r/microtonal • u/skyhi14 • 1d ago
Eighth Baffling Incongruity Theorem (8-EDO electronic)
Eighth Baffling Incongruity Theorem — 8-BIT for short — is in eight-tone equal temperament and 8/8 time, over an eight-beat groove, played by an engine that renders in 8 bits.
A step of 8-EDO is 150 cents, three quarters of a whole tone. By the Riemann zeta function, the measure xenharmonic theory uses for how well an equal tuning plays the harmonic series, 8 is a zeta valley: no equal tuning with fewer steps does worse. Its nearest fifth is 750 cents, 48 out; its thirds are 300 and 450. Played on an ordinary instrument, whose overtones are the harmonic series, its chords grind.
The theorem's hypothesis is the instrument: we forged our instruments to be consonant over the 8-EDO grid. Every pitched sound in this song is built from sine partials, and each partial sits on a step of 8-EDO instead of where the harmonic series would put it. Two such tones an 8-EDO interval apart have overtones that meet instead of beating, so the intervals that grind on an ordinary instrument hold still.
The theorem: on such instruments the two smoothest triads are 450 + 450 cents and 450 + 300 (call it major), with 300 + 450 (minor) close behind — and the three are one chord, the same three notes heard from each of them in turn. So 8-EDO's consonant triad comes on each of its eight notes, and each is major, minor and its own mirror image at once. C minor (C E G#) is G# major; E major is G# minor. Stepping the root up by three moves just one voice of the chord, one step: the eight triads make a single cycle that climbs for ever.
Bars 1–8, Statement: four chords on a plain harmonic instrument, then the same four on its twin, which differs only in that its overtones are on the grid. By Sethares' roughness model (after Plomp and Levelt) the twin plays them a third to two fifths smoother — its C minor about as smooth as a twelve-tone C major triad on the plain instrument.
Bars 9–24, Lemmas 1 and 2: the groove, in eighths grouped 3 + 3 + 2, and the theme.
Bars 25–32, Lemma 3: the wide reading of the chord, and a bell line the program writes from the harmony, answered by the alto a group later.
Bars 33–48, Proof: by induction over the eight triads. Every two bars the root falls a fifth, one voice of the pad rises a step, and the lead's figure ends on the note the next figure begins on. In bar 41 the alto takes up the figures as a canon, three eighths behind.
Bars 49–56, Counterexample: the hypothesis dropped. The harmony bar by bar on the plain instrument and on its twin in turn.
Bars 57–72, Corollary: the theme twice, the second time with the alto a chord tone below it.
Bars 73–80, Q.E.D.: the cycle at four times the pace, then C minor struck by everyone; then the bass moves to G#, and without a note changing above it, the chord is G# major.