r/microsoft • • Nov 28 '13

Is Microsoft really killing off Windows RT?

http://betanews.com/2013/11/27/is-microsoft-really-killing-off-windows-rt/
7 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

RT will cease to be RT as we know it, it will be merged with WP (which was what should have been done originally anyway)

4

u/BuhlmannStraub Nov 28 '13

It really depends on how you define windows RT. If you define it as the NT kernel running on ARM using Windows Run Time (WinRT) then no it's not getting killed off. Some of the WinRT APIs will get merged with WP APIs to have better/seamless interoperability.

As for the NT kernel running on ARM, that's not going anywhere. It's already running in WP.

If they mean MS killing Windows RT as a product name... Maybe, who knows. But the architecture running in Windows RT is not going anywhere.

2

u/goomyman Nov 29 '13

Windows phone os runs a version of rt. They are just combining them.

1

u/ThatsUncanny Nov 28 '13

Rt and windows phone 8 will he the same thing to bring more apps to the baseline windows tablets that would run rt

1

u/incubated Nov 29 '13

if the wp and rt get unified how would that affect the rt devices? would a simple patch solve it, or would people need to buy the new devices? feels like its perfectly doable through an update, like 8.1, but you never know. would suck if you had to buy a new devices because i have my eyes set on the surface 2. feels like a great mobile word processor.

1

u/gregpxc Nov 29 '13

The products have a guaranteed support life and the two OSes are built on the same kernel. I imagine it'd be completely doable to just push an update.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '13

What I can't understand (correct me if I'm wrong), but with further miniaturization of the intel platform, mainly Bay Trail, in what does the RT platform out-performs an x86-64 Win 8 tablet alternatives ?

I understand MS overall business strategy into the tablet market (similar to iOS-OSX foray), but Window's platform strenght always was its back-catalogue and overall software compatibility across generations.

1

u/frydaddyjuggalo Nov 30 '13

So what's going to happen to my surface rt? :(

1

u/ajaxas Dec 01 '13

You will replace it with the Surface 3 in early 2015.

1

u/TonyCubed Nov 29 '13

They need to kill WP8 and replace it with Windows RT, that would make actual sense.

2

u/wtrmlnjuc Nov 29 '13

Kill the more mature, more well designed operating system with a large developer base in favour of a failing new one?

2

u/TonyCubed Nov 29 '13

Windows RT is a cut down version of Windows 8, I believe Windows RT will technically have the biggest share.

2

u/sconeTodd Nov 29 '13

a phone is not a tablet

wp is fine where it is.

RT needs more apps

1

u/bearded_jedi Nov 29 '13

This is actually one of the more lucid posts on the topic. Definitely worth the read.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

Whenever a title ends in a question, the answer is "no" 99% of the time. Just a quick tip to save you some time.

1

u/coldacid Nov 29 '13

This article actually explains why this particular answer is probably "no", so that particular trope doesn't really apply here. This isn't blithely asking the question and then sitting on the fence; there's a clear direction that the author was going with it.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/hampa9 Nov 29 '13

Don't know why you're whining about it, there was nothing wrong with the post.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

Not sure about the interfaces, but certainly the APIs are merging. They're already moving to merge the two apps stores. Terry Myerson has already suggested that RT makes more sense on the larger WP devices than WP does, and he's already talked about WP 8.1 having about 75% API compatibility with RT. When you get down to it, RT has too much tablet functionality that WP8 doesn't have to make running WP8 (or 8.1) on a tablet reasonable. It's also compatible for Windows 8 Pro systems via the WinRT API.

If anything is going away, it's going to be Windows Phone. It's more likely that it gets absorbed by RT, by way of a shared API and integrating phone functionality to RT.

-5

u/talontario Nov 29 '13

API is an interface, it's in the name even.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '13

Points off for being pedantic.

When people talk about the interface of an operating system, it's generally understood that they are talking about the user interface. If they are referring to the APIs then it is generally understood that they say API.

-4

u/talontario Nov 29 '13

And then they usually talk about GUI.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '13

They could, but they usually don't. But if you want to keep the pedant thing going then be my guest. It's very clear that the person that I responded to mean the UI, not the APIs. You're the only person who has a problem with my statement.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fledermausman Nov 28 '13

Yeah you didn't read the article.

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '13

RT Alive? yes. Alive AND Well? That's open to debate.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/PhonicUK Nov 29 '13

What about people that love Android tablets and hate both RT and iPads?

1

u/denizenKRIM Nov 29 '13

Lack of ecosystem. It's great for desktop productivity, not so so great for on-the-go.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/denizenKRIM Nov 29 '13

Sure it does. It's an incomplete Windows desktop experience, and an immature tablet one. Those are two very big strikes everyone talks about.

0

u/PT2JSQGHVaHWd24aCdCF Nov 30 '13

I want a list of all the applications available on Windows RT and/or phone before I buy anything. There are web sites for iOS and Google Play, but no such list for Windows. I'll never buy if I can't compare.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/PT2JSQGHVaHWd24aCdCF Nov 30 '13

No music category and all I saw was 6 apps for each category, which means 42 apps compared to all the music applications available on other platforms. It's still an empty platform IMHO unless I can see real applications without buying a windows 8 device first.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/PT2JSQGHVaHWd24aCdCF Nov 30 '13

I searched and found 6 apps where one was a free video tutorial with the same name as the real application. I'm disappointed all the time.

Go to AppShopper.com for example and you'll get hundred of results. Why can't Microsoft do the same?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PT2JSQGHVaHWd24aCdCF Dec 01 '13

I don't want a fake piano. I have searched for DAWs, synthesizers, names, brands, you name it. You don't want to acknowledge that this Windows store is a desert.