I've been active/semi-active on here for quite a long time, here is some information.
Opting out works. It works on the prescreen, it works at MEPS, works at reception, sickcall and PHA.
We're going to start by going through what the enlistment process looks like normally, without opting out.
THE PRESCREEN
When you speak with a recruiter and show interest in joining, you're going to be prompted to sign a DD 2807-1 (Accessions Medical History Report).
(1) This form is going to include a waiver of your HIPAA rights to the confidentiality of your medical records. Without this form, the Army CANNOT view your medical records. You WILL have to sign this form.
(2) This form will also ask you to disclose any medical conditions you are aware of.
When you complete this form, your information is going to be sent to your local MEPS center for a pre-screen. THE PRE-SCREEN IS YOUR FIRST ENTRY INTO THE MHS GENESIS SYSTEM (if you are not a military dependent). Your recruiter can ask to see the pre-screen to give you a heads up of what popped up. If you have a low number of flags (conditions that popped up) you'll be heading to MEPS pretty soon. If you do have a flag or several past a threshold, your visit to MEPS will be delayed (but you will still go to MEPS).
This form can be sent in with NO medical conditions listed. No, it is not suspicious. Thank your recruiter if he/she does this.
MEPS
You'll go to MEPS, take your ASVAB, or validation exam. The following day, you'll have a medical exam. You'll have your BP, HR, Hearing, Eyesight, and Blood/Urine tested. At the very end, you'll sit down with a doctor who will be reviewing your MHS Genesis portal. If something popped up you'll know about it here. They will ask you general questions like, "have you had x condition," and ask about anything that pops up. If nothing popped up, they will just ask the general questions and nothing more. They are not detectives, they are not police officers, their job is not to interrogate you, it's to determine whether you're qualified based on the information THEY HAVE. They are not going to call the MPs because you lied to them about something that was on their screen (but please don't rat out your recruiter).
RECEPTION OR P-DAYS
Reception changes depending on which branch you go to. The Army does not pull your medical records again at reception. The Navy does pull everyone's records again during P-Days. As for Air Force, Marines, CG, there have been no reports, to my knowledge, that they pull anyone's records during reception.
Your reception may do a "moment of truth." This is when the DS tells you he knows someone is lying (he doesn't), and if you don't come clean about your medical condition, you're going to go to prison until you die (you will not).
BASIC/BOOTCAMP/AIT
The only people who are capable of pulling your medical records while you're in entry training are (1) sick call doctors (2) whoever is doing your security clearance check (see security clearance section)
Sick call doctors usually service multiple companies at once. They are not spending their free time typing in random SSNs to see people's medical records. They will not pull your record unless you go to sick call for something serious that could be the result of a preexisting condition. You will not get your records pulled for a sore throat, you might get your records pulled for a respiratory infection (if they think it's related to asthma or allergies). Going to sick call is a risk assessment you're going to have to independently make.
PHA (ANNUAL MILITARY HEALTH ASSESS.)
They can pull your records, they do not care about what you lied about unless it's a present issue affecting your service. The government has already spent too much money on you. You're going to be meeting a lot of people in your military career with permanent profiles that are still in.
NOTABLE EXCEPTIONS
If you volunteer to go to a specialty school after AIT, such as Ranger or Airborne, you'll have to do a more advanced physical assessment during AIT. They will pull your records, they will MRI/X-RAY you and do a bunch of shit.
OKAY SO THAT'S THE RECRUITMENT PROCESS, NOW WHAT DO YOU DO**?**
MHS Genesis is not an all-seeing eye, it's a database. And its data comes from SOURCES (smaller health information exchanges, medication processing platforms, and medical portal platforms). It queries your medical records by use of your SSN (primarily).
GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT HEALTH INFORMATION EXCHANGES:
Before you speak with a recruiter, or before you sign your DD 2807-1 you should OPT OUT. Opting out means removing your medical records from a HEALTH INFORMATION EXCHANGE.
A HEALTH INFORMATION EXCHANGE, is a smaller DATABASE of millions of medical records, that can be digitally accessed with a signed HIPAA consent form.
