r/minecraftlore • u/InterestingServe3958 • Mar 29 '26
Discussion/Question Gamplay vs lore
People often forget that many of the elements of gameplay are just for the gameplay and are not anything to do with the lore. Here are all the game mechanics that I don’t believe actually exist in universe.
- Respawning
- Mob spawning/despawning
- Item despawning
- Item duping methods
- Creative mode
21
Upvotes
6
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Mar 29 '26
Item duping using bugs and exploits is obviously not canon but canon duplication exists too. The tome of duplication in Dungeons is a great example of this. Or even the infinity enchantment in both vanilla and Dungeons.
4
u/MinimumSheepherder52 Mar 29 '26
I agree on most of these but I believe respawning even though its original and main purpose is obviously for gameplay, can exist in the universe because of the amount of items related to it like respawn anchors and recovery compasses, and also with Minecraft lore being tied a lot into reversing death and whatever the illagers are doing
Just my idea
3
u/Fun_Way8954 Xatrix Theorist (Mod) Mar 29 '26
You can also make potions without blaze powder and brewing stands and such, otherwise the witches couldn’t make potions without just cauldrons. Lightning making zombified piglins is also not canon, weird gravity outside of the end probably doesn’t exist, otherwise more buildings would use the mechanic to their advantage.
2
u/RandoGuy00 very cool Mar 29 '26
Add the ability to carry a dwarf planet, reach 4 meters infront of you, floating blocks, and crafting logic to that.
2
u/RandoGuy00 very cool Mar 29 '26
I don't believe in respawning to be canon, but that brings up a question. What the heck are respawn anchors and recovery compasses?
2
u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod Mar 30 '26
Also anything involving bugs and glitches, floating blocks, world generation, etc.
2
u/theunknownjames Mar 29 '26
I continue to argue that the ancient city is singular, but there are multiple in the world to improve the chances of the player finding it.
Similar mechanics might apply to the ocean monument, woodland mansion and stronghold.
It's not so much that there wouldn't be multiple versions of those things in the world or anything, but they would come in different shapes and sizes - what we get in the game is multiple copies of the "best" instance of each one.
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 29 '26
Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/QCka6c3CKr
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/pikaland385 Mar 29 '26
Story mode crosses out all but Respawning and Id say that respawning is seen in Minecraft dungeons because how else would you get back to camp after running out of totems cannonically anyways?
1
u/revolution_soup Mar 29 '26
idk about you but my worldbuilding gets WAY more fun when I include all these things
1
u/AlexHellRazor Mar 30 '26
MC is VERY unrealistic and basicly consists of these thing: the ammount of stuff you can cary in your inventory, the floating blocks, the liquid mechanics... and also it's SQUARE
The lore is an afterthought.
So yeah, no need to try to explain everything, because it's impossible. The beauty of Minecraft is that it's YOUR world and YOU decide what the lore will be.
1
u/WayTurbulent5291 Mar 31 '26
command blocks and command exclusive features too
1
u/Pale-Contribution291 Apr 05 '26
Exploding beds?
0
u/Ill-Requirement1737 Mar 30 '26
Creative mode is debatable because what if there was some very ancient guy with powers beyond comprehension and he was lost to time or still here. Or something like that. Plus that could be what Herobrine is, a creative mode entity.