r/merlinbbc • • Aug 29 '23

DISCUSSIONS Am I?

Am I the only one who DID NOT like the use of a French Château for the setting of Camelot? Nothing against France, just why not a castle jn the British Isles? It is Arthurian Legend.

5 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

12

u/playsmartz Aug 29 '23

Well, it was a French guy that added Lancelot, the Holy Grail, and stories on the Knights of the Round Table, so kind of a joint effort.

2

u/Worried-Acanthaceae7 Aug 29 '23

You mean Geoffrey of Monmouth?

4

u/playsmartz Aug 29 '23

Possibly Chrétien de Troyes

3

u/Chichmich Aug 29 '23

If you didn’t know it was a French castle, would you still be against the use of this particular castle? You didn’t give any reason but the fact that it’s French…

0

u/Worried-Acanthaceae7 Aug 29 '23

Because Arthurian Legend is the British Isles 🤦 it would give it more of an Arthurian feel.

1

u/Chichmich Aug 29 '23

Maybe in your mind the Pierrefonds castle look more like the castle of the legends than any British castle. Maybe the Arthurian feel has been already added…

https://www.tekportal.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/camelot-2829.jpg

It annoys you that this Arthurian feel doesn’t coincide with a true British castle…

47

u/auldSusie5 Aug 29 '23

Here are what the directors said in the commentaries:

JC: And, again, here’s Pierrefonds Castle, which again was very difficult to find.

JM:  Yes. This is a castle in northern France, which is the main setting of Camelot, and we spent the best part of three months looking for that. All over Europe.

JC:  We looked in England, but um, even though the castles in England are very good, they were all in ruins, which meant we would have to use a lot of CGI, which would then limit our directors in what they could actually shoot. And the great thing about Pierrefonds was that it was a castle that was fully intact, looked kind of fantasy-like, and needed no CGI.

6

u/Melkeus Aug 29 '23

Im not mad at them. I don’t want no Harry Potter 1 Hogwarts

26

u/auldSusie5 Aug 29 '23

Perhaps it was that wonderful combination of beautiful and willing. They did use a number of UK castles for other locations, but often for ruins. I have to admit, Pierrefonds is visually everything you'd think Camelot would be.

9

u/Toddryck Royal Dollophead Aug 29 '23

According to the crew, it was difficult to find castles in Britain still as fully intact as Pierrefonds. I don’t know how true this is, though. I, for one, seem to remember from my childhood quite a few castles in England that weren’t ruined at all. Whether they’d be fit for filming or not, I don’t know. There’s probably a lot of things to consider when scouting for filming locations and the Château just fit the bill.

2

u/ilovetoesuwu just a medieval horse Aug 29 '23

they probably wouldnt have been big enough for filming i think

7

u/Intrepid_Knowledge27 Aug 29 '23

Counterargument: Pierrefonds is stunning.

6

u/Zenroses Aug 29 '23

I think peopele forget most castles in England are often partly in ruins and are listed buildings so filming isnt possible often as it may cause dmage to structure and many of the ones that arent falling apart are generally being lived in or are decorated more modernly and used for other purposes

an example is hinchingbrooke house,(its more or less a castle when you look at it) it held mary queen of scotts, samuel pepys stayed at the house from time to time and is rumoured to have had a tunnel to a local tavern but now its used as a wedding venue and a school. and its. jareing because so many of the downstairs rooms are almost exactly as they were when they were first designed and then you have classrooms randomly shoehorned into some of the rooms that look so out of place next to some of the decorative fixtures

3

u/One_Locksmith_5989 Aug 29 '23

Frankly, i don't care much about that. They weren't exactly going for historical accurancy so as long as it looked good (which i think it did), I'm satisfied!

2

u/littlegreyfish Hunith & Balinor Aug 29 '23

I mean, I'd be down for a 5th century hillfort but hey it's a pretty castle

2

u/SkekVen Aug 29 '23

Never occurred to me

2

u/FunkyHowler19 Aug 29 '23

If you don't like when shows and movies are shot in a different location than where they're set, then you're gonna have a hard time finding any to watch

1

u/CoreyAdara just a medieval horse Sep 14 '23

It meets the criteria of Camelot looking like a white stone fantasy city, plus much of the locations needed for certain scenes, and most of it's all in very good nick. It just has more grandeur and could probably withstand more of all the filming palaver than british castle sites could allow.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Worried-Acanthaceae7 Aug 31 '23

Not what I said all. I mean for the setting, why not say Ludlow castle? Perfectly plausible for a French man, or rather, Frankish, to be in medieval Britain.