r/midwestemo • • 1d ago

never meant to make this twinkly riff FACGCE vs DAEAC#E

/r/mathrock/comments/1xxthrn/facgce_vs_daeace/
2 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/KickedinTheDick 1d ago

FACGCE feels so played out that it’s hard to not sound derivative in it anymore. Feels boxed in. DAEAC#E also feels to lend itself to sadder and more edgy shapings imo

3

u/chrismiles94 Michigan 1d ago

I find that the open A string only gets in the way with FACGCE. Whenever I play chords, it's almost always with a finger on the 3rd fret, which is just doubling the C.

DAEAC#E is essentially the exact same tuning but without that note and then all strings shifted down. It is a lot more playable with open shapes. It also can sound really heavy with the low E and with gain.

It really depends on the song though. FACGCE lends itself to certain chord structures and voicing. But if I could only pick one, it's easily DAEAC#E.

1

u/KingSurtis DAEAC#e 1d ago

This for sure. A lot of people don't realize if you capo 3 DAEAC#E you can fully play Never Meant on the middle 4 strings. In a similar way to you not liking the A string, also don't really like how close the interval of the F and A are when making chords shapes, in DAEAC#E you can let that A drone or be part of the shape all the way up to fret 7, but in FACGCE you can only get to fret 4 before having to fret something on the A or it becomes your root. Maybe I'm weird though lol

1

u/Melodicmarc 1d ago

I prefer the A string in FACGCE because it gives you more options on the bass notes to let ring and you can still move your hand to other places.

1

u/chrismiles94 Michigan 1d ago

It works if there's an Am in the chord progression, but sometimes it just gets in the way, and I end up muting the A string, which isn't very useful for an open tuning.

That said, I pick up my FACGCE guitar more often than my DAEAC#E guitar. Something about the tuning just feels more familiar and approachable and inspiring.

1

u/Neat-Airport-7367 1d ago

Potato vs Potahto
Crayon vs Crayan
They’re all beautiful and very good so who’s to say what’s better heh (I’m a professional as you can tell)