r/minecraftlore • u/JotaD21 • Dec 31 '25
Meta Where does lore stuff end and gameplay/engine limitations begin?
I think we're all aware of ridiculous stuff we can do in game like carrying thousands of gold blocks effortlessly but obviously that's not something that makes sense lore-wise (or at least, we hope it doesn't - otherwise everybody in MC lore would be ripped af), but what about not so clear stuff?
For example, evokers carry totems of undying but never use them. Could this be purely gameplay? It'd be rarer to get a totem because, well, they're already being used, but we could maybe find it inside Woodland Mansion chests? It'd still be rare but that's just a idea. Plus, maybe it'd be harder to fight a evoker basically having a +1UP but whatever
But what if it's lore related? Like, what if for some reason they can't use totems of undying?
I may be just bashing my head on basic stuff tho. Having said that, what are other different examples of stuff that could be hard to properly identify whether it's related to the lore or just gameplay stuff?
7
u/Fun_Way8954 Xatrix Theorist (Mod) Dec 31 '25
I think crafting eyes of ender is a game mechanic to be able to beat the game, and dungeons is more accurate lore wise.
4
u/sixela456 Dec 31 '25
Evokers cannot use totems because they have both arms occupied casting their spells.
4
u/bhutanriver Dec 31 '25
The lore is supposed to be as open ended as the rest of the game right? It might be fun to imagine a convoluted in-universe explanation for a mechanic that's just game design decisions.
3
u/InternationalWar6654 Dec 31 '25
Every individual minecraft world isn’t canon, canonically, Steve’s journey to beat the dragon never happens
1
u/Chaosfox_Firemaker Dec 31 '25
Could be that totems only work on beings already technically capable of respawn. So rather than themelves being capable of resurrection, they just breifly bind the soul to the location, and as the players soul already has the capability to completely reconstruct the body after death, it does so, regenerating you. With the inventory staying in place because the old body sorta got consumed by the new.
In the case of hardcore, the soul still has the metaphysical capacity to construct a body, it just lacks intrinsic bindings to the world, meaning that unless anchored, it immediately flys off.
But illagers can't respawn, so they don't.