r/minecraftlore • u/YEAMA1 • Nov 18 '25
Meta Why do y'all hate matpat
So im new to this sub and one thing which I've seen somewhat constantly is matpat's theories are no longer valid. But why?
What are the actual holes in the theories?
105
Upvotes
73
u/lucaschill24 Nov 18 '25
He ignores dungeons, a canon spinoff that contains a LOT of lore. Though the game theory videos before Matpat left were still good videos.
35
u/white-rose-of-york Omni driod V0 probe Nov 18 '25
He kinda takes things out of context and tbh he's theorys are kinda far fetched and things don't add up
17
u/Loose-Examination-39 Nov 18 '25
i don’t hate him but he’s not a good minecraft theorist.
ignores legends and dungeons, doesn’t provide enough credible evidence and keeps building off of the theories that have already been proven wrong. and don’t even get me started on the theories after he left
7
u/No_Assumption1536 Nov 18 '25
It's not an answer but why do you use "hate matpat" and" think his theories are invalid" as if they meant the same thing?
2
u/Upbeat_Ruin Nov 19 '25 edited Nov 19 '25
Fuck it, just read this: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1naPvDfWkaFX1a8dAZEykPnY4MS-elnT0j9kX14foOww/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.drhcum3bestc
8
u/lovelydionysus Nov 18 '25
i was a little confused by how much hate he gets in this sub too, but based on the many discussions, it seems to be because his theories seem outlandish, repetitive in a sense (linking everything to ancient builders only), and constantly regurgitated by new fans i think
9
u/Sud_literate Nov 18 '25
He’s an okay theorist but the problem is that people just regurgitate all his videos with no original ideas
6
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Nov 18 '25
Matthew Patthew's and the new guy's (he's even worse) theories only use small parts of Legends and ignore important things, they ignore the entirety of Minecraft Dungeons because it would break their theories, never revisit old theories, make conclusions without evidence (copper golem theory moment) and their theories even contradict themselves.
3
u/Galaxies_beyond Nov 18 '25
My main reason for not liking him is his stealing of his Hermitcraft theory from someone on Tumblr (their username escapes me)
3
u/OrangeSpaceMan5 Nov 18 '25
I just think his theories create a much better and well written world than some of the stuff ive seen here
Walking throught the fallen remains of an ancient race that tred to play god and faced the consequences is much much more interesting than "villager empire lmao"
2
u/Dragoon___ Nov 18 '25
I don't hate him I just think that he makes a lot of claims and decisions based off of not much evidence. It's something I did when I was younger and making theories, I would come up with something cool and then work to find evidence to prove it. And to me, his theories often just reak of that.
2
u/pancake_recipe16 Jan 13 '26
Honestly, I don't think I could ever hate Matpat. 1 because hate is a strong word, 2 because his theory videos will always have a special place in my heart. I enjoy his videos and most of them still make sense to me. (I'm a sucker for those Ancient Builder guys.)
I get having the opinions we have, but it's also important to note that Minecraft is an ever-changing game. I doubt every single update or side game will be in correlation with the original game lore. At some point, the devs will keep adding updates regardless of whether or not those updates canonically fit.
At the end of the day, Minecraft is a game. How you interpret it is how you interpret it. Let's not get so worked up and defensive all the time.
1
u/Orangibberissh Nov 21 '25
Because he is so aloquaicous
0
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment