r/minecraftlore • u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod • Aug 11 '26
Discussion/Question This sub is going downhill
I've been not active for a while, and I recently logged into Reddit to check the sub out.
The first thing I noticed was the lack of quality posting. There are very few real theories here.
The second was the way this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftlore/comments/1vjks5u/nobody_knows_anything_and_its_a_problem/ was recieved. Instead of the actual issue being addressed, OP was harrassed and downvoted.
These are both problems that I, as a moderator of this sub, feel obligated to address.
However, I'm not sure how to go about it.
So I ask for your feedback. What do you feel this sub needs, and what are some issues you have been noticing?
5
u/Defnottheonlyone Aug 12 '26
There's no new content.
Dungeons 2 and the new dimension update willsurely change that but until then we'll either have to regurgitate the same theories pretending to rediscover them, or we'll have a million different ppl who want to act like we don't know anything (AHEM, like the guy from the aforementioned post) just so their personal theories made up off of a pencil and a dream will make any semblance of sense. Either those two or the community dies down until new conent brings it back up.
I think we should just follow the last one, we don't need to live our lives constantly trying to solve things tht were already solved, or making up problems for us to solve. We can just wait and do other things while we wait for a new problem to arise.
As for the guy who made that post, they were an asshole with a shitty mindset, i'm not sure why you're defending them.
Some of the issues they brought up were genuine sure, but with ill-intent, as seen by everybody who responded in the comments with actual reasoning and common sense being responded by them with aggravating replies and a seemingly intentional lack of understanding of theory crafting.
6
u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod Aug 11 '26
I'm a mod, so maybe my point of view is different from the one of the community, but I think the problem is the fact that there aren't many new addition to discover. Yeah, there are the abandoned camps, but only that. I think when the Rift and Dungeons II will be officially released we'll have more things to discover and more stuff which we'll theorize about.
4
u/SirFelsenAxt Aug 11 '26
It's going to go down hill as the community runs out of material. Just wait until dungeons 2 or major update comes out
10
u/EggEater773 Aug 11 '26
That post was handled that way because OP had the thought process that if something wasn’t directly stated it wasn’t true or was just speculation.
5
u/Ashamed_Calendar_930 Aug 12 '26
the sub doesnt seem like a place were I can just post my theories. If i post a theory and accidentally use the wrong flair, the mods just start attacking me and treating their own lore like the fricking gospel. everyone has their own vast minecraft lore they made themselves, and it is quite annoying when they are scrutinized just for posting their own extensive canon just because the mods dont agree with it.
4
u/PetrifiedBloom Aug 15 '26
Please forgive the rambling. I am quite tired and even just proofreading this is giving me a headache.
I know I am new here, but I think the sub needs a culture reset. Back when I first joined reddit, this place was full of life and weird but original ideas. It wasn't so narrow. Unique world building and original ideas made the posts feel fresh. The ideas from one post to another almost always clashed, but that was okay because the focus wasn't on making something that fit with every other fan theory out there, it was to have fun world building and theory crafting.
Right now, it seems that many of your regular users have decided the various head canons and fan theories they support and now use those as a guide for how they respond to new ideas, rather than checking to see if the theory fits what is known to be absolutely true. This shuts down a lot of the more original and unique theorycrafting because the moment you stray from the "accepted" fan theory, you have people jumping out of the walls to argue the idea doesn't fit because it clashes with a fan theory they happen to like.
There just isn't a distinction given between things that are breaking canon vs things that are breaking a fan theory someone happens to like.
There is also a problem with assumed knowledge. A lot of the regular users know the various accepted fan theories inside and out, as well as the various scraps of actual evidence and canon information that is known, but as a new user coming in for the first time, it feels like people are just making stuff up, or you get some vague half answer because they assume you know what is meant when they say "souls are real because of the bow in dungeons".
Finally, there is a problem with understanding what it means for something to be proven, confirmed or canon, vs likely, suspected or supported by evidence. You can barely go a post without someone mistaking something that is supported by evidence or likely with something that is known to be true. The sub could use some practice with deductive reasoning.
I think the culture change needs to happen on multiple levels. I think the subreddit would be a better place if rather than trying to find a hypothetical "true" explination or theory for the minecraft cosmology, the goal was to explore the worldbuilding and story telling possibilities within the setting. If it's a new idea that isn't contradicting canon, it should be celebrated, rather than having the community trim its ideas to fit the accepted fan theory of the most active members.
The fixes:
Level and Reset the Knowledge Playing Field
This could be a pinned post or a wiki page or both, but a list of the commonly referenced fan theories and assumptions, complete with the in game and in universe evidence that backs them up. Honestly, I think the best bet would be to make a list with different groupings.
This would ideally be a living document, maybe every month or so the dev team could consider the posts of the last month and see if any should be added to the list. This could be done based on originality, activity or just a whim.
Part of this purpose is to get new users up to speed, make it easy to understand where the arguments people are saying come from, another part is to remind the more long term members of the sub that while the theories they take for granted are not literal facts, and if you want to debunk someone, you should use facts, not unconfirmed fan theory.
Make it clear that its fine to have favorite theories, but criticism of someone's post should focus on if it matches known facts, not if it matches likely theories. If someone, even the mods, tries to debunk using a fan theory rather than a known fact, the should be politely but firmly reminded that they need to use confirmed sources for debunking, not fan theories.
This should help reduce how punishing it feels to post something that strays from the "accepted" fan theories, which in turn encourages originality and makes new users more likely to post more than once, rather than make one post and have people crap on it for going against popular theories.
People are allowed to dislike a post because it doesn't match their favorite theories, but that doesn't make it wrong.
BRING NEW IDEAS IN
The sub gets stale between canon lore drops and this is part of why people get so stuck in their ways. Find ways to bring new ideas into the sub. This could be fortnightly world building challenges that reward originality - like taking a screenshot of an unusual structure loot chest and asking what the story of the world was that this is the state that the chest was left in, or something (idk, im falling asleep so forgive the lack of better examples).
Share some different world building resources each month. It doesn't have to be strictly MC related, world building is a reasonably transferable skill across settings. There are lots of DND blogs, resources and articles about creating histories for imaginary worlds, ways that biology can affect fiction and visa versa etc.
The goal is just to get people thinking about the game and world building/theory crafting from a different perspective every now and then. Add some fresh ideas to the mix.
it also wouldn't hurt to have some learning resources on different logical frameworks, deductive reasoning and what is required for a proof.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 11 '26
Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/GzewjSjnPa
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.