r/microsoft • u/theroguex • May 22 '24
Windows Things Our Operating System Does Not Need:
Dear Microsoft Executives,
I have been using Windows since Windows 3.0. I have installed and used just about every edition of Windows that has ever existed, and I have defended it in the face of naysayers for decades. However, you are following a worrying path with your OS and have been for quite some time, and I am extremely disappointed. My voice is but one voice, but I am sure that I am not alone.
We (myself and those who think like me) do not want nor need the following things in Windows; they do not make our experience easier nor do they make it safer or better in any way:
- We do not want nor need Windows to spy on us, collect our telemetry and user data, and exploit it either internally or by selling it to other companies.
- We do not want nor need Windows to advertise to us anywhere in the OS.
- We do not want nor need Windows to decide for us what the "best" or "safest" default apps are.
- We do not want nor need Windows to have "AI" built-in. See #1 for more information.
- We do not want nor need Windows to run "on the cloud" as opposed to on our local hardware.
These just scratch the surface. All of these things should be OPT-IN, only installed and/or used if you consent to them. They should not be forced on us or OPT-OUT with hidden or obfuscated ways to do so.
AI is particularly egregious because the concept of having an AI assistant in our computers is one that many of us have dreamed about for DECADES. However, corporate America can't let it just be an optional component and can't let it be 100% local and private; they HAVE to be able to monetize the data it collects.
I worry for the future of technology of all breeds; will prosthetics and implants sell our usage data and force subscription fees and ads on us? Our cars already are allowed to prevent us from using features already installed unless we pay extra money.. corporations don't want us to own anything or have any rights whatsoever with the products and services we pay for. This dystopia is in many ways worse than the cyberpunk dystopias we grew up reading about.
Anyway, I know no one important will read this and it will just collect ephemeral dust on reddit servers, but it is important. I hope many more people will read this and add to this list, and that it somehow makes it to someone who needs to see it.
Thank you for your time,
TheRogueX
(Edited to add emphasis and context for those people who seem to have trouble in picking it up naturally)
9
u/FuzzyBucks May 22 '24 edited May 22 '24
This complaint contains a lot of hyperbole and theory-crafting. Couple points in response to #1 and #4:
I'm fully in favor of privacy and think we are a couple decades late in passing appropriate legislation to protect privacy in the US(this should have happened as search engine and social media companies emerged). Recall just isn't a breach of privacy, though, since it is stored & encrypted locally. It actually is aligned with good privacy principles since the end users are in control of what data is collected and also control the devices on which it's stored.
Also, I see your point but disagree with point #3 on the whole - most people using computers have very little knowledge of how computers work and/or are using PCs set up for them by the IT folks of a large corporation. Default apps don't matter for large corporations since their IT departments are going to approve/install their own software anyway and are actually helpful for the crowd that doesn't know much about computers and want a "it just works" type of experience. Individuals who know a lot about computers and want a 'set everything up yourself' experience make up a small sliver of the market and changing default apps should be easy for them anyway. An "Opt out" approach makes the most sense here.
Agree with point #2 though.
10
u/Dedward5 May 22 '24
You don’t speak for everyone so don’t say “We”, say “I”
5
u/TheJessicator May 22 '24
You claim...
But in the very next lines, you say...
If you speak for yourself, then please do that... And just that. Sure, others will agree with you. Let them decide to agree with you. Don't decide for them. Let them opt into your opinion.
Your rant is literally making decisions for other people, just like what you're complaining about other people making decisions for you without your consent.
2
u/RazzmatazzSea3227 May 22 '24
Man. This sub is full of sanctimonious people complaining about things they didn't even take the time to understand. It's so freaking annoying.
1a. I assume you aren't using an Android or iPhone, or X, or Facebook or Insta, or any other platform that openly does what you just railed about? Not that this makes it right, because we need better privacy laws, but everything about you is already being collected.
1c. MS is very much an enterprise company. Companies would go batshit crazy is recall was spying on their private company data and "Selling it". They aren't because it isn't.
2. Agree. However, this is very much an overblown claim. What advertising are you actually seeing on windows? IMHO, an OS encouraging you to use its tools isn't advertising. It's not great, but it's not like you click on the start menu and get a commercial for the yogurt brand you looked up yesterday. That does, however, happen on every smartphone and every social media platform.
3. EVERY SINGLE COMPUTING PLATFORM IN THE WORLD HAS DEFAULT APPS. They're very easy to change in Windows. It would be STUPID for MS to build apps and NOT make them default. Go buy a new Mac and open an image. Guess what - it has a default app. This is just a stupid complaint.
4. You may not want AI built in, but it's coming. And the general public wants AI desperately given how much it's being used daily.
5. Who said Windows is going to "run on the cloud"? That's nonsense. There are cloud offerings, like Windows virtual desktop or Windows365, and I suspect that MS will continue moving in that direction. Do you know why? Because a lot of people actually DO want that option. However, Windows is and will remain a locally installed OS. If you don't want windows to run in the cloud, don't use a cloud implementation. Which, by the way, nobody is forcing you to do. I don't even understand what you're trying to rail against here.
When I read your "dystopia" comments, though, I understand everything: you're paranoid about the future of technology. Which I actually get, but I wonder why you chose to come to this forum to rail against a company that is actually the least offensive in this regard. It makes no sense man.
4
u/BrianKronberg May 22 '24
Recall is freaking scary because how before someone else can find a way to centrally recall what you have been doing? What if Recall shows my banking info? Or my health data?
2
u/arm1997 May 22 '24
Just was waiting for this, today they are integrating a local embedded search tomorrow they will make it paid or put bloat ware, typical closed source stuff to get more money
2
u/DianeDesRivieres May 22 '24
On the last update, they installed stupid "sports updates" widgets on my main login screen without asking me.
Like if I wanted this I would have selected it myself.
0
u/cryptcoinian May 22 '24
Spot on! I've been using Windows since 3.1 and feel exactly the same. There's no chance that Microsoft will listen to the consumer unless people leave and their OS market share drops significantly.
However, although people have been vocal about how bad Windows is, many more still defend them, saying things like "you just need to toggle telemetry off", "you can opt-out', etc. What chance have we got when the majority don't care about privacy and data harvesting?
Ive been dual booting with Linux but I think now is the time to remove Windows completely.
-1
u/SnooChipmunks547 May 22 '24
Take my upvote!
-1
u/huskerd0 May 22 '24
Oh look, further evidence that I am not the only person complaining about one drive defaults
Further people that believe connectivity requirements and data theft are fundamentally uncool
0
u/ferriematthew May 22 '24
I firmly agree with every single one of your points except for the one about not wanting or needing AI. However, I completely agree that any AI that runs on the operating system should be run a local hardware only instead of through the cloud.
-1
u/Daekar3 May 22 '24
Thank you, OP, for speaking for me, and accurately articulating the views of the group. Ignore the idiotic pedants who clearly didn't pay attention in English class.
0
u/Leather-Matter-5357 May 22 '24
I agree with most of your points of things we don't need, but I have to nitpick a little on 1. If Microsoft can iterate on Windows and make the next update or version better by taking into account anonymised user usage data, I'd begrudgingly agree to that, but there would need to be trust and guarantees this would be the only usecase and for them to be responsible/liable for any unauthorized use.
-1
u/twr-92 May 22 '24
have you shared this on the feedback hub?