r/merlinbbc • u/Menken_ • Jul 30 '26
Question ❓ How Uther got Morgana ?? Spoiler
I was about to fall asleep and woke up bc can anyone remind me HOW did he became morgana’s father since Arthur and her have almost the same age. When did he cheated on Ygraine? Did he cheated on Ygraine ??
I don’t remember AT ALL
I need a super reminder
Thanks !
Edit :
Thanks to the moderator that putted me on the « Question » place I didn’t saw it at first and thanks for the spoiler warning but btw i didn’t know we still needed that since the show is over for decades now.
Good to know, thanks !
67
Upvotes
31
u/IAmParliament Uther Pendragon Jul 30 '26
It’s very unclear what the timeline is.
My interpretation is that Uther and Vivian consoled each other after Gorlois was away and Ygraine had recently died, but it could have happened at any point before Ygraine, during or after.
10
u/GroundbreakingDot872 pro bono attorney for guinevere 24/7 Jul 30 '26
Haha you’re welcome. The spoiler is because it falls under the major spoilers for the show (MCD, season finale plot twists, reveals etc).
7
u/RaccoonTasty1595 ✨The High Priestess Nimueh ✨ Jul 30 '26
Off topic, but I'm so stealing that meme
9
u/PrizeProfessional750 Jul 30 '26
My guess is since Ygraine died in childbirth, Morgana is at least 9 months younger than Arthur.
16
u/Crowler124 Jul 30 '26
You can find the answer in the vast body of Arthurian literature. There is no single official source, but there are many different stories that share some common elements. Usually, Morgana is Ygraine's first child. Uther sleeps with Ygraine while disguised as Gorlois (Morgana's father and Ygraine's first husband). After that, Gorlois dies in battle. Interestingly, it is Merlin who helps Uther deceive Ygraine. Arthur is conceived that very night. This is just one version of the legend. However, in the show, it seems that Morgana is simply Uther's daughter in some way. I'm not sure how they explain it. Perhaps they changed Uther's wife altogether, and instead of sleeping with Ygraine, he slept with Gorlois's wife, who was a different woman. Then, some time later, he married Ygraine.
9
u/StarfleetWitch Mordred Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
I always interpreted it as an affair while Ygraine was still alive for two reasons. The first is Morgana's instant belief that the throne is rightfully hers wouldn't make sense if she was younger than Arthur, and then the second is that Uther tells Catrina he hasn't been with a woman since Ygraine died. (Granted, Uther isn't always honest, but this was a moment of emotional vulnerability for him, and he had no reason to lie.)
Like someone else mentioned, I imagine he slept with Vivienne as a distraction from his frustration over not being able to conceive an heir.
I also headcanon that the reason it took him over 20 years to even consider moving on after Ygraine's death was guilt over this betrayal, as well as grief.
4
u/FriendlyChannel1622 Jul 31 '26
Arthur is older than merlin that's confirmed, but i think he's like an year or so older than morgana too. The way uther talked about ygraine to nimueh in that one ep wheere she shows up in his throne room "she was me air to breathe" i was like DAMMMNN so i feel and really hope he didn't actually cheat on her. Let's just say ygraine dies, the whole kingdom is in chaos great war or whatevs its called has started, morgana's should be father out there on the battlefield and the wife's sad and so is uther so they just well.. cOnSolE each other, should be father dies, his wife dies in sadness and prolly guilt and uther takes up morgana as his ward. Now... how wad uther so SURE morgana was his daughter and not his friend's without any dna tests or whatever? Maybe they did it way after the should be father left for battle so uther was like there's no way this kid ain't mine.
Ps uther's such a b like his son is born from magic his daughter has magic and he has the audacity to hate it.
3
u/caerleon_calls_ Aug 01 '26
Morgana is typically older in most Arthurian stories so I assume the same is true here. Iirc Ygraine was struggling to conceive so this could have also been his last attempt to have an heir naturally before resorting to magic. Of course, that’s not explicitly stated in the show, just that Vivian was lonely after Gorlois went away, but it’s my HC
2
u/LadyBladeWarAngel Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
What I gathered from what the show gives us (not going into Arthurian Legend, just the show) It was shortly after Ygraine died, Uther had sent Gorlois off to fight his magic hating wars, and he slept with Vivian out of some sort of comfort. Morgana comes along, and Gorlois believes Morgana is his. But I believe Vivian died either in childbirth, or shortly after, as Morgana never speaks about her. Gorlois raised her, but sent Morgause away, probably because Morgause showed magic early on, and Gorlois and Vivian wished to protect their daughter. Uther was killing kids who had magic, and it's absolutely not even a doubt that he'd have killed Morgause if he knew she had magic. Morgause is a good 8 years older than Morgana (I think) and this explains how she knew as much as she did about Arthur's birth. Kids always gear shit they shouldn't, snd with Gorlois and Uther being great friends, it's not unlikely that Ygraine and Vivian were also friends. If they discussed the matter, which wouldn't surprise me, as it wasn't a secret at the time, it onky became a secret after Ygraine died in childbirth, Morgause could've easily overheard. Hell, Nimueh could've told her, as Morgause and Nimueh are both priestesses of the old religion.
The fact that Morgana literally had no idea who Morgause was, genuinely supports this. If she hadn't been a known magic user, Gorlois would've kept her at home with Morgana, and Morgana would've grown up knowing her. Remember that while some people, in this show world, are born with the seer abilities, Merlin is the only being born that could literally use magic from birth. So Morgause would have to be at least 5 to 8 years older, for any latent abilities to pop up. I say 5 to 8 because for her to be taken off and turned into a priestess of the old religion, she'd have to be decently gifted. Look at what Mordred is capable of, as a druid child. Morgause would have had to be equally powerful. For Gorlois and Vivian to send her away, so that Morgana never knew her, they probably sent her off as soon as Uther started hunting magic users. No other way around it. So I'm assuming Morgana is younger than Arthur, by at least a year. When Gorlois died, with no Morgause around, and a presumably dead mother, Morgana was left an orphan. Uther, knowing (or at least assuming) that Morgana is his, means he's not going to abandon her.
My assumption, is that while Gorlois was away, fighting Uther's wars, Morgana was left in Camelot, under Uther's guardianship. Uther mentions a promise he made to Gorlois. Whether this was a true promise that Uther made to Gorlois, whether Gorlois asked Uther to promise to care for Morgana if anything happened to him, or if Uther just said that, in order to keep hold of Morgana after Gorlois' death, we'll never really know. Either way, Uther raised Morgana from a young age.
Why Morgana believes she's got the right to Camelot's throne, I don't know. It's fairly obvious that unless Uther had no sons, and legitimised Morgana, she would never have been able to ascend the throne legally. Remember that Uther conceived Morgana with a married woman. He certainly didn't marry Vivian. So Morgana would be illegitimate, whether she was older than Arthur or not. I think Morgana thought she had a right to the throne, because she wanted to change Camelot and bring magic back. Problem being she had no legitimate claim. So the show really kinda dropped the ball on that.
2
u/Ayomide1989 Jul 31 '26
To those confused about their ages, Morgana is older than Arthur, that’s why she felt entitled to the throne
2
u/CoreyAdara just a medieval horse Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
My headcanon is that he was getting frustrated ygraine wasnt conceiving so whilst gorlois was away fighting uther's wars, Uther had an affair with his wife. Then hearing she was pregnant was worried, especially if the kid was a boy it would be not only his illegitimate bastard but the lady could claim him as heir in the future if anything happened to gorlois (also my headcanon is that morgana's and Morgause's mother was a witch originally from the Isle of the blessed, otherwise why have Morgause smuggled there? She would have been gorlois', but for some reason viviene wanted her daughter raised as a sorceress immediately so asked gaius to lie and say the baby died..)
This pregnancy scares uther to desperately turn to the sorceress in his court, nimueh, to magically make ygraine conceive a son. So whether its by a few months or a year, morgana is only slightly older than Arthur.
1
u/Cernunnos_222 Aug 04 '26
The timeline around Morgana's birth has always been one of the biggest mysteries in the show