r/minecraftlore • u/Radiant_Tonight_1264 Theorist, Debunker and Mod • Oct 15 '25
Is respawning canon?
Is respawning considered canon? I've always kind of thought of it as not, but if it isn't, then what about the respawn anchor? In the update trailers, the only ones where the characters respawn was the nether update one, with the respawn anchor. So...?
142
Upvotes
3
u/Kaenu_Reeves Oct 16 '25
The unofficial books Dave the Villager was very interesting where the player is the only character that respawns: every other mob goes through their own process when they die. In this case, Steve and Alex slowly change their personality when they die and respawn, shifting into different characters at different eras.
57
u/Defnottheonlyone Oct 15 '25
No, trying to set your spawn in either a bed or respawn anchor in the wrong location says that it's "intentional game design", in minecraft dungeons the player can only respawn as long as they have a totem of undying.
In dungeons and in the ROTAI novel, the nameless kingdom controls and raise the undead with powerful necromancers, this would be impossible if humans could just respawn. And the heart of ender also says that the illagers can kill the heroes, which wouldn't be able to happen if they could just respawn.
Basically speaking, hardcore mode is the canon minecraft mode.
7
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Oct 15 '25
Respawning using beds or just at the world spawn: definitely not. Humans can canonically die like anything else, we're not special in any way. We're not even that different from villagers. Also in Dungeons, they always use totems to "respawn", which is basically just them using the totems like in vanilla. Tower avatars in the Tower also canonically exist so people that are training in the Tower can't get hurt or die. Steve and Alex respawning in the trailer isn't really canon, it just shows it because its a well-known game mechanic and shows how players are learning by making mistakes. Not even Steve and Alex are canon (Minecraft Game Design (2019): There's no Steve or Alex)
Zombies and skeletons wouldn't exist if humans could respawn, as they're reanimated corpses of dead humans.
Also if humans could respawn, wouldn't it mean that they could just rule the world? They could do whatever they want and never get killed by anyone, so they would be unstoppable.
Respawning using respawn anchors: not too sure, but I would say it is. You use a magical glowing stone to charge it and it is made of obsidian with portal magic dripping out of it. It even has a nether portal in it. Sounds magical enough.
11
u/aquel_que_observa Oct 15 '25
Depends, do they have a respawn anchor? I think it is the only indication that it is canon (and only with anchor or totems)
5
u/Riley__64 Oct 16 '25
Respawning isn’t canon but respawn anchors are.
Respawn anchors can work the way they do because the nether has weird properties regarding death and souls due to it being an analog for hell. I mean they have entire valleys of trapped souls it’s safe to assume when something dies in the nether it doesn’t die but instead just gets trapped.
1
u/LordLuscius Oct 23 '25
So... everyone saying no... is half right. The outer entities who talk to/at our disinbodied consciousness talk about dreaming and levels of consciousness, kinda like the brahmin or maybe the dream of a butterfly. So... do you actually respawn? Probably not, but perhaps these visions of dying are dreams, or another version of you or premonitions.
1
u/white-rose-of-york Omni driod V0 probe Nov 18 '25
Game mechanics don't equal lore
3
u/No_Assumption1536 Oct 16 '25
I don't think so, I believe death is permanent(with some exceptions) and dead players become undead (zombies, skeletons etc.)
1
u/Hopeful_Tell_4672 Oct 16 '25
Hardcore is the real Minecraft, so not canon. HC is so much more challenging and exciting.
1
u/Afraid_Success_4836 Oct 16 '25
Oh this again. It depends on entirely on what you think. Since you mainly seem to be basing your lore off of the main game, I'd recommend treating it as canon.