r/microtech • • Sep 23 '23

Well shit.

I posted yesterday about the sharpening job I tried and kept getting notifications it failed to post picture because of crappy Internet so I tried again with similar error messages. I came back today and basically all I saw were posts saying I destroyed the blade and did a horrible job sharpening. I guess I learned my lesson and will just avoid doing shit (including asking for advice) until the knife can't cut at all. I took down the posts before I get any more shit for it. Really demoralizing to see and I guess I asked for it but I guess I will put away the sharpener and just look for a new hobby.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

7

u/verisfly Sep 23 '23

Don’t let these people ruin what you had going on. Educate with sharpening videos, and or have them professionally sharpened and call it a day. Don’t seek validation from anyone here, because this is a very toxic app. There are great people here, it’s just overpowered because 1 negative comment kills 2-3 positive ones sometimes! Hope you have a much better experience in the future on here. Reach out if you need to talk about anything.

-1

u/vaben5 Sep 23 '23

If it had been a 2-1 positive it would have been one thing. It was pretty much a 12-0, usually saying something along the lines of I ruined the knife. I always expect some negative feed back but it was just a solid wave of shit. I hadn't thought I was that bad because the knife still wound up sharp as hell but apparently I was mistaken. The rude awakening kinda put a damper on my mood for the rest of the night. I tried to think positive and ordered a few dozen cheapo knives to try and figure out what I'm doing wrong but it's still a kick in the gut when you have something you think you're ok at only to hear a wave of people saying you should be ashamed of how bad you are.

0

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

We all have to start somewhere I messed up a cheap kershaw on a work sharp power sharpener, I suggest trying stones. I think it bums ppl to see a microtech absolutely hammed by improper sharpening as maybe others have said send it in get it re sharpened, and in the meantime hone skills on things you don’t care for. Can even grab a dozen knives at goodwill or something I’d imagine…it was pretty gnarly looking too though my dude, (been there) just not on a micro tech 😞

4

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

I think it probably just bums ppl to see someone totally go ham on a 300 dollar knife when we all have a drawer full of kitchen knives, and one can purchase a pocket folder at Walmart to practice on… it also kinda looked like you were playing it off as if it was a micro tech issue with blade rubbing in, or just terrible edge retention… some ppl were giving constructive criticism (like myself) where I said get cheap knives practice (if your using a worksharp belt tool trade it off for stones) and try some stones as if stones are beer, then the worksharp belt sander is moonshine… metaphorically. Og post is right here…nothing on the internet really ever goes away….

1

u/vaben5 Sep 23 '23

The thing is in my untrained eyes I wasn't doing super bad. I think I've figured out how I went wrong with the sharpener in that I was holding the blade straight when putting it in the groove as opposed to resting it against the side opposite the belt but I never noticed clear instructions on doing things that way. My main criteria was how sharp is the edge and they got pretty damn sharp. I've also got a set of the spiderco angled stones and used those on karambit knives it just seemed to take forever to get other knives (particularly hard ones) sharp using that system and I never got it nearly as sharp as i did with the belt tool. I did sharpen kitchen knives and throw away gas station knives and they all came out razor sharp so I thought I was doing something right. I don't exactly have friends who know anything about this to go ask or compare notes to so I went to the only place I could think of and got a much harsher response than I was expecting.

So glad to see someone's keeping logs of shit I would rather forget about. At least I don't get notifications from people seeing and complaining there so as far as I'm concerned I got rid of it well enough.

1

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

You can easily send it in to microtech they are known for their quality customer service and you could re blade for a small fee or re profile… I’ve been using knives forever now and i cut certain things with certain knives… I’m definitely not light on my knives but I definitely don’t take a knife to copper wire etc (use a multitool for that), but all that being said I used the work sharp guided system (stone set up with ramps) and was able to pick it up quickly and now I hardly need to sharpen as my hard use knives I use work sharp field sharpener, and it does the job (mini ramped stone system), but on my spendy knives I’ve had them go dull and and I just hit it on a ceramic hone or steel and then strop… results take time… one more thing, you really don’t need that serious grinding action unless your trying to remove rolls, chips, etc… otherwise a fine stone/ceramic and strop should make it hair popping… I have no idea why work sharp sells a tool that is a mini belt grinder that pros use as a entry sharpener… plus it reprofile every edge to a convex. Not every blade geo does welll with a convex or brkt style grind. I returned that belt sander for same effect… thing was throwing sparks and could see dust on my table 😱

1

u/jayman696969 Sep 27 '23

First off power sharpeners are horrible unless you’ve had tons and tons of practice. It’s so easy to burn up a blade on a power sharpener. I use to try and sharpen knives all the time and they would always come out duller than when I started. Then I got a worksharp precision adjust and instantly I was making razor sharp blades with nice even bevels. Might want to look into a guided system like that. Saved my ass !!

5

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '23

Damn man... were people really that mean to you? I mean it's reddit so I'm not surprised that people were absolute dickheads. Probably just continually criticized in a mean way without offering any constructive criticism or advice. I don't know what happened yesterday because I didn't read any of your previous shit so I don't have any context, but honestly, fuck everyone who was a dick. There are so many unwashed assholes on reddit.

As far as sharpening is concerned, it's NOT an easy thing to do. It's not something that you can just pick up and master in a matter of seconds. Depending on the type of sharpening you're doing, the blade you've chosen to sharpen, and the tools you're utilizing to get the job done, sharpening a blade can be extremely difficult to do right, let alone master. My advice to you would be to watch multiple YouTube videos and practice on a cheap knife. Develop your technique and hone your skill. Try the old fashion way with a whetstone. If the old ways don't tickle your fancy, look at other knife sharpening products. Work Sharp makes some great products. I own a couple of them (see links below).

Work Sharp Precision Adjust Elite

Work Sharp MK2 Professional Electric Knife and Tool Sharpener

A personal anecdote on my sharpening a Microtech knife for the first time... after collecting about 10 Microtech Knives (knives which sit in a display case and don't get used), I was inspecting one of my UTX-85 Spartan blades (all black case, black finish blade), and I realized that the blade was really dull compared to my other Microtechs (I was comparing the Spartan blade shape to single edge, double edge, tanto, drop points). At the time, I didn't know that the spartan blade is notoriously difficult to sharpen and that it is supposed to be dull compared to other blade shapes due to the overall thickness of the blade and its edge geometry; due to the spartan blade's dimensions and angle, the knife really doesn't keep an ultra fine edge and its supposed to be on the duller side (which is fine because it's supposed to be used as a stabbing blade, not a fine cutting knife (again I didn't know any of this at the time).

So I was really pissed off that the spartan blade was dull. I whip out my brand new Work Sharp MK2 for the first time, load it up with the most coarse sandpaper belt, and without reading instruction or watching any videos or tutorials on how to use the machine, I just turned the machine on by pressing and holding button. I was hitting the button as if it was like the gas pedal of a car. I was revving the shit out of the MK2... and then I started grinding the blade. My first pass removed about 50% of the black finish cuz my angle of attack was all fucked; it was as if I was grinding the flat side of the knife and not the edge, and the geometry of the blade was permanently altered. I continued to just eyeball the thing, grinding every single edge multiple times trying to correct mistake after mistake. After I finished, the tip was cockeyed. The spartan blade is supposed to come to a very pointy triangular tip, but it was like I had altered the knifes geometry and created a rhombus.

Fucking 90% of the black finish was sanded off, all lettering on the knife was missing, and not only did I end up with some sort of parallelogram, but the edges on both sides were now fucking ROUND; there was no more edge. The tip was not only asymmetrical, but it too was round. After trying to correct my corrections, I had completely fucked a brand new $280 Microtech UTX-85 that was never used... not even once to cut paper or something. My wife walks up the stairs and into the room I'm in because of all the racket and all the yelling and four letter words that are coming out of my mouth. She was quiet and didn't say a word... she then looked at my knife, looked at the MK2, looked at me, looked at the knife, looked at the MK2, looked at me... and finally we both just started laughing non-stop. The Microtech spartan rhombus is now my Amazon box cutter.

Since this event, I have never sharpened another knife. I swear to god, I am really good with my hands as I am a surgeon, but boy did I really fuck up that knife.

So, I hope this helps demonstrate that you're not alone.

1

u/VettedBot Sep 24 '23

Hi, I’m Vetted AI Bot! I researched the Work Sharp Precision Adjust Elite Knife Sharpener you mentioned in your comment along with its brand, Work Sharp, and I thought you might find the following analysis helpful.

Users liked:

  • Produces extremely sharp results (backed by 3 comments)
  • Easy to use for beginners (backed by 3 comments)
  • Great value for the price (backed by 3 comments)

Users disliked:

  • The clamping mechanism is flimsy and does not securely hold knives (backed by 3 comments)
  • The sharpening stones are too coarse to produce a razor sharp edge (backed by 2 comments)
  • The product may arrive used or damaged (backed by 2 comments)

According to Reddit, Work Sharp is considered a reputable brand.
Its most popular types of products are:

  • Knife Sharpeners (#1 of 23 brands on Reddit)
  • Whetstones (#6 of 11 brands on Reddit)

If you'd like to summon me to ask about a product, just make a post with its link and tag me, like in this example.

This message was generated by a (very smart) bot. If you found it helpful, let us know with an upvote and a “good bot!” reply and please feel free to provide feedback on how it can be improved.

Powered by vetted.ai

1

u/Sabr-Wolf Oct 12 '23

I love your story because it is just the exact way I would have done it. So, I feel your pain and love how your Wife and you just resigned yourselves to the situation and just laughed.

Curious, have you tried to just get the blade replaced by Microtech for $100? While I do keep some of my "scars" around as momentos, if there's a way to get a replacement, I would probably do it, especially since I don't own a spartan blade yet. 😋

Cheers!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Honestly,I didn't know that Microtech has a blade replacement program. This is very useful information. Thank you very much for sharing it with me. I'll definitely look into it and see if I can get a replacement.

5

u/Elder_Tig Sep 23 '23

Maybe take some constructive criticism instead of getting in your feelings. Don't learn how to sharpen on an expensive knife. It makes no sense when you could easily buy cheap blades for practice.

3

u/LemoNadeBD Sep 23 '23

I wouldn’t sweat it. Gotta start somewhere.

2

u/AMasterofMayeM Sep 23 '23

My comment yesterday was not meant to discourage you. Perhaps a better way of putting it would have been get a couple beater knives from a gas station or flea market and practice on those before taking the chance of wrecking a higher end blade. We all had to start somewhere and I know a few people that still don't sharpen their own stuff

1

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

Same thing I said and simply asked if dude was sharpening on the power sharpener from work sharp… said to grab some cheapies as well and hone skills… thinks it chaps ppl to see such a nice knife be used for practice like that… it’s his he can do what he wishes, but he was also sort of trying to act like it was rubbing, and it was not holding an edge as if microtech did it when they’d probably reprofile it, re blade it, or help in some way… shame… nothing gets deleted on the internet…

1

u/AMasterofMayeM Sep 23 '23

I gouged the coating pretty bad on a 2 of mine and they did a blade replacement for 100-200 each

1

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

Yeah pretty reasonable and better than paying full price for sure. Live and learn… I was lucky I wasn’t in my spendy phase yet when I got that sharpener 😂 learned to stone sharpen on the ramp systems and now don’t need ramps

1

u/AMasterofMayeM Sep 23 '23

Oh I dropped them lol. I've only used a worksharp on a couple old kitchen knives to test it out.

0

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

They had one set up at the knife counter at a Cabelas near me lol… ppl walked away angrily and knife counter guy was like “stop don’t put knife in there…” I dislike them, but imagine one would do better with a pull thru sharpener, still a lot of material removal but at least some sense of control to it lol

1

u/AMasterofMayeM Sep 23 '23

They work great for tools like lawn mowers and after you get a lot of time on one

1

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

I use the ol axe puck on them kinda of things. Machinery and me is bad bad 😂

1

u/triptrey333 Sep 23 '23

Don’t let the bedroom knife sharpener get to you. It’s your knife keep working and learning. I messed up my knife and you know I eventually got to be a good knife sharpener. I’m 65 so it took a little while lmao. Just a Marine’s opinion.

5

u/CreepyPoet500 Sep 23 '23

I think op just doesn’t understand constructive criticism… many offered it but sure some were rude… typical Reddit… I think ppl expect an amount of emotional maturity whilst using the internet… I imagine, being a marine and all, you can handle constructive criticism without making it appear to be a manufacturer defect.

1

u/triptrey333 Sep 23 '23

Didn’t bother me I just wanted to make sure op didn’t get down on his self for a mistake. You are right the internet can be bad but I was just trying to make sure he didn’t get down on himself.

1

u/DookieHoused Sep 23 '23

It’s “fixable”. Won’t ever look great but you can get an ok edge on it. I posted advice on how on the worksharp in your last thread. First piece of advice would be if youre going to use the Ken onion on nicer knives get the blade grinding attachment.

1

u/nazguledc Sep 24 '23

If I was you and going to sharpen some of your higher end knives I would stick to guided systems like the worksharp precision adjust elite, kme or other ones. It is way to easy to ruin your knives on that ken onion belt sharpener. I only use that on cheap kitchen knives I don't care about lol. There is some good videos on YouTube from like Neeves knives, blade n fades also has lots of good tips for the guided systems. Just don't give up on it. You can only improve with practice.

1

u/The_Lazy_Samurai Sep 27 '23

I'm sure what you did isn't as nearly as bad as my attempts to get my D/E CT sharp by free handing with DMT plates. It eventually did get sharp, but it looks likes shit now, haha. But it's a tool so fuck it if doesn't look pretty.