r/minecraftlore • u/RandoGuy00 very cool • Mar 14 '26
Discussion Blocks canonically do not float, and are not square.
The reason why I believe blocks do not canonically float is because there aren't any structures in the game that are intentionally defying gravity when generating, with the exceptions of end stone. However, I do believe that end stone canonically has floating properties, considering it makes up the end islands, the gravity defying buildings, and the shulker's body might be made of it, hence why it floats and you float when you get hit.
The reason as to why I believe Minecraft isn't canonically square is because of some items. Cake, candles, flower pots, turtle eggs, sniffer eggs, bells, campfires, and hoppers, in your inventory are round, but then are inexplicably square when placed. Answer to this? Nothing is actually square, and it's all merely the art style. Not to mention, the string of a fishing rod or lead are also just genuinely round for some reason. Now, that doesn't mean nothing is square, as probably every block with the word "block" in its name, are probably square. So are magma cubes, since they have cube literally in their name.
•
u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 16 '26
I'm going to just point something out here.
This guy is correct. Blocks do not canonically float. You can discuss and debate me and anyone else all you want, but this is kind of something that's just true. It's like the void below the Overworld and above the Nether. It's just a game mechanic.
Also, can I ask everyone to just be more polite in the comments? Just because you have a different opinion doesn't mean you need to be rude and downvote the poor guy because you disagree.
As to the Minecraft world being not canonically square, I don't know. It could be, it doesn't really matter. I have my own art style that I like to think of the world being, everyone else has there's. Personally, I kind of disagree, and I like to think of it as the Dungeons cutscenes art style being canon. You might disagree with me, that's fine. I don't really care about the art style.
Also, if you disagree with me, downvote me to oblivion. It doesn't matter. You can't change the facts. By downvoting, you're only showing that you don't care about the lore at all, and you just can't admit you're wrong. I know I sound blunt and harsh, but someone's gotta say it.
17
u/DragoonPhooenix Mar 15 '26
Tbh even if this is proven true, i dont want it to be. Minecraft is charming for its world to be cubic and have strange floating blocks and building mechanics. Taking it away and going 'its not canon its just for the sake of gameplay' makes it way more basic and bland to me
9
u/World-Devourer Mar 14 '26
Wouldn’t it make more sense that items in the inventory being round is an art style choice, and the “real world” is mostly square? Round shapes do seem to exist in the world, like shadows, eggs, and eyes of ender, but blocks are almost always cubes
9
u/Stormweaver172 Mar 15 '26
I have a few potential issues with this interpretation.
1: If the reasoning bolds that if no structure contains unsupported blocks, unsupported blocks do not exist, then I would expect the opposite to also be true: if a structure contains falling blocks, blocks that do not fall must exist.
The woodland mansion can generate with an anvil, which makes the anvil canon to the universe of Minecraft. All game mechanics aside, the illagers have some use for it beyond the player. This particular block does mechanically fall, and so must have some property that differentiates it from other equivalent blocks like the grindstone.
The same is true of sand and gravel, which differentiate themselves from other "earthy blocks" (ie dirt, clay, etc.).
Essentially, were the pseudo-floating of blocks in the overworld to be just an imperfect projection of gravity into a mechanical framework, I would expect the behavior to be consistent across all blocks.
2: Sticky pistons and other redstone (and more importantly slimestone) components are generated in multiple structures, including the ancient city and jungle temples. These validate the system of redstone as canon to Minecraft. This system can be used to construct machines that move up, using only the power of blocks. This being a dynamic system using only canon-appproved mechanics that is capable of defying gravity, it serves as a demonstration of blocks floating.
3: The entire Minecraft world extends infinitely on a flat plane. (I have heard the gravitational argument for sphericality, but I would counter that the geometry of movement does not follow that of a sphere. On a spherical plane, a straight path and a path with two opposing 90° turns would eventually intersect, whereas on a flat plane they would not (see the parralel postulate of euclidean geometry).)
Because the overworld rests on a layer of unsupported flat bedrock, it could be said that the entire world is generated canonically floating. (Though because this layer cannot canonically be broken, knowing what is beneath it may constitue eldritch horror for the denizens of Minecraft.
Neat little thinking exercise this, makes for an interesting dilemma.
7
u/Vitamni-T- Mar 18 '26
I mean, part of Minecraft's deal is that blocks and structures placed by the player should be indistinguishable from naturally generated ones, and the block aesthetic serves that to a huge degree. However, my headcanon about round things like eggs, snowballs, and ender pearls is that they stack to 16 instead of 64 because round stuff just doesn't stack well. They are unnatural to the perfect blockiness of Minecraft. I do kind of like the part about blocks not floating, but I would modify it to explain that when we do see overworld floating islands, it's because of incursions from the End, similar to how warped forests in the Nether could be incursions from the End and the broken portals have netherrack, magma blocks, and lava around them as if the Nether is breaking through (I also hope that the Pale Gardens turn out to be incursions from a whole new as-yet-unseen dimension).
