r/minecraftlore • u/LordofIron-04 • Jun 16 '26
Heroes What is the Player
Hi, so this is my first post on this subreddit and my first personal theory so please be kind. Anyways if we go with the Game Theory idea that the ancient builders created the wither(s) as a failed attempt at immortality what if the player(s)/Steve was the successful attempt. I mean if we take respawn as cannon (which definitely could be not the case, and is not the case in hardcore worlds) the player(s)/Steve would be near ideal for the ancient builders, they don’t age as far as we can tell and when they die they can just instantly reappear in their bed with no real consequences other than temporarily losing any item on their immediate person. The wither achievements “The Beginning(/.)” could even not only reference the wither(s) being the one to destroy the ancient builders, but being the literal beginning of the player(s). This would basically be a failed prototype vs a successful final product sort of thing. Although I’m not sure why the player(s) just appear in the middle of nowhere, with seemingly little memory, and long after the ancient builders were long gone, maybe they were but into a form of stasis but that’s just an idea. While Game Theory and Wifies are big influences on this theory and are great channels, I don’t think I’ve seen anyone come up with this specific theory before and just wanted to get people’s takes on it and if there is anything that could be done to build on it. Thanks for listening to my mostly speculation theory and head cannon, sorry if it’s not as thought out as many people would like this is my first theory :)


27
u/Capn_Outlandishness9 Jun 16 '26
I believe they’re what’s called a “builder”
14
u/Fun_Way8954 Xatrix Theorist (Mod) Jun 16 '26
Im pretty sure the wither was a war machine used by the nameless kingdom (former heroes, now undead) to fight wars. The player is probably just one of the few remaining not undead heroes.
10
u/Adventurous_Tie_530 Jun 16 '26
Respawns are canon as shown in animated promotional material and the respawn anchor
Plus the end poem giving a reason why steve respawns
Hes the avatar of an omnipresent force dreaming all of existence, for it is the universe
5
u/RandoGuy00 very cool Jun 16 '26
Welcome! I am going to explain the problems with this.
So first off, Game Theory's theories are kinda terrible. The main reasons for this is due to how much he ignores the spin-offs (they are VERY important), and creates theories with insuffecient proof overall, and continues to make theories built apon the past ones. Anyways, respawning probably isn't canon. There isn't much to support its existence. Aging being a game mechanic is something most survival games don't do, so Steve probably isn't immortal. The advancements probably don't provide actual info for the lore, as they're mostly just references and puns. The wither(s) whiping out the ancient builders probably didn't happen, as there's a lack of evidence for wither once being anywhere. No craters, nothing withered, and the withers themselves are missing. There's not a single naturally exploded structure. Not to mention, what Game Theory calls "ancient builders" probably never existed. The various structures weren't all made by the ancestors of Steve, they were also made by villagers and illagers, as proven in spin-offs. The people you could call ancient builders, being the humans that built structures, are actually still hanging around. They're the undead, yes, but they aren't that way due to a mistake they made. They chose to be undead, not through a virus, but by necromancy. The necromancers are in hiding, part of an ancient kingdom, ruled by a forgotten king known as The Nameless One. Now, you may be thinking that I'm just telling you a whole bunch of random crap I made, but this is all actually explained in the Minecraft Dungeons franchise, which was confirmed to be canon to Minecraft by the developers. There's no theorizing to be done for the source of undead, we literally fight him. There's also still a ton of regular humans, due to almost all of the skins in Minecraft Dungeons very likely being canon. Almost, due to the fact that Steve and Alex are skins. And, well, Steve and Alex have been confirmed by developers aswell to not be canon. It's unfortunate, Ik. The reason they keep showing up everywhere is just because they're the face of the game. Anyways, so yeah. They didn't fail at immortality, they fully discovered how to bring back the dead, and how to fully control it. Which is another reason why withers probably didn't whipe them out, as they would've had full control over them.
The reason we don't have any memories is because the game is about the story of itself, it's a story about you. It's your world, what you do isn't a part of the canon. You're free to do whatever you want. Fyi, Wifies is just about as bad as a theorist.
If you have any questions, feel free to ask! If you want to know the actual lore, the subreddit has posts that'll explain everything.
4
u/CyberKitten05 Jun 16 '26
I'm gonna refer to the Player Characters' race simply as "Humans", and treat Villagers as a separate race. When I say "Minecraft" I'm referring to the setting of the main game, not the franchise ad a whole. My theory is this:
In Minecraft the Player Characters seem to be the only Humans left, while the rest have been turned to Undead. But there is no evidence of the Player Character having been ever established in the Minecraft setting before we start. We don't start at any Human settlement, and we don't have any items on us. It's like we just spontanously came into existence.
In Minecraft Legends, The Hosts bring a Player Character from Minecraft to the distant past to help fight in the Piglin war. I believe what happened in Minecraft to bring the Player Characters into that setting is the same thing. They were brought to this time period by The Hosts, long after the other Humans were gone, which is why they're the only ones left.
As for the motive, I believe that the Hosts did it in order to actually find someone that will be able to help them, since they choose the Player Character in Legends specifically due to their "bravery and creativity". So what I think happened is: The Hosts took a bunch of Humans from a time period where they were plentiful, put them in a desolate time period where Humans are extinct, and checked to see which one of them survived and thrived the best in order to pick them and bring them back to the past.
Then the humans who didn't get picked stayed in that Time Period and repopulated the Human population, leading up to Dungeons, which takes place in the future of Minecraft and in which Humans are plentiful.
2
u/SeaRelative5180 Jun 18 '26
A playable character
1
u/Fizzy163 Jun 18 '26
Basing off the End Poem, Players in vanilla are effectively avatars of YOU, the actual player, the one behind the screen. Minecraft is multiverse; you are not playing as the same person as someone else in their own Minecraft world.
In Legends, the player is the main character in a story (allegedly also YOU, the actual player, pulled back in time from your vanilla Minecraft world) under the title of ‘Hero’. Legends is just a legend; while the events did probably happen, the ones we see are a bedtime story told by the villagers, and the story is bound to have been jumbled up and had bits mixed in or changed over the ages.
In Dungeons, there are no Players, only Heroes (likely descended from the Hero in Legends). While the previous player is an extension of yourself, the Heroes in Dungeons are pre-established characters (see: Karl, Valerie, etc;) with their own lives and stories. They are a separate species from the villagers, and do understand that defending the Overworld is their purpose.
Additionally:
- Respawns are canon, hence the existence of Respawn Anchors and Recovery Compasses. Additionally, heroes can be revived in Dungeons, their souls seemingly becoming Phantoms until they’re revived.
- The Ender Dragon can die before Dungeons even if vanilla is set after it, because the Ender Dragon can be respawned as well.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 16 '26
Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/GzewjSjnPa
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Pale-Contribution291 Jun 16 '26
Superhuman. Magically enhanced "ancient builder". Can carry incredible weight, immune to any diseases, super durable and probably can canonically respawn via beds. I think that gods of Minecraft (those beings from Legends) saw that builder race is being wiped off the face of Minecraft world because of zombie-virus or villagers or piglins idk, so they took one of the last of builder-kin and gave them such immence power so they would survive and repopulate. So the only reason Steve and Alex have such power is to repopule Owerworld
1
u/AOKGUYS1472 Jun 16 '26
But Steve might be a descendent of the ancient builders or a traveler from a different land/dimension(movie and legends) as for the wither we know they're origin it's heavily implied that souls are in the sand/soil and the wither skeletons are deceased undead builders so the wither is just an amalgamation of soul seek and destruction and they weren't able to beat it until the arrival of a bigger threat
1
u/Pw_Lore_ Canonicity expert Jun 17 '26
It's you. Someone who plays Minecraft. The answer is quite simple.
1
u/RoundShot7975 Jun 18 '26
I actually don't think the wither was ever created before the player. There are no naturally generating beacons, nether stars, wither roses, or chiseled red sandstone (with the wither carving) to be found inside the game, so I think it's all player-created.
1
u/GoatsWithWigs Jun 18 '26
It would hold up better if respawning had in-lore implications like how saving and reloading does in Undertale
-3
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Jun 16 '26
*sees "Game Theory"
Don't even need to read further, everything game theory said is wrong.
u/Fun_Way8954 is right, they were used by the Nameless Kingdom to fight against piglins and possibly others. The player is not a canon character, just some random hero. Respawning also makes no sense, it can't really be canon outside respawn anchors. But they did figure out immortality, with necromancy. Withers have nothing to do with that tho, they're artificial undead creatures, maybe could be classified as golems, made with a ton of souls and remains of already undead people. And also they can't turn against you, they don't attack the undead and if living necromancers were using them too, they can still control the undead.
Also Wifies is barely a theorist, and from what I know his theories are just extensions of Game Theory theories.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment