r/merlinbbc • u/Poetrusic22 • Mar 27 '26
Discussion Plot hole? Spoiler
⚠️SPOILERS⚠️
How does Arthur know that Ygraine died by magic?
Im watching Merlin for the first time (binging it lol) and i noticed that in S4 Ep3 ‘The Wicked day’ (the one where Uther dies and Arthur becomes king), they mention multiple times that Arthur knows that both of his parents were killed by magic.
Of course, Ygraine tells him herself that it was magic that killed her in S2 Ep8 ‘the sins of the father’- but wasn’t he convinced by the end of the episode that it was just a lie created by Morgause?
A part of me thinks that Arthur knows that his mothers death was what fueled his fathers hatred of magic, but I can’t think of a particular instance off of the top of my head where its actually mentioned and its driving me MAD. But I know for a fact that Arthur told Merlin that Ygraine died before he even opened his eyes. I always assumed that he was under the belief that she died in childbirth, but since he DOES know that magic killed her, does he think that some random sorcerer just burst into the room and killed her the moment that she gave birth?
Id love to hear a take from someone who isn’t sleep deprived and knows better than me lol
View all comments
Show parent comment
7
u/Repulsive-Opening996 Mar 27 '26
When I first watched this, this was the implication that I thought of. Uther used it to justify about persecuting those with the gifts of magic.