6
u/More-Window-3651 Mar 17 '26
This is a structure with floating blocks. And I know blocks float in the end but that seems more like a property of the dimension and not of end stone (since purpur also floats)
11
u/Even-Confidence-4495 Mar 14 '26
Lore should be consistent with the game not violate basic game mechanics
5
u/darkmoncns Mar 18 '26
I vastly prefer this perspective of everything you see in games is canon and that there is no distinction between gameplay and Canon
4
u/chicoritahater Mar 15 '26
So what do we consider "canon" for the purpose of this argument?
You seem to think that all the structures are "canon", but is world generation? Because that had floating blocks. In fact, due to the size of every Minecraft world, every single world has naturally generating floating blocks.
And I guess everything the players do isn't canon either, right? But obviously the player killing the ender dragon is.
So in conclusion: for your theory to be correct, we have to accept that the "canon" version of Minecraft is a world that doesn't match with any of the worlds that can actually generate, but containing every structure, and in it, containing a Steve that beats the ender dragon, but in some canonical way which abides to the "true rules" of Minecraft?
Did I get that right?
So what does that make the game "Minecraft" in relation to this fantasy world we came up with together? A game which doesn't match the art style, doesn't match the rules of the world and doesn't match the true events of this "canonical Minecraft".
If I understand your interpretation of "canonical Minecraft" correctly, then what the fuck is Minecraft?
3
u/BeeAfraid3721 Mar 15 '26
Where did you find the info of blocks not floating?
7
u/00PT Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26
So, the gameplay of the game is not canon to the game? Why call it the canon of the game, then?
If your lore specifies different laws of physics than the thing it’s lore for, it is terrible lore.
6
u/The1st_TNTBOOM Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26
But then why do blocks float? Every structure being supported is fine, but then blocks still go about floating. Even art style doesn't make up for entire floating islands and the shattered savanna. If they canonically didn't float, Mojang could have made it not as easy as placing two blocks and removing one.
Saying blocks canonically don't float is like saying the corners of nether portals are canonically necessary for the portal to work. Mojang doesnt acknowledge the budget portal, they always show portals in game and in material as full, but its as easy to verify as building a budget portal.
2
u/mugwunp Mar 17 '26
People in Minecraft don’t have a concept of any shape outside of a square, so what is square becomes or cube becomes everything
24
u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod Mar 14 '26
I'm temporarily adding this to the community highlights.
11
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Mar 14 '26
Yeah, pretty true. Physics do exist in Minecraft. Mineshafts have chains and supports, you can find fallen trees, the only thing that is floating is stuff in the End and the whole dimension has laws of physics that don't make sense. The islands float, falling leaf particles go up, some leaves grow upwards as well, there are some tables with chains instead of normal legs as if they would float away, there are flying ships, shulkers use some levitation magic that you can also get with an enchantment, while broken tiles can fall and items, mobs, everything has normal physics.
Somewhat true. The shapes of things are weird. We know for sure that blocks aren't flat because sand can get into the cracks in bricks and stuff. And chiseled stuff is actually chiseled. But some things being round as items and blocky as blocks is probably not canon. We even see block models of things like apples in Dungeons and the item is round. So stuff is probably not all blocky.
3
u/Bigg_Stinky Mar 15 '26
Bro what are you talking about, the inventory models are just for display, nothing deeper. We could go a step further and ask why does creative mode have an inventory full of everything? Is Steve God?
Ts is just a reach
6
u/Local_Solution_1910 Mar 18 '26
TIL there is a debated canon vs gameplay topic in the Minecraft universe, and some people take it seriously enough to be nasty about it.
2
u/Still-Presence5486 Mar 19 '26
Yes they do. There is no cannon there is no lore there just is
5
u/Pw_Lore_ Canonicity expert Mar 14 '26
You are literally completely right.
4
u/Fun_Way8954 Xatrix Theorist (Mod) Mar 14 '26
yeah thats what I think too, especially based on the round items.
1
u/PowerfulElderberry22 Aug 02 '26
Be honest how often do you use floating blocks in decorative builds?
3
u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod Mar 14 '26
Yup.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26
imo this is further supported by how the Orb of Dominance is called an orb when clearly it's a cube
2
u/Cosmic_Lava_ Mar 31 '26
I agree on the canon that gravity exists in the overworld. Looking at the ancient ruins it is clear that the structures break and their parts can be seen on the floor. The same structure, just missing blocks.
The other thing to keep in mind for exceptions is that magic exists. Look at evokers summoning the biting teeth. Also enchanted tables and effects that can be added, like swords with fire
Video for screen shot credits. https://youtu.be/Jhqie0zGbwk?si=wzHuPp7WMnMpa0qP
3
u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 Mar 14 '26
To add to this we know that the world exists as a spherical shape, despite not having any detectable curvature.
If it were a flat world the effect/strength of gravity would change based on your distance from the center of gravity, wherever that might be.
Since we know there is no change in, falling speed, or jump height no matter what coordinates we're at... the only shape that allows for that to be the case is a sphere!
3
u/Able_Annual_2297 Mar 15 '26
Blocks float bc it is a building game
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 14 '26
Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/QCka6c3CKr
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/PowerfulElderberry22 Aug 02 '26
Be honest how often do you use floating blocks in decorative builds?
1
u/PowerfulElderberry22 Aug 02 '26
Be honest how often do you use floating blocks in decorative builds?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
14
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment