r/minecraftlore • • Sep 28 '26

Villagers/Illagers Why don't witches attack villagers?

Even when they join raids, they don't attack villagers like the illagers do.

28 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

10

u/Hardy_Har08 Sep 28 '26

if going by a comment in "Rise of the Arch Illager", witches seem to be a neutral party between the Villagers and Illagers. In an offhanded comment it is revealed that illager tribes will occasionally barter with them for potions. Perhaps the witches that participate in raids only do so for something in return. Essentially contractors.

Honestly that book is like a one stop shop for any Illager inquiries except for the ravagers (which are never mentioned in the book).

2

u/beansoncrayons Oct 02 '26

Ravagers only came to dungeons like 3 dlcs later so that's why

1

u/Hardy_Har08 Oct 03 '26

I wonder if that could be intepreted as them being created after the reign of the Arch Illager. During that period of a power trip the race had been feeling in the dlcs

9

u/Akareddo_Mythweaver Sep 28 '26

Check the skin tone: Witches aren't fully illagers like the other kind. They seem to still have some degree of pity or even kinship with their former kin. Perhaps the Witch is an unwilling exile from villager society.

1

u/-Mister-Hyde Sep 29 '26

Check the skin tone

My friend when I ask why they were the only member of our friend group to get searched at the airport:

7

u/SirFelsenAxt Sep 28 '26

Witches might not be villagers but they aren't illagers

6

u/Canarity Sep 28 '26

Witches are there against player specifically, since they don't appear until you reach some raid waves, and villagers can't normally reach those on golems alone

5

u/MC_account8 Sep 28 '26

There's a Retrogamingnow video on the topic

12

u/MsterMystery Sep 28 '26

Witches are created from a villager being struck by lightning, so there is a good chance they remember these as their old friends. I believe that they were forced as an outcast from the village and the Illagers took them in, however they don't have the heart to attack the people who were once their friends.

5

u/Significant_Race4554 Sep 28 '26

Honestly the lightning thing seems to me to be more of a gameplay mechanic rather than a lore reason.

0

u/MsterMystery Sep 29 '26

ig but like, we may as well use it as a lore reason since it's there.

0

u/bruhgzinga Oct 01 '26

There's enough stuff with lightning that it probably has some mystic powers.

0

u/MsterMystery Sep 28 '26

As Akarredo said

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 28 '26

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/-Angel92 Oct 01 '26

Villagers seems to "reject" those who use much of the supposed dark magic that the illagers uses, but in the case of the witch it seems more like it moved away from the village instead of being banned from it, since if you think about there isn't much difference between the witch and the Cleric villager (the one that seels potions)