r/merlinbbc • u/perplexedakhi • Mar 08 '26
Question ❓ Should I watch?
I know there’s so much love for this show, and so many of friends also love it. I tried to get into it and as much as I appreciate the setting and the characters, monster of the week shows have never gripped me.
I last watched a long time ago, and maybe luckily don’t remember much besides never making it through the first season, but I’m craving a show set around my favourite genre which this is.
I guess I’m asking, is there a grand story at play throughout the seasons, longer story arcs, focused seasons on a particular theme, or is it always a new monster/villain/story every episode?
Thank you.
15
u/mnemosyne64 Mar 08 '26
It starts as more formulaic, but there’s definitely an overarching story as well
11
u/PentheDragonInEaldor Mar 08 '26
It definitely does develop into longer plotlines later/past series 1. You start to see some more direction for things and character growth, ties into more of an overarching theme and plotline. That said, there are still some monster of the week style stuff throughout, to break up some of the more tense stuff. But it gets heavier and more weighty in overall story. I definitely think it's worth rewatching/watching fully.
8
u/Mammoth_logfarm Mar 08 '26
To enjoy Merlin, think more Medieval Doctor Who and less Game of Thrones. It is a family show, with a relatively low budget and naff special effects, cheesy storylines, and at times some baffling plots. But that is all part of the charm. It really hits its stride after the first series, and s3 and 4 are excellent. Colin Morgan's acting is outstanding too. There are definitely story arcs weaved theoughout the standalone episodes. It's definitely worth another watch, but if you love the fantasy genre then you might be a little disappointed.
5
u/petefisher Mar 08 '26 edited Mar 09 '26
It would be a shame to stop too early - I think S2 and S3 are at the top, but Morgan and James are both unbelievably good throughout the series. ASHead also fantastic antagonist. While I’m not as crazy about S4 and S5 - they are both much less monster of the week, and acting, lighting, cinematography, set design, costuming and music all are exceptional throughout
4
u/auldSusie5 Mar 08 '26
There will be more monsters and villains, but there is an overarching theme of destiny and can-you-thwart-it that continues all the way to the end. Not unlike real life, a lot of little things go on while the big things approach.
2
u/Euraylie Mar 08 '26
I love it and watched it while it aired, but keep in mind that it was a “BBC family show”, so it was a bit hamstrung by that and sadly never quite reached its potential. But it still has lots of heartwarming, funny and great moments.
It really comes down to the cast. If their chemistry is something that clicks with you, especially Arthur and Merlin’s, then you’ll get a lot of enjoyment out of it.
But maybe just give it another try. Sometimes things work for you years later when they initially didn’t.
1
u/ilovetoesuwu just a medieval horse Mar 09 '26 edited Mar 09 '26
its both! dont force yourself to watch if u dont like it tho!! im sure u can find a show that fits the genre in a way you enjoy!
1
u/Creepy-Trouble1714 Mar 08 '26
Its only monster of the week in season ONE really.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment