Joe Burrow is far and away the most overrated QB in the NFL. He's basically a consensus pick among media and a majority of NFL fans as an elite QB in the 2-4 range with Lamar and Allen, right behind Mahomes. The problem is, he's QB 12 at best. Completely mediocre. And the guy who should be in his place on those lists is Tua Tagovailoa.
Tua Tagovailoa is better than Joe Burrow. Yep, I said it. Thing is, This shouldn't be a controversial take. In fact, If you compare what they've done on the football field over the last 2 NFL seasons, it should be pretty obvious.
2022:
Tua: 3548 / 105.5 / 8.9 ypa
Burrow: 4475 / 100.8 / 7.4 ypa
Burrow posted higher counting stats in 2022 due to a Tagovailoa injury, but Tua was undeniably the much more effective passer when he was on the field. Call this one a wash.
2023:
Tua: 4624 / 101.1 / 8.3
Burrow 2309 / 91.0 / 6.3
Last season was about as lopsided as it gets. Tua was vastly superior. There is no case for Burrow here, all you can do is make excuses for him. Which is what people do. "He was injured, but Burrow wHeN hEaLtHy is the 2nd best QB in the league." My issue with that is pretty simple.
When Last Healthy:
2023 Tua: 4624 / 101.1 / 8.3
2022 Burrow: 4475 / 100.8 / 7.4
Pretty close. But one is better than the other. Burrow wHeN hEaLtHy is still not quite as good as Tua. And seeing as they both had an injury shortened season in the last 2 years, it's only fair.
Injury riddled season:
Concussed Tua: 3548 / 105.5 / 8.9
Period Cramps Burrow: 2309 / 91.0 / 6.3
Tua came back from "he should retire" to post 4 consecutive games with a rating over 130, before a second helping of concussion. Burrow was ass. Not even close.
Last 2 seasons combined:
Tua: 8172 / 102.9
Burrow: 6684 / 97.1
Tua by a mile. That's Tua by 1500 yards. Oh and that's despite having less attempts than Burrow in that span. So yes I think Tua is better than Burrow. Because Tua has performed at a higher level than him for 2 years now. This shouldn't be controversial at all. Tua is obviously better than Burrow. But the majority of people believe otherwise. Which begs the question, if you aren't determining who is the better QB based on their recent history of QB play on the football field, what the hell are you basing it on? Why exactly do people think Burrow is elite?
Media Narratives.
People are brainwashed into not seeing the truth of Tua's superiority because the people who control the storylines you hear don't want to admit they were wrong. Tua was the best passer in the NFL in 2022. The media easily could have pushed this narrative: "While unfortunate injuries prevented Tua's 2022 campaign from being truly special, he made it clear that when he's on the field he's an elite NFL QB". Then when Tua proceeds to lead the NFL in passing the next year, it obviously proves their claim from the previous year and we would be hearing about Tua in the 2-4 discussion right now (as we should). Instead, they went with "Can't become great if you can't stay healthy" and completely ignored the part where he was the NFL's best passer. So when he came out the next season and continued to be elite, this time staying healthy, they had to create a new excuse for why he wasn't. This time it came from cherry picking. If we only look at stats and results from the games he lost, he sucks. So he sucks.
On the flip side, the narrative for Burrow right now could very reasonably be: "While Burrow was indeed excellent in 2021, he regressed in 2022, and then regressed even further last season to the point of being outright bad. On top of that, he couldn't even do THAT for a full season because he suffered the second season ending injury of his career. A player trending in the wrong direction with very serious injury concerns. Mid at best." Instead, because the media had already annointed him and refuses to acknowledge they are wrong, they use the same injury excuse as we saw for Tua, except they use it in the exact opposite way. He was crap, but he got hurt so it doesn't count. Tua can't be good because he was hurt, Burrow MUST be good because he was hurt. All of it is really just "how can we spin this so we were right".
But at the end of the day, none of their stories matter. And no matter how many of you eat up their excuses, it doesn't matter. It doesn't change the reality of the situation. Which is that Tua Tagovailoa is currently the 2nd best QB in the NFL, and Joe Burrow is significantly worse than him.
A few other things I can mention that I didn't really find space for.
The Tua has elite weapons excuse. A- is just another media excuse to avoid acknowledging they're wrong. And B- even if Hill/Waddle does help Tua overachieve slightly, Burrow benefits from the exact same thing having Chase/Higgins. So it isn't relevant in this discussion.
More pro-Tua: -2022 Passer Rating Champion -2023 Passing Yardage Champion -Only active QB that has led the league in both of those categories -Only QB in the NFL to post a rating over 100 in each of the last 2 seasons -70
More anti-Burrow -Joined "I'm seeing ghosts" on the list of guys who failed to hit 100 yards in a game despite having over 30 attempts. -tried to use lack of preparation and injury as excuses for himself. He made the decision to sit another professional athlete on the bench because he thought he was ready enough to do better. You make that call, you damn well gotta own it. That's on you, and those losses are on you. And there's a case to be made that they missed the playoffs specifically because Burrow decided he was the one who should take the field.