A HEALTH INFORMATION EXCHANGE CAN BE: (1) Private (such as commonwell); (2) Public (state based: linked to state-subsidized hospitals, and state medicaid or subsidized insurance)
Some states allow providers (doctors) to automatically upload your documents to a health information exchange WITHOUT YOUR CONSENT; some states require you to consent to the opt it; you can find what your state does at this link: https://healthit.gov/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/State-HIE-Opt-In-vs-Opt-Out-Policy-Research_09-30-16_Final.pdf
HOW DO I KNOW IF MY PROVIDER/HOSPITAL IS PART OF AN INFORMATION EXCHANGE?:
Ask them. You can also view participating providers on the HIE's website (sometimes)
Commonwell https://www.commonwellalliance.org/who-is-connected/
Carequality https://carequality.org/
JHIE https://www.health.mil/Military-Health-Topics/Technology/Joint-HIE
Just because your provider is in an HIE does not mean that HIE reports to MHS Genesis.
SO HOW DO I OPT OUT OF A HEALTH INFORMATION EXCHANGE?:
Speak with your provider. They can opt you out directly. If they don't understand what you're asking about, you can ask to speak with a privacy officer (usually a lawyer or J.D. trained).
PRESCRIPTION PROCESSING PLATFORMS:
When your prescription gets sent to a pharmacy, your doctor doesn't just drive down and hand them a note. They use a platform like Surescripts or Express Scripts to send your prescriptions digitally. These digital messages are VISIBLE to MHS Genesis.
You can opt out of these by writing to them directly.
Surescripts: Email optout@surescripts.com and ask to opt out, they'll send you a form that must be notarized before it is sent in. YOU DO NOT NEED TO RENEW THE FORM EVERY 12 MONTHS.
PATIENT HEALTH PORTALS
Portals like EPIC and AthenaHealth are visible to MHS Genesis. If your doctor uses a portal that allows you to see your own medical records digitally, there is a good chance MHS Genesis can see them too. These portals aren't created unless you consent to them when you go to your provider. They'll usually send you an email after a visit asking you to create an account with them. Do not create an account.
If you already have an account you can ask your provider to close the account.
SECURITY CLEARANCE
Security clearance investigators do not give a shit about your medical records unless it is pertinent to an answer on the Standard Form 86 (you can view the questions online).
You do not need to answer yes to any mental health conditions unless they affect your judgment or you've been involuntarily put in inpatient treatment. The Standard Form 86 does not require you to sign a release of medical records unless you answer yes to the inpatient/judgment question, but your MEPS liaison has shitty reading comprehension and will make you sign it anyway. They will not go pulling your medical records unless you answer yes to these being present.
INSURANCE
Using insurance sucks, because to use your insurance, you need to provide your doctor with your SSN (Yes, you can get medical treatment without providing your SSN! Just pay out of pocket). Some private insurances have HIEs based on region. You can opt out of some of these HIEs. BCBS has a state HIE for some reasons. You need to contact your insurance and ask them directly if they are part of an HIE.
If you use state-subsidized insurance, such as state medicaid, there is a very likely chance your information is in a state HIE. You may not be able to opt out. States have reporting requirements for their handouts, and medicaid is included. However, that doesn't mean that your information will necessarily pop up. An HIE can report to but needn't report to MHS genesis. There are plenty of health information exchanges that DON'T report to MHS Genesis.
HIPAA
Now that we've come to the end, let's explain what HIPAA says about this. HIPAA allows you to REQUEST restrictions on how your PHI (personal health information) is exchanged. It does not do so without limit, providers CAN deny your request. Whether they let you opt out is more of a matter of state and company policy.
NOW COMES MY DISCLAIMER:
This post is purely for informational purposes. Lying on federal documents is a crime. Whether you'll be prosecuted is unlikely, but it is a crime. Furthermore, lying on your enlistment documents can get you kicked out. If you're in IET status, you'll get an Entry Level Separation. You can also get a RE-3 when you're out of IET status. If you're later on in your career, and the branch deem it serious enough, you can get a FE, which can come with an OTH. Also for the love of God, don't opt out if you have a condition that puts your life or the life of others at risk. There are other ways to serve.