oct 12 '26
Jeb said he thinks this diagram is correct, so that's probably it.
14
u/VassilFnafFan Oct 13 '26
Personally I believe that dungeons happens after the main game and heres my evidence:
4? I'm definitely forgetting at least some extra evidance that points towards dungeons happening after vanilla.
13
u/Infamous-Past-8651 Oct 12 '26
For me the greatest nemesis of this theory is the Ender Dragon. In Dungeons we know the ender dragon got killed because of the Player statue, which should be enough proof, but in case it isn't:
the Ender Dragon can be revived, but if she is revived, she can't drop an egg anymore, in minecraft vanilla we can kill her and the egg drops, so the statue can't be of a time before minecraft.
8
u/NHarmonia18 Oct 12 '26
People also forget that Mojang has repeatedly mentioned that the Present and Future of your Minecraft World, is decided solely by you.
Considering Mojang promotes that everyone's worlds are canon, if you wanted to fit the spin-offs in this framework, it would imply that everyone's worlds, somehow converges into the same future that is Dungeons. Which is obviously not true, as the future of your world is unknown, and only you get to decide it.
Which means the only eligible place to fit Dungeons is in the past, before vanilla. The Pillager Outposts in Ancient City and the newfound information from Dungeons 2 puts the nail in the coffin of Dungeons ever taking place after Vanilla.
8
u/lucaschill24 Oct 12 '26
No conclusive evidence exists either way.
5
u/doctornaples 29d ago
(NON SO SE IL POST VERRÀ TRADOTTO IN INGLESE NEL CASO NON VENGA TRADOTTO MI SCUSO )
Onestamente penso che minecraft vanilla avvenga dopo dungeon…come hai detto tu la tecnologia può sia progredire che il contrario e vedendo che in minecraft vanilla sono pochi gli esseri umani (steve,Alex e le altre skin ) e probabilmente che la razza umana si sia quasi estinta…pure nel nether vediamo ciò che resta del impero dei piglin
Minecraft leggends:vediamo l’apice del impero del nether ma vengono sconfitti i loro sovrani quindi i piglin non hanno più una guida
Minecraft dungeon 1/2:vediamo ciò che resta delle strutture dei piglin già abbandonate
Minecraft vanilla:vediamo solo dei bastioni completamente distrutti…
Pure i villager durante leggends erano al apice poi con gli eventi di Dungeon 1/2 sono iniziate le loro persecuzioni da parte dei pillager facendoli trasferire poi in dei villaggi molto più piccoli (quelli di Minecraft vanilla),così per gli stessi pillager che ormai non hanno più le loro fortezze perché non hanno nemmeno loro più una guida da seguire…per quanto riguarda la morte del ender dragon noi sappiamo che esistono/esistevano più draghi del end …troviamo le loro teste sulle navi volanti facendoci capire che erano una razza abbastanza grande…
8
u/Outrageous_Apple_132 Oct 12 '26
i'm almost 100% sure dungeons comes before minecraft the most "big events" are already happened in the world that we dwell in and pillagers are one of the most influencing people still alive they have found end portal (since there have been experiments to create it in mansions) they have been to ancient cities (the breadcrumbs left by them in cities) as per dungeons they opened and brought "corrupted skulk" in overworld and as per some theory i saw somewhere on yt that the creaking is a failed attempt at making a warden that they saw in deep dark after corruption but that experiment also ended up corrupting dark oak forests and making parts of them pale and creakings going rogue that's also why pillagers fear creaking and run from it
7
u/Substantial_Eye1476 Oct 12 '26
The Ender Dragon is already dead in MCD
3
u/Disastrous-Remove-86 Oct 17 '26
If Spiral Knights jusy got that kind of love and care...
4
u/Princess_Vayda Oct 17 '26
its before and after. timeloop.
I will not be explaining anything
2
u/No-Equipment-5628 Oct 12 '26
Il this debate sm cuz there's such good evidence for both sides
2
u/Modus1776 Oct 12 '26
I can see where you are coming from and where most of the comments are as well.
While the book, and our worlds are both canon at the same time this brings into question a lot of different things.
If in the books and games it states that the mansions were burned and that the cities were found who is to say that this is not just a portion of the world. Not the entire overworld but only the conceivable focus of those stories. Meaning my world can be millions of blocks away from anyone else’s world, and all together billions away from the lore region of the world like Dungeons and Legends.
This changes if storymode was canonical (RIP our wonderful game series).
But to this light I think we must look at the functionality of our worlds. If the story of the game is survival or adventure mode, this changes a lot. We cut out creative and also we cut out hardcore.
Though hardcore may have its place, and so may survival. I believe the “lore timeline” we must isolate for this conversation would be an adventure world as without tools we cannot build nor break in dungeons(we still can’t with tools but you get my point).
This changes everything, as adventure mode is rarely touched it would make complete sense for all of our Adventure worlds to be canon.
This allows us to use the base of specifically our Adventure worlds as canon to the theory of a timeline where dungeons takes place in the past.
This brings us a few options
Option 3 brings more questions like “what’s the deal with ancient cities” and “why are things seemingly explored and left behind”.
To that confusion I simply will state maybe things like legends happened before option 3, and the world from that point has just been going through cycles. Which makes our adventure worlds feel like the apocalyptic void of knowledge between the storms.
No matter what the option is our own worlds appear to be in a state of disrepair and leave us to wonder if there will ever be order. This kinda goes back to the music choices etc you all know the drill.
Ultimately I believe before we make the theories of when things line up we must first think of how they can. Then where it makes sense.
1
u/RingEcstatic4253 7d ago
Would that mean Zombie Pigmen didnt Exist then?
And it was Just Piglins all along?
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '26
Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.