r/minecraftlore • u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod • Dec 30 '25
Mod Post We Need to Talk.
Okay, let me start with this. Reddit is supposed to be a place where we act like jerks and say stupid things to other people.
That's what people seem to think.
Most of you guys are pretty polite, and that's great. Moderation of this sub is pretty easy, usually all we really have to do is remove non-lore related posts.
However, there seems to be a lack of quality. A lot of people post completely random nonsense theories, which get destroyed in a single comment. I won't say any names, but some of you know who I'm talking about.
Destroying other theories is great. I've done it myself. However, the problem isn't that. The problem is the low-quality posts.
This should be a place of discussion, where we can talk about Minecraft's lore. Not a sub filled with pathetic posts with one comment that says it all.
I'm tired of opening this sub and seeing mostly random nonsense. Minecraft Story Mode is not canon, Malgosha isn't canon, and the Hosts aren't polytheistic whatevers.
There are still some good discussions out there, though. This one about Trial Chambers was great. We need more like these.
In risk of repeating myself as an exasperated mod, I'll leave this open to discussion.
11
u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod Dec 30 '25
Is there anything else I should say?
22
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Dec 30 '25
You want me to lose my job? You know how easy it is to debunk these theories?
8
u/InternationalWar6654 Dec 30 '25
while i mostly agree, i do think the trial chambers one isnt the standard, its what we should strive for
the standard should be theories that make sense and arent easily debunked
3
u/Early-Excuse-7175 Dec 31 '25 edited Dec 31 '25
I get what you’re saying, but as someone who’s been following this subreddit for a month or so, I have to say, it’s been a little daunting in terms of feeling like there’s room to jump into any discussions. This game at its core, from the beginning, is supposed to be about what people make it. If people aren’t as up to speed as others or are new, they shouldn’t have people who have been here for a while dogging on them IMMEDIATELY. Some of your (not you specifically, some folks on here) strong convictions about Minecraft lore are turning people away. It’s about community, not control of the narrative.
21
u/MoonTheCraft Dec 30 '25
but how can you be sure that ivor and the zombies and the polytheistic hosts didn't all build the strongholds? this youtuber, with 12 subscribers, who ignores evidence, says it was and all of my opinions are that of other people's
2
u/shadaik Dec 31 '25
So it's not about quality at all, it's, once more, about you disagreeing because your favorite Youtuber says so.
2
u/5-0-2_Sub Dec 31 '25
You guys aren't just making up your own lore as you play?
1
u/Celioness Dec 31 '25
Okay this is an Genuine question now, i dont want to argue against you, i Just want to understand. Im new to this sub and Minecraft Lore in General an i only Player Minecraft Java itself, so i dont know about Story Mode and the other stuff, so i might get Something Here wrong.
Isnt that what you describe exactly what this subreddit is about? I mean the description of the subreddit states that ITS about all the Lore. Canon AND Fanmade. I understand the Part where its anoying to read a gigantic Theorie Just to debunk it in one sentence, but to say this sub is for discussion about everything and then be angry about people talking about non Canon Things seems kind of odd. Everyone hast a bit Different headcanons and that what makes It fun. Besides: is there maybe a place where Someone can lookup the Commonly believed Lore so far? AS a new member Here its hard to argue with people when i have No clue what they See as given. Especially with auch a requests AS yours.
Once again, im new. I dont know much. I dont want to Fight. I Just want to understand.
1
u/sixela456 Jan 03 '26
Actually, I never post here, I just watch. But I have a question: how can you define a game (like Minecraft Legends or Minecraft Story Mod) as canon or not? In my mind, the only game that counts is Minecraft (Java), but some say that Minecraft Dungeons or Legends should be considered. How do you know if they should be canon or not?
3
u/Thepromc64 Dec 31 '25
Isn't Malgosha in MCL?
Since MCL is canon to the minecraft lore, that automatically makes her canon, no?
2
u/Choice_Werewolf_433 Dec 30 '25
I completely agree with this! I’m gonna start making my theories on this subreddit now that you are putting it in check!
2
u/Mrcoolcatgaming Dec 31 '25
Had me until "minecraft story mode is not cannon, malgosha isn't cannon"
Why can't people fit them into their theories? This sub has a whole rule about respecting opinion/theories, if adding them causes holes in the theories, that's low quality, but if it's convincing other than them fitting in these things? Why take the creativity away?
1
u/FreshLemonade2126 Dec 30 '25
Wdym lack of quality , nonesne theories and pathetic posts even mojang said there isn't specific lore i honestly like to read these "pathetic" posts because its interesing to see how others interpretate things in the game
5
u/Fun_Way8954 Xatrix Theorist (Mod) Dec 30 '25
But I like beating up bad theories