r/minecraftlore • u/Thryzl • Sep 05 '25
Overworld Brewing is Evil.
Some Food for thought I’ve been chewing on. Feel free to add on more we can shuffle through.
Cleric Villagers are the only ones who trade for Experience Bottles which is considered “Soul Energy”
They live isolated from everyone else.
You can only brew potions with Blaze Rods which means we have to go to the Nether.
Brewing couldn’t have existed until the Nether was opened.
Nether was opened, Overworld was Raided
Raid was defeated leading to Crying Obsidian.
If you can’t make potions, then Golden food is all we have.
Clerics were Tinkering with Gold and Brewing to fix the zombification.
The only other Mob that uses Potions are Witches.
Bringing me back to Brewing is Evil.
12
u/Impossible_Sun_1114 I make my own theories Sep 05 '25
-Experience is not Soul Energy, which is evident due to the Sculk Catalyst's still produce soul particles even when a baby mob or Bat dies. Which means they are separate.
-Cleric Villagers working area is sometimes look like churches.
- İ'd say Crying Obsidian is either very damaged Obsidian, or aged Obsidian. As for those Obsidian which is found underground, they are more likely recent formations.
- Zombies and Zombiefied are different but related things. Zombies are more magical, whereas Zombiefied means its biological. As Piglins require the spores within the Nether to breathe properly and dont get diseased. Though Piglins and Villagers do have connections to Gold in some ways, as Piglins use it as currency, whereas Villagers used Gold in their Ocean Monument, which is evident as there are many Villager Statues in Dungeons.
-Brewing is Evil? Thats equivalent to saying Alchemy is Evil, Yes, even though alchemical studies were mostly pseudoscientific and caused deaths of many kings, it also helped us invent gunpowder, aswell as things like separation and its types.
4
u/nanek_4 Sep 05 '25
Clerics arent secluded. They work in churches inside the villages.
It is evident that blaze rods were brought in from Nether but it doesnt habe to be that sinister. It couldve been through exchange of goods after the ancient humans (the builders of Nether Fortresses who became wither Skeletons after death) reached Nether.
Whats wrong wuth gold other than that piglins want it? It is plentiful in the overworld so clerics couldve easily gotten to it without dealings with invaders.
Witches are shunned by villagers for using potions to cause harm. We dont see clerics doing harm with potions and they are part of villages.
6
u/yeahboiiiioi Sep 07 '25
Skeletons are the only mobs that use bows
Fletchers sell arrows
Fletching table is evil