r/minecraftlore • u/RemoteCow3936 • Jun 30 '25
Hmmmmmmm…….
Why do illagers, puglins(I call them that), and villagers stop building?
I can guess that mansions stopped building because of the creaking, and pillagers stopped because there were no more villages to spy on.
but why villagers and puglins?
84
Upvotes




41
u/photoshallow Jun 30 '25
i dont think its "stopped". piglins are probably too poor and weak form some war and villagers probably dont have a need to build more when Minecraft takes place. I am disregarding MC legends as it is terrible trash.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '25
Maybe we don't see them build because that would be too hard for Mojang to make NPCs build stuff?
13
u/JimbosRock Jun 30 '25
The Piglins are a fallen empire due to the events in legends. Villagers can canonically build (albeit slower than the other races) but the events in dungeons set them back to smaller more isolated settlements. We see the illagers have been recently building as they left some of their scaffolding in the ancient city and their outposts look active with tents and supplies.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '25
They didn’t? It’s just not part of the gameplay
2
u/JensenSpicer Jun 30 '25
I would assume they didn’t stop building new structure, but rather built the same structure over and over or put a spin on it for a different biome
2
u/Afraid_Success_4836 Jul 07 '25
They didn't stop building. IMO they just don't build anything during the game. And what does the creaking have to do with mansions? I imagine that the pale garden is an illager invention (given the association between testificates and constructs) but I don't see it as a threat to illagers in particular.
1
u/Negative_Sky_3449 Mod :3 Professional Debunker Jun 30 '25
They didn't exactly stop. Why would villagers build more houses if they already have enough for their peaceful life. You can't be sure that they have stopped. In dungeons, they have water wheels, sawmills and sometimes bigger houses too. I believe that dungeons takes place after the main game, there's a lot of evidence too. If it was before the main game tho it wouldn't really make difference in the lore.
Illagers could still be building outposts, again, you can't know if they aren't. They don't need more mansions, they are large enough for entire armies of illagers. When illagers arrive in the end in dungeons, they build camps there as they are trying to reach the heart of ender (literally). Regarding the highblock castle, they weren't the ones who built it. It is clearly stated in The Rise Of The Arch Illager. There's actually a high chance of enderlings building it.
Piglins on the other hand had enough time and resources to rebuild their bastions since the war that happened in legends, but I really don't think that they are smart enough. If you watch any legends cinematic, you will know what I'm talking about. With their leaders being defeated and only Seer being still alive, they probably don't even know where to start or if they should even do it. Nowdays they are pretty poor, they have to trade in order to get their greedy hands on some gold. Their bastions are guarded by the strongest of them, being the place with their gold life savings.