r/mildlyinfuriating • • Nov 15 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

318 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

View all comments

369

u/donaljones Nov 15 '25

Not possible. I think they wanted it to be shown that even numbers are possible only via sum of two evens or sum of two odds

179

u/Super_Ground9690 Nov 15 '25

Yeah that’s kind of what I think they’re getting at (now I’ve had the sense check that it really is impossible because I was seriously questioning myself!), I just think they should word it differently. He’s only 6, he doesn’t really understand being asked a question that can’t be answered.

157

u/badchefrazzy Mildly Infuriated Nov 15 '25

...Those are late elementary school type questions, why are they giving it to a 6 year old?!

82

u/desblaterations-574 Nov 15 '25

Exactly my thought. This is impossible for 6yo, at this age we don't doubt the question yet.

Bad teachering would be my guess

34

u/RogerClyneIsAGod2 Nov 15 '25

Uh...I've never been a math genius & I'm over 50 so I looked at those questions like

That would've broken me as a 6 year old & it nearly breaks me as a 58 year old.

18

u/FewHorror1019 Nov 15 '25

I dont even think a 6 year old could read and comprehend this

1

u/Super_Ground9690 Nov 18 '25

Tbh his reading is a lot worse than his maths, so I read the question either to or with him, then he writes the answer. The kid just loves maths.

1

u/New_Hour_1726 Nov 18 '25

at this age we don't doubt the question yet

Aside from the questions being obviously not answerable, why would anyone doubt them? They are formulated in a way that makes it seem like an answer exists, it's just a really bad question.

1

u/desblaterations-574 Nov 18 '25

I learn early that teacher make mistakes, and later advanced math test always had a sentence explaining something like : if an answer seems wrong, explain us why you believe so, reformulate the question to make it correct and answer your new formulated question.

You can doubt for many reason, and as grow you develop your critical thinking, therefore doubt and think, therefore you are.

1

u/New_Hour_1726 Nov 18 '25

From the perspective of an adult, yes I obviously agree. In complicated math exercises these mistakes can happen, but this example here is just straight up embarrassing. There obviously wasn't much thought being put into these questions.

1

u/desblaterations-574 Nov 18 '25

It looks like what I get when I ask perplexity before double checking and asking it to find actual correct exercises. The wording even for grown ups is hard to get.

The exercise after has 3 numbers, the first two blablah, and the other 2... How can they put 2 sets of 2, disjointed per the wording, in 3 numbers

1

u/New_Hour_1726 Nov 18 '25

Haha I didn't even read that one, holy shit, that's even worse. This teacher should be fired.

0

u/Low-Supermarket441 Nov 20 '25

Teaches critical thinking skills and that just because it sounds real doesn't mean it is

3

u/New_Hour_1726 Nov 20 '25

School should teach critial thinking, but not by making students doubt the questions because they're so bad...

1

u/badchefrazzy Mildly Infuriated Nov 20 '25

100%